The Inquisitors
MS 1540.29 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Inquisitors are the investigative body of the Tower, charged with convening formal inquiries into alleged violations of established protocols and with adjudicating the questions those inquiries raise. They are the only office whose writ runs the full vertical extent of the building, and the only office empowered to compel the production of a floor. Membership is never stated in full; the Inquisitorial Roll is sealed, recopied each decade by hand, and consulted only by the Keeper of the Roll, a post presently held by no one, the last holder having retired into the east stack in 461.
Composition and the pool
Inquisitors are not recruited directly. They are drawn from a pool of senior practitioners — Archivists of the Archivist Cadre, Curators of the Curatorial Guild, and Verification Officers — and named to a panel by the presiding officer of the Third Concordance for the duration of a single inquest. The arrangement is meant to prevent an investigative class from forming. It has not prevented one, but it has kept the class small enough to be seated at one table.
Service is compulsory and unpaid. A senior Archivist summoned to a panel in the winter may find the summons delivered eleven years after it was written, since the Central Index files them by floor of destination rather than by date. Dame Ollivane Tress, an Archivist of the ninth bank, received her summons in 468 for an inquest that had concluded in 459, and attended anyway, on the grounds that the summons had not been rescinded.
The Inquest Mandate
The body's standing authority derives from the Inquest Mandate (88-), which confers on the Inquisitors the right to mandate an inquest, to preside over its proceedings, and to require the production of any record, landing, or apparatus named in the writ. Clause 9 of the Mandate is the operative one and is quoted in nearly every procedural dispute in the archive:
"That the Inquisitors may demand the landing be produced, and it shall be produced, and the manner of its producing shall be recorded by a clerk appointed for the purpose and not by the Inquisitor demanding it."
— Inquest Mandate (88-), Clause 9
The final clause has caused more difficulty than any other provision of Tower law. Inquisitors have repeatedly held that they may not record their own proceedings; clerks appointed for the purpose have repeatedly been unavailable; and the resulting gaps in the record have furnished grounds for appeal in at least forty-one cases. The Protocol Inquests remain the standard form, though their procedures are amended by Concordance 17 more often than they are performed.
Findings, and the matter of floor 2,208
The Inquisitors are frequent filers of Provenance Challenges, since their methods tend to uncover several competing ownership paths for a single object where one had been supposed to exist. It was on precisely this ground that they audited floor 2,208 in the winter of 468 and demanded the landing be produced. The landing was produced. It was then produced a second time, from a different stair, by a different clerk, and in a condition the audit had not anticipated. Whether the floor possesses one landing or two has never been settled; the Inquisitors issued no finding, and the 468 file remains open under the designation 2,208 (Landing, Doubtful).
The audit is remembered chiefly for the dissent of Inquisitor Halvard Rusk, who argued in a minority opinion of nine pages that a floor required to produce its landing ought to be told in advance which landing is meant. Rusk's opinion was not adopted. It has since been cited approvingly in every challenge to the Mandate, and Rusk himself has asked that it stop being cited.
Disputes and jurisdiction
The Inquisitors' jurisdiction is contested on two fronts. The Bureau of Architectural Integrity maintains that anything structural — landings, stairwells, the load-bearing capacity of a reading room — falls to the Bureau, and that an Inquisitor standing on a disputed landing is a trespasser. The Inquisitors hold that the manner of producing a thing is their business and the thing itself the Bureau's, a division of labour the Bureau has never accepted in writing.
The second dispute is quieter and older. The Bureau of Coincidental Resonance has argued since 402 that certain inquests generate resonance sufficient to disturb the catalogue itself, and that Inquisitors ought to submit their writs for damping before issuance. The Adjunct Office of Resonance Damping was created to arbitrate this claim and has instead absorbed it, and it is now ordinary practice for an Inquisitor to consult the Adjunct Office before compelling a landing, though no instrument requires it.
Scholarly disagreement
Whether the Inquisitors are a standing body or a convening one is unresolved and matters a great deal. Concordance 44, Annex Δ treats them as a permanent office with a continuous existence, its members merely absent between inquests; Protocol Inquests treats each panel as dissolved upon its finding, its members returned to their Cadres, Guilds, and Offices. The practical difference is the sealed Roll. If the Inquisitors are permanent, the Roll is a membership list and its loss in 461 is a catastrophe. If they are convening, the Roll is only a record of service, and its loss is an inconvenience.
The Keeper's chair has been empty for seven years, and no one has proposed filling it. The Inquisitors themselves decline to comment on the question, on the grounds that the manner of their commenting would have to be recorded by a clerk, and no clerk has been appointed.
Recorded holdings
The following materials are held in the Inquisitorial annex and may be consulted by written application:
- Inquest Mandate (88-), fair copy and three recensions
- Protocol Inquests, bound, 388–469
- File 2,208 (Landing, Doubtful), open
- Rusk, H., minority opinion, nine pages, uncited by leave of the author, 468
- Inquisitorial Roll, 461 — not held; presumed lost
Application for the minority opinion is refused.
See also
-
MS 3240.43
Adjudication of Taxonomic Violations
The Adjudication of Taxonomic Violations constitutes the formal process by which breaches of established classification and catalo…
-
MS 3774.55
Standard Verification Protocols
Standard Verification Protocols are the established means by which the foundational assumptions of formal inquiries are themselves…
-
MS 5508.37
Inquest of the Whispering Atlas
Inquest of the Whispering Atlas refers to two distinct but related formal inquiries conducted by Librarian Inquisitors of the Thir…
-
MS 7809.13
Committee on Nominative Distinction
The Committee on Nominative Distinction is a standing administrative body established under Seventh Concordance, Clause 12, charge…
-
MS 5280.01
Ad Hoc Inquisitorial Protocols
The Ad Hoc Inquisitorial Protocols constitute a foundational, though superseded, body of procedural law appended to the Third Conc…
-
MS 4607.30
Class Beta Causal Violations
Class Beta Causal Violations is a designation applied to holdings whose recorded disposition precedes, exceeds, or otherwise fails…
Referenced by
- MS 4482.30 Resonance Damping
Readers also asked
Archivist Cadre: who are they?
The Archivist Cadre is a specialized tier of professional custodians within the Office of the Archivist, responsible for the direct physical oversight, custody, and chain-of-possession verification for classified or mate…
Archivist CadreConcordance 17: what does it set out?
Concordance 17, often styled "The Obsolescence," is a foundational document of Tower administration, formally enacted on the 17th day of the Unnamed Month in the Year of the Locked Shelf. Its primary and enduring functio…
Concordance 17Archivists: how is it conducted?
Archivists constitute a broad occupational class within the Tower, defined under Concordance 12, Clause 7 as "any person or collective formally engaged in the classification, maintenance, or expansion of the holdings." T…
ArchivistsProvenance Challenges: how is it conducted?
Provenance Challenges are formal, procedural objections filed with the Office of Provenance contesting the established or asserted history of a holding within the Tower’s archives. These challenges are the primary mechan…
Provenance ChallengesPassages cited from this record
-
That the Inquisitors may demand the landing be produced, and it shall be produced, and the manner of its producing shall be recorded by a clerk appointed for the purpose and not by the Inquisitor demanding it.
Inquest Mandate (88-), Clause 9
Because you consulted