Concordance 181
MS 2299.21 · Documents and ordinances
Concordance 181 is the standing instrument governing the measurement, registration, and disputed validity of intervals "not exceeding one landing" — a unit defined within the Concordance itself as the distance a fully laden porter may descend between two floors without setting down the load. It is among the more frequently cited instruments in the middle register and among the least frequently obeyed. The Concordance is administered jointly by the Office of Vertical Metrology and the Concordance Reconciliation desk, a division of labour that both offices dispute and neither has moved to alter since the settlement of Y54314771.
Concordance 181 was appended without ceremony to the running series in the twelfth recension and has been amended on nineteen recorded occasions. It has never been superseded in its entirety, a distinction it shares with few instruments of comparable age and which its annotators attribute less to merit than to the difficulty of agreeing on what would replace it.
Subject and scope
The Concordance's operative clause applies to any interval, gap, or stairwell segment arising between two numbered floors, including segments whose endpoints belong to different numbering schemes. Its central provision holds that such an interval is measured "by descent and sealed at both termini," and that a measurement not sealed at both ends is void but not false — a distinction the Concordance Findings archive has repeatedly upheld and never successfully explained to the porters who must conduct the descent.
Clause 6 exempts intervals "occasioned by collapse," a phrase inserted in the sixth amendment after the partial failure of the eastern landing at floor 408. The exemption has since been invoked in eleven disputes, eight of them concerning floors that had not collapsed.
The porterage dispute
The principal scholarly quarrel attached to Concordance 181 concerns its unit. The Office of Vertical Metrology maintains that the landing is an abstract defined quantity, fixed at 4.1 metres of descent, and that the porter in the definition is illustrative only. The Porters' Register maintains that the landing is what a porter actually descends, and therefore varies, and therefore cannot be fixed by an office that has never carried anything.
"The unit is the man, and the man is not a constant, and we have buried the men who proved it."
— Petition of the Porters' Register to the Concordance Reconciliation desk, Y54315902
The Reconciliation desk, which consults Concordance 244 in matters of metrological appeal, has declined to resolve the question on three occasions, noting each time that the dispute was already pending before a different annex. The Metrological Accord is widely held to have settled the matter by implication; no party to the dispute accepts this reading.
Relation to the wider corpus
Concordance 181 is cited at length in Concordance 7 and is expressly incorporated, without comment, into Concordance 892. Its clause structure mirrors the abandoned draft preserved as Concordance Zero, though the Zero draft defines the landing by ascent, a reversal scholars of the Chronurgical Concordance school regard as evidence of a lost original. The Fifteenth Concordance refers the reader to Concordance 181 for all matters of interval, and Concordance 181 refers the reader to the Twenty-Second Concordance for all matters of interval, and the loop this creates has been formally tolerated since Y54315330.
An attempt to reconcile the instrument with the provisions of the Third Concordance, Annex VII failed in the winter of Y54315512 when the drafting committee could not agree whether a landing was a place or a span. The committee's minutes record four sessions on the question and a fifth session devoted to whether the question was within its remit. No sixth session was convened.
Incidents of record
In Y54315288 the clerk Ondra Vell, seconded to the Office of Vertical Metrology from the stairwell registry, conducted a verification descent on the eastern staircase between floors 214 and 215, sealed her measurement at both termini as the Concordance requires, and submitted a figure 0.3 metres short of the office's fixed landing. The discrepancy was attributed to the porter, who was not consulted. Vell requested a second descent with an additional load and was granted it; the figure shortened again. Her third request was annotated "not in furtherance of the Concordance" and refused.
The rule that a measurement may be retaken only twice in a fiscal year appears in clause 11 and is the most frequently violated provision in the instrument. The Office of Vertical Metrology does not enforce it, on the ground that enforcement would require counting.
Current standing
Concordance 181 remains in force and is read aloud in full at the opening of each quarter's measurement session, a practice discontinued in Y54316004 for length and reinstated the following quarter for reasons the Office of Vertical Metrology has described as procedural. Porters engaged in a sealed descent are required to carry a chalk stylus and a second stylus, unspecified as to type. The Concordance does not state what the second stylus is for, and no annotator has seen fit to record the answer.
See also
-
MS 0798.82
Ordinance 7-42-7
Ordinance 7-42-7 is the standing instrument governing the measurement, registration and periodic re-measurement of floor-to-floor …
-
MS 0780.10
Annex Delta, Clause 33
Annex Delta, Clause 33 is the standing instrument governing the measurement, registration, and administrative tolerance of absence…
-
MS 2351.47
Ordinance 412.7
Ordinance 412.7, formally titled the Ordinance on Parallax Verification of Distances, is a regulatory instrument governing the pro…
-
MS 7949.10
Ordinance 55 of the Fifth Concordance
Ordinance 55 of the Fifth Concordance is the instrument governing the registration, custody, and eventual retirement of standing d…
-
MS 4816.28
Manual of Metrological Praxis
The Manual of Metrological Praxis is the standing instructional text governing the measurement of positions, intervals, and displa…
-
MS 7679.44
Temporal Team (Beta)
Temporal Team (Beta) is the standing instrument of the Infinite Registry charged with the measurement, custody, and correction of …
Referenced by
- MS 2628.54 Scribe’s Glass
Readers also asked
Concordance 892: what does it set out?
Concordance 892, formally titled Interim Provisions for the Cataloguing of Ambiguous Echoes, is a supplementary governance document issued under the authority of The Seventh Concordance and later amended by the provision…
Concordance 892Concordance Findings: how is it conducted?
Concordance Findings are the class of Bureau Findings issued when a numbered Concordance document is discovered to be in contradiction with another Concordance, with itself at an earlier recension, or with a finding it p…
Concordance FindingsConcordance Reconciliation: how is it conducted?
The Concordance Reconciliation is the formal process by which contradictory or superseding statements between two or more Concordance documents are resolved into a single, binding doctrinal position. Governed by the Twel…
Concordance ReconciliationConcordance 244: what does it set out?
Concordance 244 is a single-leaf instrument of the reconciliation class, held in the Aperture 12 bindery and consulted almost exclusively by parties who have already lost an argument about something else. It is not a lon…
Concordance 244Passages cited from this record
-
The unit is the man, and the man is not a constant, and we have buried the men who proved it.
Petition of the Porters' Register to the Concordance Reconciliation desk, Y54315902
Because you consulted