The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 144

MS 8454.60 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance 144 is the standing instrument governing the custody, measurement, and periodic re-issuance of narrow-gauge stairwells between Floor 1188 and Floor 1201, together with all landings, niches, and intermediate half-floors contained therein. It is unusual among the Concordances in that it has never been formally superseded; it has instead been "held over" by every subsequent instrument that might have replaced it, a status the Concordance Reconciliation desk describes as "provisional but binding" (Memorandum of the Reconciliation Desk, series D, folio 61).

Origin and the Stairwell Question

Concordance 144 was promulgated in the aftermath of the so-called Stairwell Question, a dispute concerning whether the half-landings between Floors 1193 and 1194 were to be counted as floor-space or as vertical circulation. The distinction mattered: floor-space fell under the survey of the Concordance Amendment Tracking registry, while circulation answered to the older metrological offices entrenched by the Metrological Accord. Neither body wished to assume the count, and for a period of nine years the twelve half-landings were recorded by no one, save in the private notebooks of a stair-clerk named Havrel Onn, whose figures were not admitted as evidence because they had been kept in pencil.

Concordance 144 resolved the matter by declining to resolve it. Its second clause assigns the half-landings to "whichever survey shall next present itself," a formula that has functioned without interruption for the whole of its life. The Concordance Reconciliation has twice noted the elegance of this arrangement; it has also twice noted that no survey has ever presented itself.

Provisions

The Concordance runs to fourteen clauses and three annexes. Its first clause fixes the gauge of the stairwells at forty-one and one-quarter inches between handrail centres, with a tolerance of one-eighth inch, and provides that any stairwell falling outside tolerance be "designated, not repaired" — a provision that has produced a long inventory of slightly-too-narrow stairs, each carrying a designation tag and no other remedy.

The fourth clause concerns lighting and is frequently cited out of context. It requires that each landing be lit "sufficiently for the reading of a medium-sized hand," and it is on the strength of this clause alone that the Fifteenth Concordance later asserted primacy over the entire stairwell. The claim was not accepted. It was, however, never formally rejected, and Clause Four remains the most litigated single sentence in the narrow-gauge holdings.

The seventh clause establishes the office of Stair Warden, an appointment held concurrently with the wardenship of Floor 1197 and carrying no stipend. The office has changed hands forty-one times since promulgation, generally by inheritance among three families who no longer contest the matter. Clause Nine prohibits the storage of anything on a half-landing overnight, with the single exception of a bucket, which may remain if it is empty.

Held-Over Status and the Disputed Repeal

Scholars disagree sharply on whether Concordance 144 was repealed in the winter of the year recorded as Y54315445. The Twenty-Second Concordance contains a schedule listing instruments "to be retired upon reconciliation," and Concordance 144 appears on that schedule as item 19. The Twenty-Third Concordance does not carry the schedule forward. The Ninth Concordance is silent entirely. The Seventh Concordance, which touches the stairwells only obliquely, was retroactively reconciled with The Fifth Concordance under Concordance Update Y54315445, and that event — being the last general reconciliation on record — is held by some to have carried the schedule into effect by implication.

The prevailing view, maintained by the Reconciliation desk and by the compiler of the Chronurgical Concordance, is that Concordance 144 survives because no instrument has ever named a successor. Writing on the question, the archivist of Floor 1201 observed that "a Concordance is not repealed by being disliked, nor by being listed, nor by being forgotten; it is repealed by being replaced, and this one has had the good fortune to be irreplaceable" (Third Concordance, Annex VII, marginal commentary, folio 4).

A minority position, associated with the survey registry on Floor 1188, holds that Concordance 144 lapsed entirely on the day the schedule was published and that its continued citation is a clerical habit masquerading as law. The registry has nonetheless complied with every one of its clauses without interruption, which the Reconciliation desk has described as "the sincerest form of jurisprudence."

The Onn Grievance

The Concordance's most durable controversy is not legal but personal. In the year following promulgation, Havrel Onn petitioned for recognition of the nine years of half-landing counts he had kept in pencil, arguing that Concordance 144's silence on the interim period left his records as the only continuous account. The petition was refused on the ground that the Concordance, by declining to count, had established that no count was required — and that Onn's industry, however sustained, had been "in aid of a question the instrument had already answered by not asking it" (Ruling of the Reconciliation Desk, series D, folio 63).

Onn was thereafter appointed Stair Warden under Clause Seven and served in that capacity for thirty years. His grievance is preserved in the registry as a standing item, re-entered each year in the same hand, and is the oldest unresolved appeal in the narrow-gauge holdings. It is read aloud at the opening of each survey. No survey attends.

Current Custody

The original instrument is held on Floor 1200, in a cabinet bolted to the wall of the upper landing, the stairwell being by its own terms too narrow to admit the cabinet otherwise. Access requires the presence of the Stair Warden and one witness from the Concordance Findings office. The seal is intact. The bucket is empty.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Metrological Accord: what does it set out?

The Metrological Accord is the collective designation for four Concordance instruments — Concordance 44, Concordance 44-A, Concordance 44-B and the so-called Quiet Recension — by which the Tower purports to reconcile the…

Metrological Accord
Concordance Findings: how is it conducted?

Concordance Findings are the class of Bureau Findings issued when a numbered Concordance document is discovered to be in contradiction with another Concordance, with itself at an earlier recension, or with a finding it p…

Concordance Findings
Concordance Update Y54315445: what does it set out?

Concordance Update Y54315445 is a 712-page amending instrument that formalized a post hoc reconciliation between The Fifth Concordance and The Seventh Concordance. Enacted during the 88th Survey Window of the 15,432nd Ca…

Concordance Update Y54315445
Concordance 23: what does it set out?

Concordance 23, also formally designated as Concordance XXIII or the Spiral Concordance, is the official governing document for Floors 14–19 and the attendant auxiliary stacks collectively known as the Whorl. It was prom…

Concordance 23
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.