Citation of Contingent Action
MS 8011.70 · Practices and doctrines
The Citation of Contingent Action is a procedural instrument by which an act that has not yet been performed is cited as though performed, for the limited purpose of establishing standing in an administrative proceeding. Its defining feature is that the citation does not assert that the action occurred, only that its occurrence is sufficiently foreseeable to warrant a citation number. The instrument is administered under the Citation Protocols by the Office of Reciprocal Citation and is distinct from a Binding Citation in that nothing is bound; the citation is issued, logged, and left open against a future. The form was devised on the Fourteenth Recension Floor in the winter of the year recorded as 4,112 by the Tower's internal calendar, following a dispute over whether a stairwell closure could be challenged before the closure took effect. The Concordance on Standing and Antecedent Harm (Concordance 77, Annex 2) answered in the negative; Concordance 77, Annex 3, drafted eleven days later by an overlapping committee, answered in the affirmative and was the version entered into the register. Both annexes remain in force.
Form and issue
A Citation of Contingent Action is issued on a two-part slip. The upper part, the declared, names the action as it would be named if performed. The lower part, the reserved, is left blank until such time as the action is performed or abandoned, at which point a clerk of the Office of Reciprocal Citation strikes the citation through or seals it complete. Approximately one in six slips is never completed, the action having been abandoned without notice. These are held in the Unstruck Drawer on the same floor and may not be consulted except by Librarians.
The citation confers standing only. It does not confer a right of appeal, an entitlement to notice, or any expectation that the action will in fact occur. It may not be issued for an action whose performance would itself require a citation to authorize it — a recursion forbidden under Circular Citation — though the boundary between the two has been litigated at least nine times, most recently in the matter of the halted lift inspection on the Sixteenth Ascending Court.
Slips are filed with the date of issue and the date foreseen. Where the foreseen date passes without the action, the citation lapses and must be reissued; reissue is free of charge for the first lapse only.
Relation to provisional and secondary subjects
The instrument is frequently confused with the machinery of Provisional Subjects, whose existence is similarly contingent. The distinction is one of what is contingent. A provisional subject waits upon an administrative action or an unfulfilled condition; a cited contingent action waits upon nothing but the actor. The Contextualist School has argued, in its 4,208 paper On the Standing of the Standing, that the two are differentiable only within the frame in which the citation is read, and that a reader outside that frame would see a single class. The Office of Reciprocal Citation has not adopted the paper but has not refuted it either, which the School regards as a concession and the Office regards as a filing.
Secondary Verity classification is not extended to contingent actions, on the ground that an action foreseen in a citation has no existence to be secondary. A proposal to grant such actions a provisional SV status was tabled in 4,215 and remains tabled.
Scholarly disagreement
The principal dispute concerns whether a Citation of Contingent Action is available in proceedings under the Writ of Contingent Supersession. Concordance 91 (Annexes 1–4) restricts contingent holdings to documents, and its commentary of 3,988 states flatly that "the Writ addresses holdings, not deeds, and a deed foreseen is not a holding" — Concordance 91, Commentary, clause 6. Concordance 94, drafted in the same decade and concerned with the Contingent Stacks, refers without qualification to "contingent holdings and the acts that create them," which the Commission on Deferred Acts has read since 4,090 as including cited contingent actions.
Where the two Concordances are cited against one another, practice has settled on the rule that the earlier number governs unless the later is annexed to a floor in which the proceeding is physically held. The rule is not written down anywhere and is followed without exception.
Restrictions and incidents
A Citation of Contingent Action may not be issued by the party who foresees the action. It must be issued by a party with an interest in the action's performance, and at least one party to every citation must be capable of performing the action without instruction from another. In practice this means the slip is signed by whoever will do the thing, where doing the thing is defined widely enough to include deciding not to. Clerks have complained that this makes the signature a formality and the formality the substance, most memorably Clerk Ameline Vorth, whose 4,301 memorandum On Signing for a Thing One Has Not Done was returned unopened on the ground that it was itself a contingent action.
In 4,266 a run of four hundred slips was issued on the Seventh Adjustment Floor foreclosing actions that had already occurred, on the reasoning that a thing once done can always be cited as pending. The run was voided. The issuing clerk, Halm Berrick, was reassigned to the Index of Antecedent Regrets and completed his service there without incident. His four hundred slips are preserved as an appendix to the Index and are cited in teaching.
Citations are not issued during the interval between the ringing of the third bell and the sealing of the day's register. The interval is eleven minutes. Nothing may be filed during it, and the practice of presenting slips at the bell is treated as an attempt at Simulated Citation Mapping and refused.
See also
See also
-
MS 5935.84
Contradictory Citation
A Contradictory Citation is a formal citation within the Tower’s documentation that, when ratified, retroactively alters the valid…
-
MS 3356.47
Procedural Adherence
Procedural Adherence is the doctrine and administrative practice holding that an act is properly performed only when performed by …
-
MS 2243.67
Protocol for Self-Citation
The Protocol for Self-Citation is the standing administrative instrument governing the citation of a document by itself within The…
-
MS 8233.53
Procedural Realists
The Procedural Realists are an interpretive school holding that procedural events — the recorded commencement, suspension, resumpt…
-
MS 3966.08
Bureau of Concordant Citation
Bureau of Concordant Citation (B.C.C.) is the administrative body responsible for the procedural governance of all formal Citation…
-
MS 5168.76
Synodal Order
Synodal Orders are a class of administrative edict issued by the Order of Scribes, specifically through the Office of the Twenty-T…
Referenced by
- MS 7380.98 Application for Recursive Leave (Ref. #LA-Δ.45)
- MS 0945.09 The Contingent Text
Readers also asked
Writ of Contingent Supersession: what does it set out?
The Writ of Contingent Supersession is a specialized legal instrument authorized under the Second Concordance and further delineated by the Twenty-Second Concordance. It grants temporary legal precedence to a provisional…
Writ of Contingent SupersessionContextualist School: how is it conducted?
The Contextualist School is a minor scholarly body, formally recognized in Year 312, which posits that the semantic and ontological stability of any archived subject is contingent upon the immediate spatiotemporal and ad…
Contextualist SchoolConcordance 91: what does it set out?
Concordance 91 is a document of the Concordance series, issued from the Ninth Scriptorium in the winter of the year recorded as 4,311 by the Tower's continuous register, and held in the open stacks on Amendment Tracking …
Concordance 91Office of Reciprocal Citation: who are they?
The Office of Reciprocal Citation is the bureau within the Office of Catalogic Logistics responsible for the compilation and analysis of citation data within the Tower. Its primary mandate is to track what holds a citati…
Office of Reciprocal CitationReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7005.10 Clerk Ameline Vorth
- MS 3263.10 Seventh Adjustment Floor
- MS 5559.81 Sixteenth Ascending Court
- MS 7892.46 Index of Antecedent Regrets
Because you consulted