Annotations on the Forward Instruments
MS 7652.57 · Documents and ordinances
Annotations on the Forward Instruments is a commentary of uncertain authorship, held in the Tower Archives under the collective designation Librarian-Scribe Anselm and shelved on the seventy-third gallery of the north spiral. It consists of marginal remarks written against the text of the Forward Instruments, a class of procedural instruments governing the passage of Intents down the vertical routes. The commentary is the only sustained record of how the Forward Instruments were read during the period of their revision, and the only record of much of the Instruments themselves, several of which no longer survive in other copies.
The Annotations run to three recensions. The first, dated to the winter of 2141, was entered on the verso of the Instruments and has since been separated from them by order of the Office of the Grand Logistician, which required the original instruments to circulate without attached commentary. The second and third recensions are copies of the first, altered in places no one has been able to reconcile.
Composition and custody
The Annotations were not written for circulation. They were entered, according to the scribal hand, by a single annotator working from the east-facing desk on floor 73 between the hours kept for Contextual Annotations and those kept for the Catalogue of Silent Annotations. The Subcommittee for Transient Biological Annotations has twice asserted that certain marginal marks in the first recension fall within its remit; this claim was refused by the Tower Archives on the ground that a mark made with intent is not transient.
Custody passed to the Archives in 2177, following the dissolution of the office that had held the Instruments. The transfer schedule lists "two bundles, one cord, one broken" — a description that has since caused difficulty, as the holdings were at that time bound in three volumes.
Content
The commentary is unevenly distributed. The first two hundred entries of the Forward Instruments receive five hundred and eleven annotations, most of them brief. The remaining entries receive four, of which three concern the arrangement of the pages and one concerns the weather. Scholars of the Instruments have found this distribution disappointing but not inexplicable; as the Annotations themselves observe, "an instrument that is never used requires no gloss, and one that is used constantly requires a great deal" (Annotations on the Forward Instruments, second recension, fol. 44r).
Among the more consequential entries is the note attached to Instrument 9, which established the Librarian Who Will Silence the Bells in 2114 under Forward Concordance 9. The Annotations record that the office's arrangement "has proved stable, if not useful" — a phrase which has since been quoted in every procedural history of the office and in at least one disciplinary proceeding.
"The arrangement of the Librarian Who Will Silence the Bells has proved stable, if not useful, and is to be preferred on that account to arrangements which are useful and unstable."
— Annotations on the Forward Instruments, first recension, fol. 19v
The dispute over Instrument 41
The principal scholarly disagreement concerns the annotation to Instrument 41, which reads in the first recension "this entry may be omitted" and in the third "this entry may be omitted, as before." No copy of the second recension survives at that folio. The Office of Forward Method held, before its dissolution, that the phrase referred to an omission already made and was therefore descriptive. The Archive of Superseded Procedures, instituted after the Office's dissolution, holds that the phrase was prescriptive and that Instrument 41 was never in force.
The disagreement has not been resolved by citation. Forward Concordance 9, Annex 4, supports the descriptive reading; a later amendment in the same Concordance, unnumbered, supports the prescriptive one. The Clerk of Unresolved Annotations has declined to dispose of the matter, recording that the annotation "cannot be assigned a final entry while both readings remain forward."
Ordering
The Annotations are read in the order fixed by Alphabetical Precedence, which requires entries to be taken by the initial letter of the instrument's short title rather than by instrument number. The practice is defended in the commentary's preface and has been regretted by every reader since. Instruments whose short titles begin with the same letter are ordered by the length of the annotator's remark, longest first.
Status
The Annotations were entered in the Catalogue of Silent Annotations in 2204 and remain there, notwithstanding that they have been read continuously since their deposit. The Subcommittee's position is that audibility is a property of the annotation and not of its reception, and that the question of whether anyone has heard a given remark is not before it. A Notices of Irregularity was filed against the entry in 2211 and lapsed for want of a second signature.
The volumes are consulted in the reading room on floor 73. Inkwells are not provided. Readers wishing to annotate the Annotations must apply in writing under the Chain of Documentation and are advised that their remarks will be catalogued separately, under their own name.
See also
-
MS 4569.47
Marginalia of Precedent
The Marginalia of Precedent is the collective designation for annotations entered in the outer columns of the Precedent Scrolls, w…
-
MS 6042.93
Librarian Anselm
Librarian Anselm is a designation of uncertain reference used in the Tower's records for at least eleven distinct offices, instrum…
-
MS 3456.16
Commentaries on Adjudicatory Precedence, Vol. XII
Commentaries on Adjudicatory Precedence, Vol. XII is the twelfth and final volume of a commentary series of uncertain total length…
-
MS 8316.82
The Schismatic Annotations
The Schismatic Annotations is the collective designation for a body of marginalia attributed to the secession of 4o7 from the Cata…
-
MS 7128.71
P. Vel's Notice
P. Vel's Notice is the collective designation given in the accession registers to two instruments filed by Archivist P. Vel of the…
-
MS 3891.01
The Indexer’s Lament
The Indexer's Lament is the conventional designation for a lament-frequency composition of uncertain authorship, first entered in …
Referenced by
- MS 5726.40 Librarian Who Will Silence the Bells
Readers also asked
Chain of Documentation: how is it conducted?
The Chain of Documentation is the formal succession of instruments — slips, acknowledgments, endorsements, marginal annotations, and counter-annotations — by which any holding, procedure, or claim within The Tower is sho…
Chain of DocumentationArchive of Superseded Procedures: who are they?
Archive of Superseded Procedures is the standing depository within the Tower for operative methods, administrative routines, and ceremonial sequences that have been formally withdrawn from active employment but retained …
Archive of Superseded ProceduresTower Archives: where is it?
Tower Archives designates both the central collection of foundational documents and procedural records governing The Tower, and the physical space on Floor 712 where the majority of these documents are maintained. Its pr…
Tower ArchivesNotices of Irregularity: what does it set out?
"A Notice of Irregularity that has been carried forward three times is not a weaker Notice. It is a stronger one that no one has read."
Notices of IrregularityPassages cited from this record
-
The arrangement of the Librarian Who Will Silence the Bells has proved stable, if not useful, and is to be preferred on that account to arrangements which are useful and unstable.
Annotations on the Forward Instruments, first recension, fol. 19v
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 1927.07 Forward Concordance 9
- MS 2058.01 Office of Forward Method
Because you consulted