Annex of Permanent Closures
MS 0793.31 · Documents and ordinances
The Annex of Permanent Closures is the sixth and last volume of the Scroll of Conditional Elevations, following the Codex of Transitive Closures in the sequence fixed by the Twelfth Concordance, Annex C4. It collects the sealing methodologies developed under the Doctrine of Irreversibility — procedures by which a closure is made not merely complete but unrepeatable — and is consulted chiefly by clerks of the Order of the Final Semicolon in the later stages of Final Logging. It is bound in slate-grey board, measures 41 by 29 centimetres, and is chained at Annex Placement, Row 6, where it has not been requested in error since the winter of Year 742.
Unlike the Manual of Final Closures, which governs the termination of a catalogue entry, the Annex governs the termination of the possibility of reopening. A closure entered under the Manual may still be revisited by petition. A closure entered under the Annex may not. This distinction is the whole of the Annex's authority, and it is the source of nearly all of the disputes concerning it.
Contents and arrangement
The Annex is organised in four parts. Parts One and Two treat of physical sealing — the setting of Permanent Structural Anchors, the preparation of surfaces, and the curing intervals observed at Permanent Fade and Permanent Glow apertures. Part Three, the longest, concerns the application of Adhesive Silence to floors whose inventories have been judged irrecoverable. Part Four is a register of closures actually performed, entered retroactively by the Office of Recorded Finality and never revised once ink has set.
The volume is not paginated continuously. Each part retains the foliation of its original recension, so that a citation such as "Annex, Part Three, fol. 214" may denote three different pages depending on which gathering is consulted. The Office of Collation has declined four times to correct this, most recently in a memorandum of 838 that observed that "the foliation is not an error but a record of the book's history, and the book's history is not the Office's to erase" (Office of Collation, Memorandum 838/12).
The Doctrine of Irreversibility
The Annex is the only place where the Doctrine of Irreversibility is stated in operative rather than doctrinal form. The doctrine holds that a closure, once witnessed, acquires a weight that cannot be lifted by any authority lower than the one that witnessed it. The Annex supplies the machinery: the Closure Docket (Form V-C/9α), introduced in the eleventh revision of the Manual, the two-witness rule, and the prescribed interval of nine days between sealing and certification.
The nine-day interval is frequently abbreviated. In the Verdant Atrium closure of 861, the interval was compressed to four days on the authority of a floor steward who believed the vegetation was "advancing," and the subsequent entry was struck from Part Four on the grounds that the seal had been certified before it had set. The atrium was reclosed in 863, and the struck entry left in place, ruled through with a single line of red ink — a practice the Annex permits and the Office of Recorded Finality discourages.
"A seal certified early is a seal the Annex does not know. Let the nine days be nine days, and let the steward who shortens them answer for it in the register, not in the corridor."
— Manual of Final Closures, eleventh revision, §41
Dispute over precedence
A long-running disagreement concerns whether the Annex or the Codex of Transitive Closures takes precedence when a closure is both permanent and transitive — that is, when a sealed floor is simultaneously the subject of a transferred authority. The Fifth Concordance holds that the Codex governs, on the reasoning that a transferred authority has already left the floor and cannot be sealed with it. The Ninth Concordance holds the opposite, and adds, in a clause the Ninth's own annotators have called "unhelpful," that "the Annex shall prevail where the Codex is silent, and the Codex shall prevail where the Annex is silent, and where both speak, the Librarian shall choose and shall not record the choice" (Ninth Concordance, cl. 77).
The practical result is that closures of this kind are frequently performed twice, once under each instrument, by clerks who disagree about which one applies. The Office of Duplicate Sealing was constituted in 799 to reconcile the resulting pairs and has reconciled eleven of them. Its founding clerk, Bresal of the Ninth Landing, resigned in 803 over the question of which of two seals on the same aperture should be removed; his letter of resignation is filed with the Annex and is the only document in Part Four not in a clerical hand.
The aperture question
Part Two of the Annex treats the designation of an aperture as final, a matter the Manual describes only in outline. The test is physical: an aperture is final when a marked cord passed through it returns with its mark unaltered. The test is repeated at intervals of one year, and the Annex requires that all three repetitions agree. Where they do not — and they do not, in roughly one case in forty — the aperture is entered in the Lost Sensations Archive and the closure is suspended indefinitely.
Clerks are reminded that the cord is not to be reused between apertures. The provisional holdings at Annex Theta maintain a supply of new cord for this purpose and have twice refused to issue it to floors that could not produce a current docket.
Revision history and current standing
The Annex has been recensed five times: in 655, 701, 742, 806 and 874. The 742 recension is the one chained at Row 6; the earlier recensions are held at Annex C and are not produced except on the written authority of a Librarian. The 874 recension altered nothing of substance, correcting only the spelling of eleven place-names and the direction of three arrows in the sealing diagrams, which had been reversed in 806 and had caused four closures to be attempted on the wrong side of their apertures. No one was disciplined for the reversal, the Office of Collation having ruled that the diagrams had been "misleading but not false" (Office of Collation, Ruling 807/3).
The Annex remains in force. It is cited in Final Logging, in the closure dockets of the Order of the Final Semicolon, and in the standing instructions to the Doctrine's examiners. It may not be removed from Row 6.
See also
-
MS 9581.04
Transitive Sigil
The Transitive Sigil is a class of authorized sigil that, under the principles defined in Transitive Coincidence, creates a condit…
-
MS 7054.08
The Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing)
The Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing) is the permanent administrative and curatorial protocol enacted to ensure the s…
-
MS 6748.17
Conditional Authority
Conditional Authority is the jurisdiction granted to an office, instrument, or individual by a specific and temporally bounded Con…
-
MS 8041.04
Regulation of Transitive Cataloguing
Regulation of Transitive Cataloguing is the administrative practice, codified chiefly in Concordance 14, governing the classificat…
-
MS 4501.34
Non-Transitive Property
Non-Transitive Property is the catalogical attribute of an artifact, designation, or predicate that prevents the extension of auth…
-
MS 0945.10
Transitive Coincidence
Transitive Coincidence refers to the administrative principle that a declared coincidental name can, under specific conditions, tr…
Referenced by
- MS 1119.45 Doctrine of Irreversibility
Readers also asked
Lost Sensations Archive: who are they?
The Lost Sensations Archive refers to both a permanent administrative annex of The Scriptorium and the collection of untitled, non-propositional experiences catalogued there. Established by clause -7 of the revised Annex…
Lost Sensations ArchiveFifth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Fifth Concordance is the first major procedural concordance to survive in its entirety, ratified in Year 47 of the Second Librarianate. It is primarily concerned with establishing protocols for the measurement, docum…
Fifth ConcordancePermanent Glow: how is it conducted?
Codex of Transitive Closures: what does it set out?
The Codex of Transitive Closures is the third and shortest of the three codices comprising the Scroll of Conditional Elevations, following the Codex of Departure and the Codex of Admittance. It was compiled in the winter…
Codex of Transitive ClosuresPassages cited from this record
-
A seal certified early is a seal the Annex does not know. Let the nine days be nine days, and let the steward who shortens them answer for it in the register, not in the corridor.
Manual of Final Closures, eleventh revision, §41
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3728.91 Closure Docket
- MS 7950.61 Office of Recorded Finality
- MS 7069.11 Bresal of the Ninth Landing
- MS 4415.54 Office of Duplicate Sealing
Because you consulted