Annex Γ (Gamma)
MS 9353.62 · Documents and ordinances
Annex Γ is the name borne by no fewer than nine distinct instruments of Tower governance, an ambiguity that the Office of Annex Reconciliation has formally declined to resolve on three separate occasions. All nine are handwritten, all nine are emphatically in force, and the precise wording of each annex is disputed between any two floors on which copies are held. Where a Concordance refers simply to "Annex Γ," the presumption established under the Fourth Concordance, Article 2, is that the reader already knows which one is meant. The presumption is described in the same Article as "remedial and final."
History of the designation
Gamma was assigned to the annex at a date no one has yet fixed, though the assignment long predates its first surviving citation. The Ninth Concordance, which speaks plainly where others hedge, records only that Annex Γ "was Gamma before the counting began." The Uncounted Year — a period of uncertain length during which no floor numbers were issued and which the Tower now dates as beginning and ending in spring — produced the accumulation of parallel Γ designations that persists today. Annexes were copied, the copies were copied again, and by the time anyone looked up from the copying the designation had attached itself to nine different documents, several of which contradict each other on the question of what an annex is.
Proposals to reletter the offending annexes (Gamma to Delta, Delta to Epsilon, and so on down the alphabet) have failed twice. The Alphabet Resolution of Floor 1140 failed on procedural grounds after the floor's alphabet exhausted itself at Omega with eight annexes still unlettered. A second attempt, the Reclassification Petition of 4018, failed for a simpler reason: the reconciling scribes could not agree on which document they had been asked to reletter, and the petition was returned uncorrected.
The principal text
The Annex Γ most often cited is the text that establishes wavelength measurements for the determination of seniority among the Librarians, and which further sets the standard parameters for archival atmosphere under the annex's own Protocol Gamma-12. That a single instrument should govern both the standing of graduate scribes and the humidity of manuscript storage is a consequence of an amendment passed in the annex's third recension, which appended the atmospheric schedules to the wavelength tables and removed them only on appeal. The schedules remain appended.
"No annex shall be read in isolation, and no annex shall be read with another annex in the same room."
— Sixth Concordance, Annex Γ, marginal instruction to custodians
The Central Vault of Annex Γ preserves the full text of Clause 17, Annex B, which is not itself part of Annex Γ and is retained on a shelf at the far end of the vault for reasons the vault's own inventory describes as "conservative." The final page of several enterable copies of Annex Γ instead bears a short notice, in a different hand, that measurements taken on the stairs are provisional and that the stairs are closed to measurements. Readers who persist in measuring the stairs are directed to the Stair Measurements Office on the western landings, which does not exist on every floor.
Relationship to other annexes
Annex Γ does not stand alone. Annex Gamma-7 codifies Protocol Gamma-12 in fuller form and is frequently mistaken for the Annex Γ itself, an error the Measurer Scribes for Annex Gamma 7 have stopped correcting in writing. Annex Gamma of the Sixth Concordance echoes and often contradicts the principles of Annex Gamma, while the Tenth Concordance's Annex Γ offers a corrective reading of the same principles that the Sixth has never formally rebutted. Annex Gamma 7 of the Seventh Concordance is appended to Annex Gamma of the Seventh Concordance and should not be confused with Annex Gamma-7 of the Ninth. Second Concordance Annex Gamma codified Phase Gamma as a three-phase access regime, and the distinction between Phase Gamma and Annex Γ has caused at least one delegation to be admitted to the wrong floor for a fortnight.
Access and standing room
Admission to Annex Γ floors is governed partly by Third Concordance Clause 31, which assigns standing room to each floor, and partly by Concordance 44, Annex Gamma, which assigns the same standing room to different floors without repealing the first. Clauses 12 through 47 of the Third Concordance govern access by phase, and Clause 22, Annex Gamma restricts the posting of signs for reading rooms. The practical effect is that a visitor's standing room is determined by which document the door-keeper consulted that morning. Keepers are forbidden to confer.
One consequence of the overlapping regimes is worth recording. In the winter following the Second Recension, the keeper on Floor 338 admitted a delegation from the Spiral 88-Gamma Annex on the strength of the Second Concordance and then, on the strength of the Third, declined to admit them to the room they had already entered. The delegation remained standing for six days. The incident is the subject of Concordance 19 Annex Gamma, which finds in the keeper's favour without requiring the delegation to leave. A plain notice at the foot of the stair records that the delegation's chairs were requisitioned on the fourth day.
Scholarly disagreement
The central dispute concerns whether Annex Γ is a place, a document, or a designation. The Place Party, strongest on the low floors, observes that one enters Annex Γ through a doorway, that the doorway has a lintel, and that the lintel is numbered; on this view the annex is a floor that happens also to be written down. The Document Party, strongest in the scriptoria, observes that only the text of Annex Γ is cited in disputes and that no dispute has ever been settled by walking somewhere.
The reconciling position, advanced in the Third Concordance, Annex Γ, holds that the question is itself improper, since the document and the floor are "the same article viewed from the stair." That formulation satisfied the Commission on Standing Questions for eleven years before the Spiral 719-Gamma recension revisited it, and the Commission has since reported that it remains satisfied but has not read the recension. The Circulation Ledger Gamma records the annex on its shelves and its shelves in the annex; neither entry is cross-referenced, and the Office has declined to say whether the omission is deliberate.
See also
-
MS 6795.65
Concordance 209
Concordance 209, formally the Edict of Unidirectional Ambiguity, is a foundational yet paradoxical governance document pertaining …
-
MS 3274.91
Precedential Reconciliation
Precedential Reconciliation is the formal procedure by which contradictory legal instruments within the Tower are brought into tem…
-
MS 8444.85
Seven-Day Ambiguity
The Seven-Day Ambiguity is the standing classification given to a period of unresolved administrative meaning lasting one full wee…
-
MS 8403.45
Gap Reconciliation
Gap Reconciliation is the administrative procedure by which discrepancies disclosed through Gap Measurement are formally closed, s…
-
MS 0404.74
Precedence Assignments
The term Precedence Assignments denotes two distinct instruments that share a name, a seal, and — inconveniently — a filing tray. …
-
MS 1898.66
Concordance 311
Concordance 311 is the designation borne by three distinct instruments of Tower governance, none of which acknowledges the other t…
Referenced by
- MS 2990.22 Floor 1,114-Δ Standing Order
Readers also asked
Clause 31, Annex Gamma: what does it set out?
Clause 31, Annex Gamma is the provision of the Third Concordance governing the standing room of the Annex itself — that is, the aggregate volume on each Annex Gamma floor that may be occupied by persons, instruments, and…
Clause 31, Annex GammaSecond Recension: what does it set out?
Second Recension is the collective designation for the body of corrected, expanded, and in places reversed text produced during the general revision of the Floor Register in the years 1141–1149. It is the earliest recens…
Second RecensionAnnex Γ: where is it?
Annex Γ is a provisional holding located on the undesignated landing between Floors 137 and 138, officially established by the Clause 4, Annex C variance petition of 07--8912. It serves as the primary repository and proc…
Annex ΓSecond Concordance Annex Gamma: what does it set out?
Second Concordance Annex Gamma is the codified procedural and administrative framework governing the core operational and doctrinal principles of The Tower. It is the most frequently cited and amended annex of the founda…
Second Concordance Annex GammaPassages cited from this record
-
No annex shall be read in isolation, and no annex shall be read with another annex in the same room.
Sixth Concordance, Annex Γ, marginal instruction to custodians
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4221.01 Reclassification Petition
- MS 4189.10 Stair Measurements Office
- MS 1353.80 Uncounted Year
- MS 6190.49 Commission on Standing Questions
Because you consulted