The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Tomes Auxiliary Index

MS 3722.29 · Documents and ordinances

The Tomes Auxiliary Index is a secondary finding-aid maintained in the fourth sub-basement of the Cartographers' Auxiliary and administered, since the administrative reorganisation of 809, by the Scrivener’s Auxiliary. It records the location, condition, and current certification of volumes held in auxiliary custody — that is, volumes whose shelf has been assigned but whose shelf is not, for the time being, agreed upon. It is not to be confused with the Reference Cross-Index, which is larger, older, and answers a different question.

The Index occupies forty-one shelves of cards, none of which are catalogued by the Index itself. This arrangement is deliberate and is defended in the standing notes of the office.

Origins and the fixed-shelf question

The Index was established in 641 to resolve a class of dispute that the Eastern Auxiliary Ladder could no longer absorb. The Ladder submits dossiers to the Scriptorium for update to the Fixed Ladder Index, and it had found itself repeatedly asked to file volumes that were fixed on no ladder at all. These volumes were not lost; they were merely in transit between two shelf assignments, sometimes for years at a time.

The founding instrument, the Third Concordance, Annex 4, established the principle under which the Index still operates. It held that a volume in transit retains its number and loses its position, and that a register of numbers without positions was preferable to a register of positions without numbers, since the latter could not be verified.

"The Index shall record what the volume is, not where it may presently be found; for the volume is constant and the finding is temporary."

— Third Concordance, Annex 4, Clause 712.4

That clause has been read narrowly and broadly for four centuries. The narrow reading — adopted by the Index's own keepers — is that location columns may be filled in only when a location has been confirmed twice by separate sweep. The broad reading, advanced by the Intermittent Auxiliary in 738, is that the Index ought not to record location at all, and that the columns were added in error and should be struck through rather than filled. The matter remains open.

Description of the holdings

The Index is organised into three registers. The Register of Transit holds the cards of volumes between shelf assignments. The Register of Condition holds the cards of volumes whose binding has been questioned, and includes the certified dossiers of the Self-Irrigating Tomes, which require frequent annotation and, in the opinion of the Index's keepers, rather more blotting paper than has been supplied to them. The Register of Exception holds volumes entered under the Catalogue of Temporary Exceptions, and is maintained in red ink by long custom.

A card in any register carries the volume's title, its number, its certifying officer, the date of last verification, and a column headed Expected Position, which is not a prediction and is left blank. The Index has never explained the column. When asked, in 791, the Index-Tender of the day replied that the column was required by the form and that changing the form would require a recension of the form, and that no one had proposed one.

Administration

The Index is administered by the Index-Tender of the Cartographers' Auxiliary under the appointment provisions of the Index of Non-Absolute Standards, which governs such appointments through the Standards for Auxiliary Custodianship (DoIT-9,003). The present Index-Tender, Lysandra Vex, appointed in 812, has held the office through two recensions and has declined a third.

In practice the Index is kept by a senior clerk and a rotating assistant drawn from the Auxiliary Plumbing Guild, whose members are the only staff permitted to move the Index's shelves, on the grounds that the shelves are load-bearing and that the Guild has the appropriate equipment. The current senior clerk, Perrin Aulus, has held the post since 817 and has twice petitioned to be relieved of it. Both petitions were returned unopened, on the ground that they had been filed in the wrong register.

The Index is open to consultation on the second and fourth days of each week. Visitors are asked not to reshelve their own cards.

The Aulus grievance of 817

In the winter of 817 a wall of the fourth sub-basement was found to be admitting water along its western length. Eighty-one cards in the Register of Condition were rendered illegible. Aulus requested that they be recopied from duplicate records held by the Scrivener’s Auxiliary. The Scrivener's office replied that the duplicates were held under the 44-7.B auxiliary filing system, which permits copying only upon the authority of the office that made the original entry, and that office had been dissolved in 690.

Aulus then appealed directly to the Curators of Living Paradox, on the reasoning that several of the damaged cards concerned volumes held at the Vault Place, and that the Curators therefore had an interest. The Curators accepted the appeal, heard it, and returned a finding that the matter fell outside their competence, as it concerned the cards and not the volumes. Aulus's later remark, entered in the office daybook, was that "the water has been ruled to have fallen between the two of us." The eighty-one cards remain unreconstructed. Their numbers are known; their titles are not.

Disputed status

The chief scholarly disagreement concerning the Index is whether it ought to be regarded as an index at all. The Office of Concordance Studies has argued, in a paper of 802, that the Index is properly a register, since it records entries rather than pointing to them, and that its designation as an index was a clerical convenience of 641 never ratified. In support it cites the Catalogue of Temporary Exceptions, which records and does not point, and which the office regards as the correct model.

The opposing view, put by the Scrivener's Auxiliary in reply, is that the distinction is not sustained anywhere in the Concordances, that the Index has been called an index on every form, seal, and doorway plaque since 641, and that a change of designation would require the doorway plaque to be altered, which has not been budgeted. The Catalogue of Temporary Exceptions is cited in the same reply as evidence that even recording registers are sometimes called catalogues, and that nothing follows from this.

The Resolution of the Mis-shelved Tomes of 674 settled a related question — whether a volume entered in the Index during transit could be shelved without the Index's confirmation — in favour of the Index. The resolution has been cited in every subsequent dispute and has satisfied neither party. The matter is expected to be returned to the Concordance in the next recension, where it has been returned four times before.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Auxiliary Plumbing Guild: who are they?

The Auxiliary Plumbing Guild is a chartered body of the Tower responsible for the installation, survey, and periodic condemnation of plumbing networks held to be separate from the Vascular Canons. Its charter, granted un…

Auxiliary Plumbing Guild
Resolution of the Mis-shelved Tomes: how is it conducted?

Resolution of the Mis-shelved Tomes refers to a series of interlocking administrative rulings and procedural adjustments enacted between Floor 7,122 and Floor 7,126 to address the persistent and systemic issue of bibliog…

Resolution of the Mis-shelved Tomes
Vault Place: where is it?

Vault Place is the informal, albeit widely adopted, designation for the administrative and residential precinct occupying the entirety of Tower Floors 721 through 724. It serves as the primary living quarters, administra…

Vault Place
Curators of Living Paradox: who are they?

The Curators of Living Paradox are a semi-autonomous oversight body within the Curators Guild, charged with the administration, containment, and theoretical reconciliation of self-referential and actively contradictory a…

Curators of Living Paradox

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.