The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Seventy Second Concordance

MS 5062.47 · Documents and ordinances

The Seventy-Second Concordance is the compendious instrument of governance under which the Tower's seventy-second register of administrative acts is currently maintained. It was sealed in the winter of the year the Librarian-Taxonomist office records as 3,412 (by the reckoning of the Seventy-First Concordance, 3,409), and it remains the single most cited and least read document in the archive. Its forty-one annexes, its two codicils, and its unruly body of clauses together touch nearly every matter of Tower procedure, from the classification of Divergent Grids and the approved colours of the codified spectrum to the duties of observers, the disposition of script-moths, and the jurisdictional boundaries of a staircase no one has fully surveyed. No complete recension exists. The working copy in the Chamber of Fading Impressions is missing Annexes Θ through Λ, and the Seventy-Third Concordance refers to provisions none of its surviving annexes contain.

Structure and Annexes

The Concordance is organised as a body of numbered clauses appended by annexes, each annex bearing a Greek letter and a subject. Annex γ is the largest, and the administrative burden of the archive falls largely on it: it classifies the Seventy-Second Floor as a Divergent Grid and establishes the Division of Counterfactual Integrity to administer such grids under protocols of its own devising. Annex Δ is short and technical, having formalised the adoption of Pace per Second Squared as the standard measure of acceleration in all instruments of the Tower. Annex C preserves a typical duty roster for a Factotum-Second, and is consulted chiefly by clerks who wish to know what a Factotum-Second ought to have been doing on a given afternoon.

Annex 3 of Codicil 44 formally articulates the Paradox of the Silent Observer, a formulation that has generated more commentary than any other passage in the Concordance and settled no dispute whatever. Clause 8, in the body of the text, describes the direct application of Script-Moths to written matter, and has been read as authorising the practice rather than merely describing it — a reading the Librarian-Taxonomist, Provisional Grade office has never successfully overturned.

The Observer Question

The Concordance defines the position of Observer and enumerates its entitlements and immunities in some detail; what it does not do is resolve whether the Observer's perception of a document alters that document. The dissent regarding the so-called Observer's Patina is recorded in the Concordance itself, at length, and without conclusion, the parties having agreed only to disagree in writing. The dispute has since hardened into a division of the archive: clerks of the counterfactual division hold that the patina is an artefact of inspection, while the whisper-stacks administration at Seventy-Second Floor maintains, per Seventy-Second Floor (Whispering Stacks) Administrative Bulletin 704-b, that the patina precedes the observer. Both offices cite the same annex.

"Where two clauses of this instrument conflict, and neither yields to the other by plain reading, the later clause shall prevail — provided it is numbered higher. Where it is not, Clause 404 applies."

— Seventy-Second Concordance, Clause 404, cited in the resolution of the Spiral Nine clause dispute

Clause 404 and the Non-Sequential Difficulty

The Concordance's numbering is not sequential, and this is not regarded as an error. Clause 404 exists precisely to resolve conflicts between clauses that do not stand in a legible order to one another, and it has been invoked eleven times since sealing, most notoriously in the Spiral Nine affair, when two clauses bearing the same number were found to contradict each other and neither could be shown to be later. The resolution — that both clauses stand, and that the conflict between them is itself the operative rule — was recorded without dissent and has caused difficulty ever since.

Jurisdiction and the Sub-Basement

Amendment Seventy-Two, Clause 309, formalised the jurisdictional division of the Sub-Basement of Floor 5,307, apportioning its custody between two offices whose names differ by a single letter and whose seals are indistinguishable at a glance. Whispering Column (442–17) has been cited in connection with the boundary survey; the column's marking is not referenced in any surviving annex, and the surveyors' notes were filed under Annex Θ, which is missing. The Stacks of Possible Geometries were catalogued under the same amendment, though the stacks' own custodians dispute this.

Reception and Contradiction

The Concordance is amended more often than it is read, and the amendments are not consolidated. A clerk seeking the rule on Unofficial Colors must consult the codified-spectrum criteria in the body of the text, the qualification added at Annex Θ (lost), and the Seventy-Third Concordance, which restores the qualification but alters its wording. Scholarly opinion divides on whether the Seventy-Second supersedes the Seventy-First or merely continues it; the Seventy-First Concordance claims precedence in its own closing clauses, and the Seventy-Second does not address the claim, which some take as tacit assent and others as contempt.

The Concordance also ratified the Doctrine of Perpetual Dispute on Floor 880, an act whose consequences remain under review. Its precise status — sealed instrument, living record, or something between — is the subject of a standing enquiry before the Librarians, whose findings have not been issued. The enquiry's terms of reference are filed under Annex Θ.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Whispering Column (442–17): where is it?

The Whispering Column (442–17), also known as the Acoustic Residual Column, is a designated conceptual-structural void on the Seventy-Second Floor, first catalogued under the Seventeenth Concordance as the acoustic and p…

Whispering Column (442–17)
Observer: how is it conducted?

Observer is a rank within the Librarian order responsible for the primary documentation and cataloguing of non-existent phenomena. The position is defined by Concordance 72, Section 4, and carries the formal entitlements…

Observer
Factotum-Second: how is it conducted?

The Factotum-Second is a discontinued specialist rank within the Guild of Factotums, officially operational from the ratification of the Second Concordance in Year 1 to its supersession by the Forty-Second Concordance in…

Factotum-Second
Pace per Second Squared: how is it conducted?

Pace per Second Squared (PPS), also known as the Concordant Unit of Accelerative Measure, is the fundamental derived unit of acceleration used throughout The Tower for administrative and structural engineering purposes. …

Pace per Second Squared

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.