The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Seventeen Murmuring Marbles

MS 9092.35 · Objects and instruments

The Seventeen Murmuring Marbles are a matched set of glass spheres, each 3.1 cm in diameter, held in the care of The Murmuring Stacks on the western half of Floor 6,412. Each marble emits a sustained vocal murmur audible at a range of approximately two paces. The seventeen voices do not speak in unison, nor in sequence, nor in any order that the Index of Ambiguity has consented to record. They are catalogued as a single holding under Entry 6,412-W-17 and have been the subject of four formal disputes, one withdrawal of custody, and the standing irritation of the Stacks' night staff.

Description and Provenance

The marbles are of a pale green glass with a faint internal clouding, consistent with the Vitrine Glassworks of Floor 4,880, though that workshop's ledgers for the relevant period were destroyed in the Second Spillage and cannot confirm the attribution. Each stone is drilled with a single aperture of 2 mm; the aperture is not visible on casual inspection and cannot be located twice in the same place.

Provenance is recorded in the accession note of the Keeper of Western Shelving:

"Received in a lined box, seventeen compartments, no covering letter. The box was warm. The marbles were not. Both facts are entered here so that neither is later denied."

— Accession Note 6,412-W, folio 3

The set is not to be confused with Seventeen Identical Spoons, which are silent, nor with the whispering narratives attributed to Sigil 8.14.γ-β, which are held at a considerable distance for reasons the Stacks decline to restate.

The Vocal Qualities

The murmur produced by the set has been classified by Murmuring Athenaeum auditors as an instance of phenomena manifesting "vocal qualities without corporeal source," the same category applied to The Murmuring Consensus. Unlike the Consensus, the marbles are portable, and this is the root of most of their difficulty.

Auditors of the Third Recension recorded the marbles over eleven nights in the winter of the year of the four gates, producing 340 hours of wax. The recording is held but may not be replayed. Concordance 2,117 governs: "A murmur that has been captured shall not be released, lest it resume in a place of its choosing" (Concordance 2,117, clause 9). Staff of the Stacks therefore transcribe by ear, and the transcriptions do not agree.

The Custody Dispute of 1896

In 1896 the Office of Portable Holdings asserted that any object small enough to be carried should be carried — and thus removed — from the Stacks to a designated reading room on Floor 6,414. The Keeper of Western Shelving objected on the ground that the marbles, when lifted, are heard by every reader within the room, and that the reading room in question had a reader in it.

The matter reached the Librarians and was resolved, as such matters often are, by citation of contradictory instruments. The Office cited Concordance 44, annex 2; the Keeper cited the Librariansreconciliation of 1901, which did not yet exist. The Keeper's clerk, Aethelred of the Ninth Ledger, is recorded as having drafted the reconciliation four years early in order to have something to cite, and then having been obliged to spend the following four years arranging for the Tower to arrive at it independently. He succeeded. The 1901 text rules in the Office's favour; the annex appended to it in the small amendment rules against. The marbles remain where they were.

They are not to be carried through the east door of Floor 6,412.

Scholarly Disagreement

Whether the set comprises seventeen voices or one voice heard seventeen times is unsettled. The Seventeen Provisional Protocols hold the former position, Protocols 1 through 16 and the Seventeenth Provisional Protocols being silent on the attendant implications. The Reconciliation of the Seventeen Calendars — a document concerned with numbering rather than sound — has been cited in support of the latter view by clerks who concede they have not read it.

A minority position, advanced in the marginalia of Seventeen Mirrors of Partial Reflection and never formally tabled, holds that the number seventeen is itself a property of the listening rather than of the objects, and that an eighteenth marble was returned to its box in 1889 and has been murmuring unheard ever since. The Index of Ambiguity records this claim without endorsing it, under the heading Unresolved, Portable.

Current Holding

The Marbles occupy a locked cabinet in the western half of Floor 6,412, in seventeen lined compartments, one marble to a compartment. Custody is with the Keeper of Western Shelving, who reports to The Murmuring Athenaeum quarterly and to no one annually. The Murmuring Stacks reconciles its own accounts of the set with those of satellite collections such as Floor 730, which holds a listening station and disputes the count.

The cabinet is opened for inspection on the first of each month, in the presence of two clerks, neither of whom may speak during the opening. This precaution dates from the incident of the answering box and has not been rescinded. Visitors wishing to hear the set must apply in writing and must leave their own glassware at the door.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Concordance 44: what does it set out?

Concordance 44, formally Concordance Regarding the Deductive Non-Correlation of Hermetic Sequences, is a foundational yet contentious document governing the procedural isolation of unrelated archival phenomena. It establ…

Concordance 44
Seventeen Mirrors of Partial Reflection: what is it for?

The Seventeen Mirrors of Partial Reflection are a classified and permanently sequestered set of reflective instruments catalogued under Seal 117-B on Spire 404, Gallery of Partial Weaves. Their primary, and contentious, …

Seventeen Mirrors of Partial Reflection
Index of Ambiguity: what does it set out?

The Index of Ambiguity is the central registry and concordance for all subjects within the Tower whose ontological status is, or has been, the subject of pluralist interpretation. Maintained on Floor 9,099 (The Murmuring…

Index of Ambiguity
The Seventeen Provisional Protocols: what does it set out?

The Seventeen Provisional Protocols are a suite of regulatory documents, comprising seventeen distinct clauses, drafted and ratified between Concordance 148 (referencing Floor 1022) and Concordance 302 (Floor 404). Thoug…

The Seventeen Provisional Protocols

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.