The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Glass Spheres Aviary

MS 1226.28 · Places and structures

The Glass Spheres Aviary (Floor 883, North Aperture) is the enclosed hall in which the seventeen Glass Spheres have been housed since the third recension of their inventory, and the room in which the Contradiction of the Glass Spheres was argued to its present stalemate. It should be distinguished from the Aviary of Silent Consensus, which occupies the same floor but a different aperture and was constituted only after the dispute closed. The Aviary is jointly administered by the Bureau of Hypothetical Durability and the Office of Reverberant Antiquities, an arrangement that no Concordance authorises and none forbids.

Construction and the quiet specification

The hall was built in CY 101 and refitted twice, in CY 337 and CY 512. Its walls are of grey raddled stone to a height of four and a half metres, above which the fittings are entirely of glass; the readiest account of this is the mason's specification, which survives in the Ledger of the North Aperture and asks for a building "in which nothing within may be heard to shift, and nothing without may be heard at all." The Aviary has no windows. It is entered by two doors on opposite sides, and the rule of the hall is that neither is to be held open. The floor is raked at a gradient of one in nine so that the oldest instruments sit lowest.

Each Sphere rests on a felt cradle upon a slate bracket. The brackets are numbered in the order in which the Spheres were catalogued, not in the order in which they were made, and the two orders do not correspond. Visitors are admitted in parties of four and are asked to leave their gloves at the door with the attendant, who keeps them in a tray.

The Contradiction and the Orrery

The Aviary's importance rests on the dispute that made it famous. The Contradiction of the Glass Spheres was referred to the hall in CY 104, when two delegations, each with its own reading of a closed session, could not agree what the Spheres were made of. The argument did not turn on the Spheres themselves but on the composition of the ceremonial orrery, which exerted 1.1 SCU at its greatest extension, and which several witnesses held had been present. The delegations' findings were irreconcilable, and the matter was carried through the Aviary of Contradictions before any record of the hall's own proceedings was made.

What emerged was the Doctrine of Perpetual Review, under which the question of the Spheres is not closed but reviewed on a fixed cycle, and the Aviary of Silent Consensus, which was constituted to hold the two readings side by side without resolving them. The Bureau of Hypothetical Durability subsequently adopted the Contradiction as a calibration standard, since it is a case that shatters only when observed by two premises that are mutually exclusive. The standard is applied to instruments in the Aviary's west bay, and the readings are recorded in the Durability Register under the signature of the day's duty auditor.

The Artificers' party has long held, and restates each cycle, that the Contradiction was caused by a crystal sphere that produced a paradoxical nested image, and that the hall's present arrangement is a poor repair of the epoch's intellectual decline. The Mercantile party replies that the disputing delegations never saw the same session. See Abridged History of the Dispute for the fuller account.

Routing of the Spheres

The Aviary is not only a store; it is a turning point in the routing of ideational material. Under the precedent that carries the Contradiction's name, a Courier-Sphere conveying ideational material through the Aviary must be re-registered at the inner door and may not proceed without the counter-signature of the doorkeeper. This is the origin of the standing of the hall in Resonance Cartography, which treats the Aviary as the principal calibration point in the north of the building. The rule's history is instructive. In the winter of CY 447 a courier traversed the Aviary and the outer door on the south side was opened to receive it, and the three nearest Spheres did not settle for a day and a half. The courier's papers were found in order, which is the point: the rule had not been made. The amended rule, drafted within the season, requires the counter-signature to be affixed in the outer corridor before the inner door is tried.

Two Administrative Spheres were deposited here in CY 505 and remain. They have never been catalogued, having been brought in during the review cycle, and their brackets are marked in chalk.

Holdings and the account of the seventeen

The Aviary's holdings are a matter of record and may be listed, the record being the only part of the Aviary that is beyond dispute.

  • Seventeen ideational Spheres on slate brackets, the oldest (No. 1) at the lowest point of the raked floor.
  • Two Administrative Spheres, uncatalogued, chalk-marked on the south wall.
  • The ceremonial orrery, in the west bay, at the panel where the Bureau takes its calibration readings.
  • A brass counter for the calibration standard, the earlier one being in the Aviary's keeping after the 9 SCU scale was withdrawn.
  • One tray of visitors' gloves, held at the door by the attendant.

Contradictions in the record

The hall's own furnishings are better attested than its function, and the Concordances disagree on how the Aviary came to be. The Concordance of 109 states that it was "raised for the Spheres and the instruments at once," while the Concordance of 121, as amended in 210, holds that the Spheres "were placed in a hall formerly given to the orrery, and that no room is to be named for one office's instruments." The Concordance of 402 refuses to name an origin at all and directs that the question be referred to the cycle. The Archivist of the North Aperture has noted, in the margin of the register, that the Spheres were "in the hall regardless of the hall's name, and other than that the arrangement suits them."

There is a collateral dispute, at present live, over the fitting of the west bay's awnings for the calibration cycle. These are documented in the 402 recension and were never formally installed, the carpenters having attended on the wrong day in the record to which they were summoned. No party has ordered the Aviary to be opened further, and none has proposed that it be closed.

"A sphere is not to be examined in the hall, nor its shape remarked upon in the presence of the attendant"

— Concordance of 402, Appendix D, para. 11

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Courier-Sphere: what is it for?

Courier-Spheres are autonomous, semi-solid logistical units used for the internal transport of classified or topographically sensitive materials between designated Administrative Spheres. Classified under Ordinance 7-Θ a…

Courier-Sphere
Resonance Cartography: how is it conducted?

Resonance Cartography is a mapping methodology practised by certified Boundary Clerks, in which three calibrated harmonic spheres are sounded in sequence to measure boundary porosity and vibrational integrity across a co…

Resonance Cartography
Aviary of Contradictions: where is it?

The Aviary of Contradictions is a designated aviary-class holding occupying the whole of Floor Ξ.99 and the four auxiliary galleries that open off its western face. It is the oldest aviary in continuous operation in the …

Aviary of Contradictions
Doctrine of Perpetual Review: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine emerged not from a single legislative act, but from a protracted series of disputes in the early archival periods, most notably the Contradiction of the Glass Spheres (Record 4,712-A). Early cataloguers, att…

Doctrine of Perpetual Review

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.