The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Principle of Transient Nourishment

MS 0559.21 · Practices and doctrines

The Principle of Transient Nourishment is the governing doctrine of the Guild of Nourishment Cartographers and the standing rule by which the Tower determines whether a consumable item is entitled to registration as real within its floor. As codified in In re: The Whispering Mall Food Court (survey hall record 1412-G, appended in Floor 1,412), an item is "provisionally real" for the duration of its sensory impact and ceases to be so upon conclusion of that duration, at which point it is remanded to the register of finished goods. The Principle is the load-bearing assumption beneath nearly every eating surface in the Tower's mid-floors, and the reason no one has ever successfully demanded a refund from a floor.

Formulation and register

The Principle was not drafted in a single instrument but assembled from four recensions of the Guild's survey practice between the Eleventh Concordance and the present day. Its operative clause appears in the fourth recension, §7(b), and is quoted in every subsequent filing with the same care and the same typographical errors:

"That which is consumed is real in its consuming; that which is digested is real in its digesting; that which is neither consumed nor digested is not a meal and shall not be entered on the Roll."

— Guild of Nourishment Cartographers, Fourth Survey Recension, §7(b)

Consumers are therefore said to hold a transient tenure over what they eat — a tenure that is not ownership, not leasehold, and, per a supplementary note of 2 Candle, not occupancy. Disputes between the Principle and the Rights of Transient Entities are argued at roughly one sitting per season before the Subcommittee for Transient Biological Annotations.

Registration and the survey hall

The Guild surveys comestibles from its hall on Floor 1,412, where its motto is carved above the entry and, owing to a smudge in the stonecutting, reads Nourish, and the rest follows. Under the current Surveyor of the Third Register, Aurelia Vex, the hall maintains a standing inventory of provisionally-real goods — gardens, kitchens, one eighty-metre corridor of vending apertures whose tenants have never been identified — and stamps each new item with a transient integer drawn under the Theorem of Transient Integers. Access to the hall requires Transient Credentials; the credentials do not admit the holder to the vending corridor, and the Guild has declined to say why.

The Corridor ruling and the glowing preserves

The Principle's most contested application concerns glowing substances. Biologically, they self-illuminate; legally, many of them are food. The Bureau of Transient Forms, authorized by the Second Concordance to register transient lights, began in 7 Candle to enter the glowing preserves of the lower refectories on the Master Roll of Transient Glows. The Guild objected that the preserves were nourishment before they were light, and that under the Principle a consumable could not be reclassified merely because it had been observed flickering after dark.

The Subcommittee for Transient Biological Annotations took the dispute in 9 Candle and reached a workable compromise later the same winter: the light was registered by the Bureau, the nourishment by the Guild, and the two registers were read aloud jointly once a year. The compromise held for eleven years, until the Sub-Committee for Transient Biological Annotations catalogued The Corridor of Transient Anomalies and ruled its contents a transient biological provisional annotation — a finding that had no home in either register. The Sub-Committee's ruling turned partly on the sediment question, and partly on the Manual of Transient Custody, whose criteria for transient custody glows without sediment did not satisfy.

The scholarly disagreement

Librarians disagree over whether a provisionally real item remembers its tenure after digestion. The Principles of Self-Sustenance, a rationing code drafted by the Provisioner Caste and widely cited in lower-floor canteens, hold that nourishment terminates with the meal and that nothing of the meal survives it. The Guild's own instrument says otherwise: an item, once registered, "is not unmade by being finished" (Fourth Survey Recension, §7(d)).

The discord between these two — that a meal both exists for the length of its eating and continues to exist in the register afterward — has never been resolved, only reconciled: the Provisioner Caste's Refectory Guild maintains that §7(d) is a filing instruction mistaken for a doctrine, and the Guild maintains that the Principles are a cookery text mistaken for law. Both cite the Concordances, which is no help, because the Fourth Concordance and the Ninth Concordance say opposite things about the filing of dissent (§3(a) and §11 respectively), and the Eleventh Concordance was amended three times during the dispute, once to correct a spelling error and once, at the Guild's request, to strike a word that no longer appears anywhere in the sentence.

Transient integers and the provisional codex

Each registered item receives a transient integer by Transient Integer Assignment, a procedure administered in the shadow of the Theorem of Transient Integers and known for failing under sustained inspection. Clerk Ovin Marrow, who annotated the survey inventory from 11 to 19 Candle, filed a formal grievance that his integers had on four occasions been reassigned to a consignment of glowing root vegetables that had not yet been eaten; the Guild's reply was that the vegetables existed, and that was enough. The full controversy appears in the Archives of Transient Impressions, along with Marrow's marginal note, "number them anyway."

The Provisional Codex for Transient Custody governs all of this work, requiring the maintenance of Transient Biological Provisional Annotations and the annual re-annotation of every preserved good whose glow outlasts its shelf-life. The Codex's criteria are applied to food, to light, and — by an amendment that no one has attempted to defend — to the plates.1


1 The plates were ruled transient in 14 Candle and have not been re-registered since. Visitors are reminded that the survey hall closes at the second bell.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Subcommittee for Transient Biological Annotations: who are they?

The Sub-Committee for Transient Biological Annotations (colloquially, the Transient Committee) is a curatorial body of the Librarian Order responsible for the classification, containment, and documentation of biological …

Subcommittee for Transient Biological Annotations
Transient Integer Assignment: how is it conducted?

The Transient Integer Assignment is a formal administrative procedure whereby an unresolved or definitionally unstable entity is provisionally allocated a numerical identifier from the Open Integer Set for the purposes o…

Transient Integer Assignment
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance
The Corridor of Transient Anomalies: where is it?

The Corridor of Transient Anomalies is a designated lateral passage on the unsequenced floor designated Floor 770, catalogued under the joint authority of the Sub-Committee for Transient Biological Annotations and the Co…

The Corridor of Transient Anomalies

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.