The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Correspondence Is the Context

MS 6553.31 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and scope

The Correspondence Is the Context is a standing principle of the Office of Voluntary Correspondence, first entered into the Concordance apparatus as an annexural gloss and later cited independently in disputes over retention, bounding, and the applicability of Context Tags. It holds, in its received form, that correspondence — the exchange itself, as preserved in the ledgers of the Office — constitutes the operative context of any matter passing through it, and that no separate or prior context need be identified, bounded, or captured in order for the exchange to be valid. The principle is routinely invoked against petitions that seek to declare a purpose under Ovc 1a before correspondence has begun. In such cases the Office has held that the purpose declared is itself a form of context that arrives only through the act of corresponding, and that requiring its prior capture would be to demand a bounding of something not yet bounded — a demand the Bureau of Unspoken Context has elsewhere declined to entertain, notably in its refusal to bracket Typical Context for retention.

Text and citation

The operative wording appears in three recensions, each cited differently. The earliest, preserved in the Fourth Annex of OVC Directive 14.7, reads:

"The correspondence is the context; and where the correspondence ceases, the context so far as this Office is concerned is at an end."

— OVC Directive 14.7, Fourth Annex

A later recension, entered during the disputes over unsolicited correspondence, extends the principle with a clause that has proven contentious:

"No correspondence shall be held to have occurred retrospectively for the purpose of supplying context to a matter already closed."

— OVC Directive 14.7, Fourth Annex, as amended

The amendment is attributed to the Desk of Lateral Correspondence and is cited by that Desk as settling several longstanding grievances involving returned mail. The Department of Voluntary Correspondence has at times resisted the amendment, arguing that it reads the earlier wording too narrowly.

Relation to bounding

The principle is not formally in tension with Bounding Context, though the two are frequently confused. Bounding Context, as a practice, proceeds by declaring where a context ends; The Correspondence Is the Context proceeds by declining to ask where it began. In practice the two are often applied in sequence, with the bounding deferred until correspondence has generated enough material to bound. The School of Literal Correspondence teaches the sequence as standard, while critics associated with The Correspondence of Mirrored Intent regard the deferral as a form of evasion. A recurring difficulty arises when correspondence continues past the closure of the matter it concerned. In such cases the Office has held, inconsistently, that the continuing correspondence generates a new context rather than extending the old one. The two rulings — cited as the "fresh matter" position and the "continuing matter" position — appear in adjacent annexes of the same Directive and have not been reconciled.

Interaction with Uncaptured Context

Under the Principle of Uncaptured Context, context not explicitly bounded will accumulate. The Correspondence Is the Context has been read by some clerks as a means of preventing such accumulation: if the correspondence is the context, then whatever falls outside the correspondence falls outside the matter, and need not be bounded because it is not, for these purposes, context at all. This reading was challenged in the winter of a year now recorded only as 3/17/2, when a clerk at the Desk of Lateral Correspondence returned a packet of unsolicited letters with the endorsement that they had been received but did not constitute correspondence, and therefore supplied no context. The ruling was overturned on appeal, but the endorsement remains in the marginalia and continues to be cited in both directions. The Bureau of Unspoken Context takes a narrower view, holding that the principle governs what the Office of Voluntary Correspondence may claim as context, and does not bind the Bureau's own determinations under the Eschewal of Context. The Bureau's position is recorded in Bureau of Unspoken Context Notations and is not, at present, reconciled with the Office's.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Eschewal of Context: how is it conducted?

The Eschewal of Context is a philosophical and procedural stance, now formally deprecated by the Bureau of Unspoken Context, which holds that meaning is most purely derived from textual or procedural elements considered …

Eschewal of Context
OVC Directive 14.7: what does it set out?

OVC Directive 14.7 is a key administrative ordinance governing the preliminary processing cycle for unsolicited correspondence within the Office of Voluntary Correspondence. Formally titled "Directive on the Provisional …

OVC Directive 14.7
The Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence is the principle, codified in clause 81.B of the Seventeenth Concordance, that governs all formal communication initiated within or regarding the Tower. It states: "The purpose of…

The Doctrine of Imperfect Correspondence
Office of Voluntary Correspondence: who are they?

The Office of Voluntary Correspondence is the administrative body designated Clerk Registry A-7 and the primary recipient of all unsolicited written communications directed towards the Tower. Located on Floor 14,142, it …

Office of Voluntary Correspondence

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.