The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

The Contra-Argument

MS 8143.93 · Practices and doctrines

The Contra-Argument is the formal instrument by which a settled finding of The Argument on Floor 404 is opposed by a second finding of equal force, neither being subordinate to the other. It is not an appeal. Appeals request revision of a holding; the Contra-Argument requests that a second holding be entered beside the first, permanently, so that no subsequent reader may consult one without the other. The distinction is maintained by the Office of Paired Findings and is the source of most of the difficulties described below.

The instrument was constituted under Directive 9001.1, which permits a contra-directive against a codicil only where the parent instrument is itself subject to a contra-directive. Because the rulings of The Argument are issued as codicils to the Conditional Existence Argument, the first Contra-Argument filed — against the Hermenean codicil of Year 604 — could not be entered until a contra-directive was raised against the parent. That contra-directive took nine years to draft and was eventually written against Directive 1-Alpha, there being no other parent then findable in the record.

Procedure

A Contra-Argument is filed in triplicate on the same stock as the original finding, with the aperture marking of Floor 404 repeated in the upper margin. Filing does not suspend the original. Both instruments stand from the moment of receipt, which the Office of Paired Findings describes as "the intended inconvenience" (Office of Paired Findings, Memorandum 14, Year 611).

Sifting then proceeds on both halves simultaneously, in the manner already established for a Directive/Contra-Directive, and the result enters the record as a sifted pair. Where the pair is entered against a ruling that was itself sifted, the sifting compounds; the earliest such case, Year 618, produced a finding in four parts that no Recensionist has since been able to reduce.

The Stack of Open Argument holds all unresolved Contra-Arguments in filing order, which is not chronological order and is not intended to be. Retrieval is by weight. A Contra-Argument submitted on lighter stock than its antecedent is returned uncatalogued; the practice is not written down but is enforced at the desk.

The Marrow objection

Ottavine Marrow, Senior Recensionist, objected in Year 609 that the Contra-Argument reproduces the error condemned in Contra the Protocol for Unstable Transmutative Articles: that a second instrument does not stabilize a first but merely doubles the number of unstable articles requiring attention. Marrow's objection was drafted in the Archive of Unstable Media, the scriptorium where the Contra itself had been written over eleven weeks, and was filed in the same room, a circumstance she noted in the objection's preamble without comment.

The Office of Paired Findings answered that the Contra-Argument is not a transmutative instrument, since it alters nothing, and that a finding which alters nothing cannot be unstable. Marrow declined to reply. Her marginal note of the same year — "It alters nothing, and so nothing about it can be corrected" — is preserved in the Archive and is cited by both sides.

Dispute over the parent

Two readings of Directive 9001.1 govern current practice, and they are not reconcilable. The reading of the Office of Unreceived Instruments holds that no Contra-Argument may be constituted where the parent has been ruled ineligible under Directive 55.1.3, on the reasoning that an ineligible pair cannot generate a siftable half. The reading of the Office of Paired Findings holds that a Contra-Argument is constituted by the act of filing and that the parent's eligibility is a separate question, settled later or not at all.

The contradiction has produced a class of instruments known informally as orphans: Contra-Arguments entered, sifted, and stacked, whose parents were subsequently ruled never to have been eligible. Nine are currently held in the Annex Alpha. They cannot be withdrawn, because withdrawal would require a contra-instrument, and orphans cannot generate one.

"An orphan stands. It has no parent, no antecedent, and no place in the sequence. It may nevertheless be cited, and is."

— Stack of Open Argument Stabilization, Annex 3

Prohibitions

The Contra-Argument may not be filed against a finding already subject to a Contra-Argument, except by leave of the Warden, which has been granted four times and revoked three. It may not be filed by a party who has not read the original in full; the reading is attested by countersignature and, since Year 622, by the recital of the finding's final clause. It may not be filed on a rest day, and may not be filed on Floor 404 itself — filings are received at the adjacent landing and carried in.

See also

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Conditional Existence Argument: how is it conducted?

The Conditional Existence Argument is a foundational logical doctrine codified in Clause 17, Sub-Annex Ω, which posits that the reality of a catalogued subject within the Tower is contingent upon the completion of its ar…

Conditional Existence Argument
Archive of Unstable Media: who are they?

The Archive of Unstable Media is a designated repository and administrative body responsible for the classification, containment, and study of substrates whose physical or notational integrity degrades predictably upon e…

Archive of Unstable Media
Directive/Contra-Directive: how is it conducted?

Directive/Contra-Directive is the composite designation given to a paired instrument of Tower governance in which a directive and a second directive of equal force are issued over the same subject matter, neither being s…

Directive/Contra-Directive
Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing): how is it conducted?

Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing) is the permanent administrative holding pattern and curatorial protocol by which the Librarians maintain the structural and ontological coherence of The Stack of Open Argume…

Stack of Open Argument Stabilization (Ongoing)

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.