The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Subsidiary Atrium 7.117-epsilon

MS 5645.94 · Practices and doctrines

Subsidiary Atrium 7.117-epsilon was a classified research annex of the Grand Atrium of Reference, entered on the subsidiary register under the epsilon series and struck from that register by instrument of the Librarian-Registrar in the forty-first year of the present recension. It is not to be confused with its sister spaces: Subsidiary Atrium 7.117-omega, which remains in service as a repository of lapsed ordinances and houses the primary Incinerator of Lapsed Potential, nor with the Perpetual Atrium, whose position on the register has never been disputed. The epsilon annex is now universally cited under its later designation, the Echovoid Atrium.

Designation and Register History

The epsilon series was created by Ninth Concordance, Annex 7, to accommodate annexes whose work could not be described in the ordinary schedule of holdings without disclosing what that work was. An epsilon designation therefore carried two properties at once: a number, which located the annex, and a reticence, which did not. Subsidiary Atrium 7.117-epsilon held both for the whole of its registered life.

The Grand Atrium of Reference maintains the register of subsidiary atria, and its clerks record that the epsilon entry was examined at each of eleven audits, found regular at ten, and found "present but not locatable" at the eleventh. The phrase recurs in the audit returns of that period and has never been formally defined.

Layout and the Problem of Sound

The annex comprised a single vaulted chamber, 14 by 9 by 6m, with a mezzanine gallery and a reading gallery above, approached by a service stair later recorded as Spiral Epsilon on Floor 712. Its distinguishing feature was acoustic. The chamber returned speech to the speaker in altered form — not delayed, not reversed, but revised. A sentence spoken at the north lectern came back at the south wall as a correction of itself. Researchers attached to the annex referred to this as the "reply," and to the room as one that "answers," a usage deprecated in the annex's own handbook but never suppressed.

Furnishings were minimal and are inventoried in the annex's standing schedule: one lectern, seventeen reading desks, a wall chronometer of the twelve-hour pattern, and a brass notice at the threshold directing that all speech be conducted below a conversational level after the fourth bell. The notice is the only element of the annex to survive in the Reliquary Alcove after the closure.

The Incident of 14--898

On 14--898 the Echovoid Atrium incident took place. The record of what occurred is itself contested; what is agreed is that a reading party of four was at work in the chamber, that a question was put, that the reply was returned at greater length than the question, and that the party did not emerge at the appointed hour. The Order convened an inquiry under the Standing Order of Quiet Chambers and, before the inquiry had reported, issued the instrument now known as Annex Epsilon, Clause 2. The clause is one sentence long and has been quoted in every subsequent discussion of the annex: "No reply shall be regarded as a holding."

"The chamber is not a witness. It is a room with opinions."

— Annex Epsilon, Clause 2, preamble note, attributed to the Inquiry of 14--898

Scholarly Disagreement

The Eleventh Concordance holds that the annex ceased to be the epsilon chamber at the moment of its reclassification, and that the Echovoid Atrium is a distinct space occupying, or not occupying, the same recess. The Fourteenth Concordance, Annex 3, holds the contrary: that there is one chamber and two registers, and that the register, not the room, was altered. The difference is not pedantic. Under the eleventh reading, the Perpetual Atrium inherited the epsilon number and now stands where the annex stood; under the fourteenth, the number is retired and the Grand Atrium of Reference has been in default of a complete register since the forty-first year.

A third position, advanced by the Clerk Orsina Vell in her marginalia to the audit returns, is that the annex was never at 7.117 at all and that the epsilon entry was a place-holder entered in anticipation of an annex that was never built. Vell's marginalia are unsigned, uncited in the Concordances, and frequently consulted.

Inventory of the Reply

Before closure, the annex maintained a running register of replies judged sufficiently stable to be recorded. The final register was recovered and is held, incompletely, in the Epsilon Reference Shelves. It lists, in the annex's own numbering, the following classes of returned speech: corrections of fact, corrections of tone, corrections of intent, sentences not previously spoken by anyone present, and a fifth class entered only as "furniture."

The fifth class comprised eleven entries over the annex's life. Each is a single line of description, and each describes the position of a chair.

Closure

The annex was struck from the register in the forty-first year and its holdings transferred under seal to the Atrium of Authority, which has declined to confirm receipt. The service stair was left in place and is entered, with the adjacent administrative blocks, as Spiral Epsilon on Floor 712, where the Archivist of that floor continues to answer enquiries concerning the annex in writing only. The brass threshold notice was deposited in the Reliquary Alcove. Requests to read the annex's final register in the chamber itself are declined on the ground that the chamber has been shown to answer, and that the answer would be a reply.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians
Epsilon Reference Shelves: what is it for?

The Epsilon Reference Shelves are a closed stack of ratified instruments housed one half-landing below Annex Epsilon, consisting of the Epsilon Reference Shelves proper and their accompanying finding apparatus. Every ite…

Epsilon Reference Shelves
Spiral Epsilon: where is it?

Spiral Epsilon is a disused service spiral and adjacent administrative annex located on Floor 712. It is principally noted as the former headquarters of the Chiaroscuro School and as the official location of the Reliquar…

Spiral Epsilon
Fourteenth Concordance: what does it set out?

"A Concordance is not a map; it is a surveyor's claim to have settled the territory. The Fourteenth merely surveyed a different set of contours."

Fourteenth Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.