The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Source Provenance

MS 3423.10 · Practices and doctrines

Source Provenance is the record of where a Source came from, held separately from the Source itself and consulted, in the ordinary case, before the Source is read. It is not a Source Document and is not to be confused with one: the Office of Provenance maintains the distinction with some heat, having circulated a memorandum in the winter of 411 that describes the difference as "the difference between a letter and the hand that posted it" (Memorandum OP-19, second recension). A Source without Source Provenance is not inadmissible. It is simply held with its back to the reader.

Practitioners distinguish Source Provenance from Source Authentication, which certifies that a Source is what it claims; Source Provenance states by what route it arrived, and in what condition, and through whose hands. The two processes are usually performed in the same room and disagree in the same room.

Structure of a provenance statement

A canonical provenance statement consists of five elements, recorded in fixed order: the originating instrument, the chain of custody, the apertures crossed, the condition at entry, and the name of the clerk who first held it. The originating instrument may be any document of the highest tier — a Concordance, an Ordinance, a ratified Treatise on Tiered Authority — or, where none survives, a sworn account of its loss. Where no instrument and no account of loss exist, the Source is assigned to the Chain of Non-Origin and its provenance statement is filed blank, which many clerks find harder to accept than a false entry.

The chain-of-custody columns are cross-referenced during the Evidentiary Review & Contextual Cohesion phase of Source Authentication against the Master Provenance Ledger, and against the Ledger of Initial Anomalies where the Source is known to have moved through the lower circulatory runs. A provenance statement that agrees with the Master Ledger and disagrees with the Initial Anomalies is presumed correct. One that agrees with neither is presumed honest.

Dispute: the Ordinal and Substantive readings

The long-running Provenance Debate turns principally on whether Source Provenance inheres in the Source or is conferred upon it. The Ordinal reading, associated with the school at Palimpsest Landing and set out at length in the Doctrine of Unverifiable Provenance, holds that provenance is a posterior act of description and cannot alter the Source. The Substantive reading, favoured by the Office of Provenance and by the compilers of the Provenance Index, holds that a Source is the sum of its documented arrivals, and that a Source whose provenance is successfully challenged ceases, in a modest but real way, to be the same Source.

The disagreement is not decorative. In 407 the two readings produced opposite findings in the same case, and the matter went to the Concordance of Arrivals, which resolved nothing while appearing to. Its Annex 2 states:

"The provenance of a Source shall be taken as established where the record of it is coherent; and as taken where the record of it is not, provided the record of its incoherence is coherent."

— Concordance of Arrivals, Annex 2, clause 6

Both schools cite the clause as favourable. The Concordance of Departures, issued eleven years later and chiefly concerned with returns, contradicts it at clause 3 without naming it: "A Source shall carry its provenance unaltered from the hand that first recorded it, however altered that hand has since become." Citing either against the other is the standard method of settling an argument about provenance, and has settled none.

The Ink Provenance Project

Systematic management of fractured provenance dates from the Ink Provenance Project, initiated in 396 by Provenance Master Kael following the discovery that four ink-supply lots on Floor 218 drew on mutually exclusive origin stories, all validly attested. Kael's solution was to record provenance at the level of the medium rather than the document, so that a Source's inks could be traced even where its text could not. The project produced the ink-spiral registers, still in use, and the standing rule that no Source is to be authenticated on ink drawn from an unattested spiral.

The rule was tested badly in 409, when a clerk on Floor 62 authenticated a Concordance on ink traced to a spiral that had been struck from the registers three years earlier for reasons never recorded. Her defence — that the strike had itself no provenance — was upheld on appeal by the Office of Provenance, which then discovered it lacked the authority to restore the spiral and referred the matter to the Provenance Council. The Council has sat on the referral since. The Concords remain authenticated. The spiral remains struck.

Challenges and audits

Any Librarian of the fourth rank or above may bring Provenance Challenges, of which the most frequently cited is MAP-2, concerning a persistent discrepancy between a Source's stated aperture of entry and the wear on its first and last folios. Challenges that succeed do not remove the Source from the corpus; they re-designate it as "provenanced by dispute," which is a durable status and, by most clerks' accounting, a higher one.

Provenance Audits are initiated by the Office of Provenance at intervals it does not publish, and proceed floor by floor. Auditors work left to right along a shelf and are not permitted to close a shelf that has been opened, however late the hour. The practice is old and the reason for it has not survived in writing. Audits of Floors 40 to 44 have been under way since 381.

Practical notes

Source Provenance statements are written in iron-gall ink on the recto only. Clerks holding a Source for provenance work must return the shelf marker to the position in which they found it, whether or not they intend to return to the shelf. Reading a Source before its provenance statement is complete is discouraged but not prohibited; readers who do so are asked to record which portions they read first, as this information is now considered part of the record.

Inquiries concerning the Provenance Schism should be directed to the liaison office of the Office of Provenance near the Unending Stairwell, which receives them on alternate days and answers them on neither.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Doctrine of Unverifiable Provenance: how is it conducted?

The Doctrine of Unverifiable Provenance is a procedural framework within provenance practice that governs the intake, classification, and stewardship of Tower holdings whose chains of custody cannot be satisfactorily est…

Doctrine of Unverifiable Provenance
Provenance Index: what does it set out?

The Provenance Index is the foundational codification and classification system used throughout the Department of Provenance to record and structure the origin, custody, and amendment history—collectively, the provenance…

Provenance Index
Treatise on Tiered Authority: what does it set out?

The Treatise on Tiered Authority is a foundational document of the Registrational Oversight system, which formalizes the hierarchical and procedural stratification of administrative power within The Tower. Authored by Pr…

Treatise on Tiered Authority
Provenance Master Kael: who were they?

Provenance Master Kael (fl. 690–742) was the longest-serving Head of the Office of Provenance and the principal architect of the modern provenance-tracking protocols. Their tenure is defined by the codification of Form 8…

Provenance Master Kael

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.