The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Senior Archivist Valen

MS 4277.95 · Practices and doctrines

Senior Archivist Valen is a designation carried, at various times and under disputed conditions, by no fewer than four cataloguing officers whose records the Tower has never fully separated. The designation is not a name but an office-mark, and the fact that it was held by more than one person — possibly by a sequence of persons, possibly by one person across an implausibly long service — has made it the subject of a filing controversy older than most of the floors it concerns. Third Concordance treats the designation as singular; Seventh Concordance does not, and the two have been in open disagreement since before either was last amended.

The practical difficulty is that a "Senior Archivist Valen" signed a document on Floor 112 in Tower Year 6,271, and another signed a margin-note on Floor 8,904 in Tower Year 8,410. The interval is 2,139 years. The Tower has never resolved whether these are the same hand.

The Question of the Senior Archivists

Three persons are conventionally distinguished. Archivist-Scribe Valen served as a cataloguing officer on Floor 112 from Tower Year 6,120 to 6,288, and is separately recorded as Archivist-Scribe Valen of Floor 112, though whether these are one officer or two is the matter that first split the file. The Scribe's petition to the Archon for the de-accession of the Whispering Atlas survives; the Archon's reply does not, and the Atlas remains in place.

Archivist-Superior Valen Karr authored Reflections on Jurisdictional Echoes and is the figure most often meant when the bare designation is used without qualification. Karr's seal appears on seventy-one cataloguing instruments between years 7,402 and 7,988.

Archivist-Luminary Valen held office from Tower Year 8,301 to 8,511 and is remembered for the Valen Reckoning, a revision of the office's calendar that removed eleven days from the administrative year and has never been fully reconciled with the central register. The Luminary wrote Reflections on the Mending. The chronological problem is evident: the Luminary's term begins after Karr's seal falls silent, the Scribe's term ends long before either, and yet all three signed documents bearing the identical office-mark.

Senior Assessor Valen, who heads Division VI: Unallocated Phenomena, is not a Senior Archivist and has asked, twice, in writing, that this be noted. The request has been granted once.

The Pencil Annotation

The controversy acquired its present shape in the winter of Year 7,995, when a recension clerk named Otho Mennick compared two bound registers and found that the office-mark had been altered. In the earlier register the mark read Senior Archivist Valen, in the hand of an amanuensis; in the later it read the same, in a different hand, with the final letter reinforced — twice struck, as though the writer had begun a longer word and thought better of it. Mennick's memorandum of 7,995 proposed that the mark was not a name at all but an abbreviation, and that the "Valen" of the senior office was a truncation of a longer designation whose full form had been lost.

"The mark is not a man. It is a rule, and a rule does not die and cannot be succeeded. That we have read it as a man for two thousand years is a consequence of our clerks having been trained to read names and not offices."

— Otho Mennick, Memorandum on the Office-Mark, Floor 112 register, Year 7,995

The memorandum was not accepted. It was, however, filed, and the file is now three times the length of the memorandum. Archivist-Proctor cites Mennick's memo in every procedural dispute concerning the office; Archivist-Provisional Isadora Vane has argued that the memo is inadmissible because Mennick was never confirmed in his post, a position the Proctor describes in writing as "a technicality of Mennick's own making."

Rulings and the Reckoning

Eleventh Concordance, Annex 2, holds that where two officers share an office-mark, the earlier signature governs. This is the rule the Luminary's supporters rely upon, since the Luminary's signatures fall earlier in the bound registers — though not, owing to the Reckoning's eleven missing days, in the administrative calendar. Ninth Concordance holds the opposite, that the later signature governs as the more considered. Neither annex mentions Valen by name, which both parties regard as significant.

The Valen Reckoning itself was not, as is sometimes supposed, a calendrical reform. It was a ruling of the office concerning which of its own records should be numbered from the office's founding and which from the year of the sitting officer's appointment. The Luminary's application of it shortened the office's year by eleven days and lengthened its history by four hundred. The Quarterly Report of the Senior Archivist, Floor 413, Cycle 502 records the resulting confusion with a patience that reads, in places, as exhaustion.

Current Standing

No sitting officer claims the designation. The office of Senior Archivist is presently filled by Senior Archivist Aethelred, Senior Archivist Kael, and Senior Archivist Kaelen, who administer it as a triad under a working arrangement that no Concordance authorizes and none has yet forbidden. Their arrangement does not extend to the Valen records, which remain unallocated.

Archivist Vorl was at one point designated Archivist, Senior Archivist, and Senior Taxonomist concurrently, and this is sometimes raised in argument as evidence that the Tower permits multiple office-marks on one officer. It is not clear that it is evidence of anything, and Vorl has stated that it is not.

Division VI continues to receive the file annually.

The register on Floor 112 records one standing instruction, written in a later hand beneath the office-mark: that the volumes are not to be re-shelved while the question is open. They have not been moved since 7,995. A reader wishing to consult them must apply to the floor clerk and wait, on average, nine days.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Eleventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Eleventh Concordance is a foundational administrative document ratified in Year 45 of the Third Librarianate, primarily concerned with establishing procedural guidelines for the cataloguing of non-entities and govern…

Eleventh Concordance
Archivist Vorl: who were they?

Archivist Vorl is recorded in the Tower's registers under three concurrent designations — Archivist, Senior Archivist, and Senior Taxonomist — a redundancy attributed by the Office of the Archivist to successive regradin…

Archivist Vorl
Archivist-Scribe Valen: who were they?

Archivist-Scribe Valen (fl. Tower Year 6,120 – 6,288) was a cataloguing officer of Floor 112, remembered chiefly for the petition of de-accession concerning the Whispering Atlas and for the singular procedural exception …

Archivist-Scribe Valen
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …

Ninth Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.