The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Sectorial Re-Concordance

MS 3855.94 · Practices and doctrines

The Sectorial Re-Concordance is the term by which the Tower's archive designates any of four separate reviews of Concordance texts conducted along the administrative sectors of a single floor rather than across the whole Tower. Unlike the great reconciliations — the work of Concordance Reconciliation, which consults Concordance 244 as a matter of course — a sectorial re-concordance reconciles only the portions of a Concordance that fall within one sector's jurisdiction, and leaves the remainder untouched, in dispute, or actively worse off. Four such reviews are on record: Sectors Calamus and Sennet, on floors 4,411 and 4,412; Sector Halyard, on floor 9,003; and the unfinished Sector Vellum review of floor 1,190, suspended in the winter of Y5431 and never resumed.

Procedure and the Seal of Sectorial Standing

A sectorial re-concordance begins when a sector Steward petitions the Librarians for a Seal of Sectorial Standing. The seal, once granted, limits the review to the texts physically held within the sector and forbids any finding from taking effect above the sector's ceiling arch. Petitions are rarely refused and still more rarely granted quickly; the Calamus petition waited eleven years, and the seal was finally issued to a Steward who had died in the fourth year of the wait. His successor accepted it without comment.

The reviewing clerk works from the sector's own copies, collating each page against the master text and annotating discrepancies in the margin. Under the ordinary reconciliation this is a thankless task; under the sectorial form it is a thankless task conducted in a room without windows. The standard handlist of a sectorial clerk's equipment is short:

  • one collation frame, brass, adjustable to folio;
  • one seal-press and a stand for the Seal of Sectorial Standing;
  • two ink-wells, one for findings and one for withdrawals;
  • a covered lamp, and a bucket of sand for the lamp.

The bucket is the only item on the list that is never audited and never replaced, and every sectorial chamber in the Tower has one.

The Calamus and Sennet Review

The earliest sectorial re-concordance, conducted on floor 4,411 in Y4290, was intended to clean up the portion of the Third Concordance held in Sector Calamus. That portion included Annex VII, and the reviewing clerk — one Maren Ostell, whose grievance against the Concordance Amendment Tracking desk is preserved in her margin notes — could not determine whether the Annex's supersession clause applied within her sector only or everywhere. She therefore entered a finding, filed it under seal, and declined to publish it. Neighbouring Sector Sennet, on floor 4,412, learned of the finding, assumed it had been published, and reconciled its own hold of the Second Concordance against a document it was not permitted to read. The resulting sectorial record states that the Second Concordance was superseded by the Third twice, which is not possible, though the wording is preserved in the archive out of respect for Ostell's seal.

Sector Halyard and the Fifth

The Halyard review, completed on floor 9,003 in Y5188, concerned a single damaged quire of the Fifth Concordance. Because the Third Concordance had formally superseded the Second, and because the Fifth had superseded the Fourth, the Halyard clerk reasoned that the damaged quire could be reconciled against whichever supersession remained in force at the moment of reading. He therefore left the question of which one that was to be decided on each occasion of consulting the text. The Halyard chamber has since been asked to reconcile the same quire on sixty-one separate occasions, and has given sixty-one separate answers. The office's standing note on the matter runs, in full: "The quire is reconciled. The answer varies. Consult before citing."

Dispute: Does a Sectorial Finding Bind the Floor?

Scholars disagree on whether a sectorial re-concordance, once sealed, binds the neighbouring sectors on the same floor. The Calamus record suggests that it does not, since Sennet's error arose precisely from assuming otherwise. The Halyard record suggests that it does, since the neighbouring sectors have quietly adopted Halyard's consult-before-citing practice without any amendment to their own texts. Concordance 891 is cited on both sides: it appears to hold that findings travel by floor and not by sector, but its text is cross-referenced from Concordance Update Y54315445, and the update's retroactive reconciliation of the Fifth and Seventh Concordances leaves the relevant clause ambiguous as to which document is speaking. The Concordance Findings desk has declined to resolve the point, noting that the desk resolved it in Y5190 and that the resolution was itself superseded.

A minority position, associated with the Fifteenth and defended chiefly by clerks who have worked a sectorial chamber, holds that the question is meaningless: a finding sealed within a sector cannot bind anyone outside it, but anyone who relies on the sector's text is already inside it, and so the distinction never arises. This is generally regarded as elegant and unhelpful.

The Vellum Suspension and Later Practice

Sector Vellum, on floor 1,190, began a re-concordance of the texts surrounding Concordance IX in Y5429 and suspended it two years later. The suspension order gives no reason, though the chamber's daily returns for the final month record only the words "lamp smoking" on each of thirty-one sheets. The seal remains on the chamber door and the room has not been entered since. Prospective Stewards are advised not to petition for a re-concordance of the same materials on the same floor, and no one has.

The four recorded reviews together occupy eleven shelf-feet in the sectorial annexe, of which eight are margin notes. The remaining three are the findings themselves. The 72nd Concordance treats the sectorial form in a single clause, which is more attention than it gives most procedures, and less than the clerks who performed them believe they are owed. Revisions to the practice were last discussed during the drafting of the Chronurgical Concordance and were set aside as unlikely to be needed. They have not been needed. They have, however, been requested four times.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Chronurgical Concordance: what does it set out?

The Chronurgical Concordance is the instrument, distinct from the Concordance series proper, by which the Chronurgy Guild fixes the sequence in which its own rulings take effect. It is administered jointly with the Conco…

Chronurgical Concordance
Fifteenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifteenth Concordance (official designation: Concordance XV) is a superseded legislative and administrative document of the Tower, formally invalidated in its entirety by the ratification of the Sixteenth Concordance…

Fifteenth Concordance
Concordance Findings: how is it conducted?

Concordance Findings are the class of Bureau Findings issued when a numbered Concordance document is discovered to be in contradiction with another Concordance, with itself at an earlier recension, or with a finding it p…

Concordance Findings
Second Concordance: what does it set out?

The Second Concordance was the primary governance document of The Tower from Year 89 of the First Librarianate until its supersession by the Third Concordance in Year 12 of the Second Librarianate. It established the leg…

Second Concordance

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.