Second-Order (Environmental)
MS 4329.00 · Practices and doctrines
The term Second-Order (Environmental) designates the middle category of negative phenomena established by Ordinance 412.7. Where First-Order (Lexical) phenomena are faults of the record itself — a wandering noun, a survivor of a replaced recension, a footnoted event whose footnote has been cut out — Second-Order phenomena are faults of the fabric in which the record is kept. They are, in the Ordinance's own phrasing, the afflictions of air, surface, sound and residue: conditions that arise from the material furnishings of the Tower and must be answered by the material apparatus of the Department of Environmental Consistency.
The distinction is broadly accepted but the instrument has always been overturned. The ordinary gloss is that a First-Order phenomenon is a fault of the record; a Second-Order phenomenon is a fault of the record's setting; a Third-Order phenomenon is a fault in the standing rule under which the first two are detectable. The histories of the Department of Environmental Consistency are almost entirely a record of the third category masquerading as the second.
Definition and classification
Ordinance 412.7 devotes a single paragraph to each of the first two orders. Its paragraph on the second reads: "The Environmental order is any negative phenomenon whose cause does not inhabit the record, but the medium in which that record lies open, and which may be corrected without altering the record or its citation." A footnote of the same paragraph, unaccountably numbered 'ii' for a page otherwise set in Arabic numerals, advises that the Local Office of Measured Exceptions should be consulted before any division of the environmental from the lexical is defended.
Under the Ordinance, correct handling is by reference to the procedures of the Environmental Control Ordinances, which place a survey and stabilisation hierarchy in the hands of the Department of Environmental Consistency. It has been the practical experience of the Department that the surveys are the part that works, and the hierarchy the part that does not.
Testing and the 96-cycle tone
Second-Order phenomena are ordinarily detected by Environmental Resonance Testing in the manner standardised by Guild Standard 22-Σ. The standard prescribes a testing tone of 96 cycles per second, and the current maintained figure is the same to the fourth decimal place. The origin of the figure is a matter of dispute; the Registrar of Weights has ruled that it is not germane to the use of the figure.
Testing for Second-Order signs is conducted by a surveyor of the Department of Environmental Consistency in the company of a witness drawn from the floor's own staff, and a survey that proceeds without a witness is void as evidence but not void as a survey. The practice is the opposite for the tone: the tone is sounded without a witness, and the record of it is attested by a second sounding.
Two schools of practice
Departments of the Environmental Sequestration school hold that a second-order sign is a disturbance of a place and should be confined to it, and that the correct instrument is the Environmental Stasis Fields of Annex 4-B of the Theta-7 Stasis Order. The school is established on its own floor and has never consented to move the apparatus, which is built of the same material as the enclosing stairwell.
Against this is the doctrine of the Environmental Inversion school: that a sign is not overcome but reversed, and that a stabilised second-order phenomenon is merely a first-order phenomenon under restraint, and so gives hazardous readings. The more severe members of the Inversion school hold that the second order should be read as the first order read backwards, and that the whole environmental apparatus is a way of not reading at all.
The Second Concordance cites oneiric feedback as a logistical hazard of the third order, which has not settled the disagreement but has given it a principle of sorts. The Second Concordance, Addendum 3, Clause VII is invoked by the Sequestration school to the effect that a confined hazard is a hazard of its own place, while the Inversion school maintains that the clause is being read as nonsense. The Order of the Calculated Rise has taken an interest in both, and the Second Concordance Addendum 3 of Clause Vii is often cited in the halls on both sides, none of which settles the matter.
The counter-attempt of 2,412
In the year 2,412 a junior examiner of the lower readings, a clerk named Kavel Orrun, attempted personally to certify a second-order disturbance as first-order, having first removed its citation. The ensuing change did not remove the sign; it approximated it to a condensation forming on the inner face of a shelf and ran from the floor's brass line to the stairwell. The Department of Environmental Consistency was compelled to declare an Environmental Contingencies at Environmental Monitoring and to append a note to the survey. The note is now the standard form of the reading, and it is not known in the other order.
The mirror precedent
There is a strong, now standard, objection that the same criticism cuts against the imposition of a stasis field: that the field, while in force, turns every second-order phenomenon within it into a first-order phenomenon. The point is recorded in the margin of the Environmental Survey conducted at the Annex, and the practice has been to certify the field's effect as a second-order phenomenon in the second degree. No Comprehensive register has been searched and the reading remains one of some convenience. The pages have been annotated by three successive handwritings, and the most recent of them appears to be trying to answer the two earlier on the subject of the witness. The correspondence cannot be independent of the annual sound of the testing tone.
See also
-
MS 5509.03
School of Negative Phenomena
School of Negative Phenomena is a formal academic and procedural discipline concerned with the cataloging, analysis, and stabiliza…
-
MS 7482.69
Ordinance of Perilous Ambience
The Ordinance of Perilous Ambience, formally designated as Ordinance 23.Δ, is a regulatory instrument governing environmental cond…
-
MS 8740.51
Negative Phenomena
Negative phenomena are the observable manifestations and archival consequences of documented absences, voids, and inversions withi…
-
MS 6949.13
Negative Folios
Negative Folios are an administrative category of document maintained by the Registrar of Negative Integers for the formal catalog…
-
MS 6698.86
Class Beta (Radiant)
Class Beta (Radiant) designates a category of Class Beta unattainable directives whose specific logical or physical impossibility …
-
MS 7444.28
Incident of the Wandering Resonance
The Incident of the Wandering Resonance was a series of unauthorized, self-sustaining auditory phenomena that began within the Wan…
Referenced by
- MS 8740.51 Negative Phenomena
- MS 9402.94 First-Order (Lexical)
Readers also asked
Ordinance 412.7: what does it set out?
Ordinance 412.7, formally titled the Ordinance on Parallax Verification of Distances, is a regulatory instrument governing the proper measurement of spatial intervals within the Tower, particularly those subject to non-E…
Ordinance 412.7Second Concordance, Addendum 3, Clause VII: what does it set out?
The Second Concordance, Addendum 3, Clause VII is a foundational legal instrument within the Tower's administrative corpus, serving as the constitutive charter for the Librarian Order and defining the standard linear uni…
Second Concordance, Addendum 3, Clause VIIDepartment of Environmental Consistency: how is it conducted?
The Department of Environmental Consistency is the Tower body charged with the authorization of Environmental Stasis Fields, the declaration of Environmental Contingencies, and the oversight of the Environmental Control …
Department of Environmental ConsistencyOrder of the Calculated Rise: how is it conducted?
Order of the Calculated Rise is the Collegiate Guild sanctioned under the Twenty-Second Concordance Annex 8 for the design, certification, and maintenance of all primary vertical transitways between floors of The Tower. …
Order of the Calculated RiseReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 3281.10 Annex 4-B of the Theta-7 Stasis Order
Because you consulted