The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Rhetorical Overdetermination

MS 2327.87 · Practices and doctrines

Definition

Rhetorical Overdetermination is the condition in which an item, structure, or argument is supplied with more justificatory support than its load can bear, such that the surplus justification ceases to reinforce the item and begins instead to deform it. The phenomenon was first named in the marginalia of a structural survey conducted on Floor 312 in the autumn of Floor 312's fourth recension, and was not formally recognised until the Department of Structural Verifications issued its provisional finding, later folded into the Manual of Acceptable Strain as Annex 7.

Overdetermination is distinct from ordinary rhetorical excess. An overargued beam is merely tedious; an overdetermined one is measurably changed. Survey parties report that such members acquire a slight forward lean, an auditory residue resembling distant agreement, and a tendency to cite themselves.

Relation to Rhetorical Filigree

The mechanics of the condition are inseparable from the behaviour of Rhetorical Filigree. Because the alloy's physical properties respond to the complexity and validity of the justifications accompanying its placement, an overdetermined joint is one in which those properties have been tuned past the point of usefulness. The Architects' Guild maintains that the alloy has a saturation threshold and that beyond it the surplus justification is simply wasted; the Logic Guild disputes this, holding that surplus justification is never wasted but merely relocated, and appears again somewhere else in the structure, usually a floor below.

Both positions are cited in the Edict of Filigree Reinforcement, which in Section 9 requires that any filigree placement accompanied by more than three supporting citations be inspected for overdetermination before the mortar sets. The requirement is widely ignored. A survey of Annex B workshops carried out in the winter of Floor 71 found that fewer than one in nine placements had been inspected, and that the inspecting clerks had themselves cited the Edict so extensively in their reports that the reports required inspection.

The Saturation Question

No figure for the saturation threshold has ever been agreed. The Third Concordance sets it at eleven concurrent justifications per load-bearing member, while the Fourth Concordance — written some decades later and never reconciled with the third — fixes it at four, on the grounds that the third Concordance's figure had been arrived at by counting the same justification twice under different headings. The Department of Rhetorical Consistency, created as a sub-department following Bench Ruling 45, has declined to arbitrate, noting in its standing minute of Floor 44 that "the question of how many reasons a wall may have is not, strictly, a question about walls."

"Where a member is supported by reasons exceeding its requirement, the surplus shall be understood to support not the member but the argument for the member, and to be catalogued accordingly."

— Manual of Acceptable Strain, Annex 7, clause 3

The practical consequence of this clause is that overdetermined members are entered twice in the Department of Structural Verifications catalogue: once under their Rhetorical Load-Bearing Walls designation, and once under a supplementary series recording the argument. The supplementary series is longer than the walls it describes.

The Floor 208 Incident

The clearest documented case remains the collapse of the eastern mezzanine on Floor 208, in the spring of the year the Index of Unspoken Prefaces was rebound. The mezzanine had been reinforced over three successive audits, each audit adding justifications without removing those of its predecessor. By the third audit the supporting documentation for a single balustrade ran to two hundred and six leaves, bound in three volumes, and the balustrade had begun to lean toward the reading desks.

The collapse occurred at the hour when the volumes were shelved alongside it. Investigators from the Department of Structural Verifications found that the failure had originated not in the metal but in a footnote on leaf one hundred and forty-one, in which a previous auditor had justified the balustrade by reference to itself. The self-citation was accurate, which under the Manual of Acceptable Strain made it admissible, and under the same Manual made it fatal. The department's report recommended, without enthusiasm, that no member be permitted to support its own argument, and this recommendation was circulated for comment and has not been resolved.

Overdetermination and the Gallery

Rhetorical Overdetermination bears on admission to The Gallery of Silent Rebuttals through the Principle of Rhetorical Exhaustion formalised in the Fourth Concordance. An item whose justifications have exhausted their own subject — leaving nothing further to be said for or against it — is held to have entered the condition the Gallery exists to house. Curators of the Gallery of Silent Rebuttals have objected that this confuses a structural fault with a curatorial category, and that the Gallery is not a place for things that were argued at too well. The objection is recorded in the Gallery's register and has itself been cited so often that the register entry is now flagged for overdetermination.

Scholars of Tonal Realism have taken the opposite view, arguing that tone and categorical confidence are the primary reinforcing agents and that an item cannot be overdetermined, only under-toned. This position is not well regarded by the Department of Structural Verifications, which has noted that Tonal Realism, if applied to filigree, would render the Non Canonical Filigree series structurally sound, a conclusion no survey party has been willing to certify.

Maintenance Note

Members flagged for overdetermination are inspected at intervals of no more than nine years. Clerks conducting the inspection are reminded to bring a second pen.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Rhetorical Filigree: what is it for?

Rhetorical Filigree is a class of ductile metal alloys whose physical properties are directly influenced by the complexity and validity of the administrative justifications accompanying their placement within the Tower’s…

Rhetorical Filigree
Architects' Guild: who are they?

The Architects’ Guild is the legally recognized body for the design, certification, and maintenance of all structural transitions between catalogued floors, most notably Stairwells, Spiral Apertures, and Interstitial Lan…

Architects' Guild
Logic Guild: who are they?

The Logic Guild is the formal administrative body responsible for the maintenance, adjudication, and periodic recalibration of logical systems within the operational floors of The Tower. It holds primary jurisdiction ove…

Logic Guild
The Gallery of Silent Rebuttals: where is it?

The Gallery of Silent Rebuttals is a subsidiary archive sector located on Spire 209, cataloguing evidentiary and rhetorical materials deemed to have conclusively resolved a point of contention, thereby rendering further …

The Gallery of Silent Rebuttals

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.