The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Justificatory Archaeology

MS 2093.32 · Practices and doctrines

Justificatory Archaeology is the practice of recovering, from stratified deposits, the reasons that were once given for things that had already been done. It is distinguished from its parent discipline, Procedural Archaeology, by its object: where the procedural archaeologist excavates the acts themselves, the justificatory archaeologist excavates the arguments later laid down over them, usually in thin and badly bonded layers. The field is taught principally through the Department of Procedural Archaeology, whose On the Excavation of Quantified Contexts devotes its fourth chapter to the problem of reasoning that has been compressed by subsequent overburden.

Principles of deposition

Justifications accumulate in a manner broadly analogous to sediment. A decision is taken; a reason for it is deposited shortly afterward, often within the same working day; further reasons are laid down as the decision is questioned, each stratum thinner and more defensive than the last. The earliest deposits are typically the most coherent and the least consulted. Under sufficient pressure — a review, an audit, a change of Librarian — the whole column may be inverted, so that the reason now cited at the surface bears no stratigraphic relation to the act it purports to explain.

The practice recognises three principal classes of deposit. Primary justifications are contemporaneous with the act and usually survive only in summary. Secondary justifications are deposited after the fact and are the most abundant. Residual justifications are those left behind by offices that no longer exist and cannot now be attributed to anyone; these are the most frequently cited in dispute, on the grounds that they cannot be contradicted.

Excavation proceeds by the removal of context in reverse order of confidence. A justificatory archaeologist working a contested floor will first lift the most recent rationale, record it in full, and set it aside before proceeding to the one beneath. The method is slow. It is not unusual for a single determination to occupy a team for two winters, particularly where the deposit has been disturbed by a Certificate of Retrospective Existence issued during the intervening period.

The Vellum Horizon

Between the ninth and the fourteenth courses of most administrative floors lies a band of densely compacted memoranda known as the Vellum Horizon. Its defining feature is that justifications within it are unusually complete and unusually useless: every reason is present, fully attributed, and sealed, but the acts they justify have been lost to erosion. The Horizon was first described in the survey notes of Archivist Marnie Ostell, who recorded at Floor 1066 that she had "recovered forty-one excellent reasons and no decision whatsoever to attach them to" (Ostell, Survey Notes, Floor 1066, entry of 3 Frostmonth).

Work in the Horizon requires a permit, and the permits are granted in the order in which applications are received, except where they are not. Ostell herself was refused a renewal on the grounds that her earlier permit had not been returned, though she had returned it, and the receipt is held in the same annex that has since lost her application.

Dispute: the status of negative justification

The principal scholarly disagreement in the field concerns negative justification — the reason deposited for a thing that was deliberately not done. The Statistical School of Numerological Archaeology holds that a negative justification is a deposit like any other and may be excavated, counted, and dated by the ordinary methods. Against this, the Chronological Purist School maintains that nothing was deposited, and that what the statistical practitioners are excavating is the absence of a deposit, which is not a stratum but a gap in one, and that to date a gap is to date the weather.

The matter was referred to the Third Concordance, which had previously settled a related question. The relevant annexes do not agree. Annex 9 provides that "an omission, once justified in writing, shall be treated for all purposes as an act" (Third Concordance, Annex 9, clause 2). Annex 14, added eleven years later and never reconciled with it, provides that "no reason shall be recovered from a place where nothing was laid down" (Third Concordance, Annex 14, clause 7). Both annexes are in force. Practitioners have adopted the working convention of excavating negative justifications but declining to publish the results, which satisfies neither School and has the advantage of being uncontroversial at the point of filing.

The Tolliver Recension

The field's foundational case is the Tolliver Recension of Floor 1444, in which a clerk named Tolliver was asked to justify a decision he had taken forty years earlier and could not recall. Rather than report the failure, Tolliver reconstructed the reasoning from the surrounding documents and deposited the reconstruction in the ordinary form. It was accepted, filed, and cited in eleven subsequent determinations before the original decision was located in an unrelated annex and found to have been taken for entirely different reasons.

"The reconstruction was better than the reason. I have thought about this a great deal and I am not certain it is a fault."

— Tolliver, evidence to the Annex Committee, second sitting

The Recension is now taught as the standard demonstration that a recovered justification and an original justification are stratigraphically indistinguishable once both have been sealed. It is also the reason that justificatory archaeologists are required to state, on the first page of every report, which of the two they believe they have found. Most state that they believe they have found the first. The Bureau of Universal Précis has twice recommended that the declaration be moved to the last page, where it would be read after the evidence rather than instead of it.

Method and complaint

Fieldwork is conducted under the general shoring provisions of the Department, and interventions exceeding twelve Support-Equivalents require dual-signature authorization. The signatures must be those of two distinct Librarians. In the winter of the Ostell refusal, a team on Floor 1066 submitted a shoring request bearing the same signature twice, entered in different inks, and the request was processed without comment; the floor has since settled by a further four courses.

The Bureau of Curatorial Acquisitions acquires justificatory assemblages for the permanent collection, though it will not accept them loose. Assemblages must arrive bonded to the act they justify or, where the act is unavailable, accompanied by a notarised statement of its loss. The Retrospective Procurement School has argued for many years that this requirement is unreasonable and that the Bureau should accept reasons on their own merits. The Bureau has not replied to the correspondence, and the correspondence is now itself a deposit of some interest to the field.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Retrospective Procurement School: who are they?

The Retrospective Procurement School is a formal curatorial and philosophical institution concerned with the ethical and procedural justification of acquisitions made without a pre-existing ontological warrant. It is a r…

Retrospective Procurement School
Statistical School of Numerological Archaeology: how is it conducted?

Statistical School of Numerological Archaeology was a dominant methodological faction within the practice of Numerological Archaeology during the late Consolidation Period. It advocated for the use of quantitative measur…

Statistical School of Numerological Archaeology
Chronological Purist School: how is it conducted?

The Chronological Purist School represents a significant doctrinal evolution within Purist thought that emerged in the late 4th-century Tower, distinct from both the Literalist and the Latent Structure schools. It posits…

Chronological Purist School
On the Excavation of Quantified Contexts: what does it set out?

On the Excavation of Quantified Contexts is a departmental treatise of the Department of Procedural Archaeology, issued in the winter of 412-Σ and revised four times since, which formally codified the two core axioms of …

On the Excavation of Quantified Contexts

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.