The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Re Receivers of Absence

MS 2835.11 · Practices and doctrines

Re Receivers of Absence is the standing annotation appended to the second recension of the instrument schedule governing the Receivers of Absence, issued to resolve the persistent confusion between the Guild's apparatus and the Guild's officers. The phrase is not a title and belongs to no single document; it is the formula by which copyists mark any passage in which the words "Receiver of Absence" might refer either to a calibrated instrument of the Realized Absence Guild or to a member of the body that operates it. The annotation was first entered in the margin by the recorder Sister Amarine Vesk in the winter of the year recorded as Floor 4311, and has been carried forward by every subsequent recension, including those that no longer contain the passage it was written to clarify.

Origin and disputed authorship

The annotation arose from the so-called Morning of Two Columns, when the schedule for Receiver-Complex Theta was copied by two scriptoria on the same day and emerged with contradictory headings. The Theta copy read "Receivers of Absence, instrumental, hereinafter the Receivers"; the Annex copy read "Receivers of Absence, custodial, hereinafter the Receivers." Both copies were sealed. The dispute that followed occupied the Standing Committee on Instrumental Ambiguity for a period given variously as nine months and forty years, and was settled only by the entry of the marginal note, which reads in full:

"Where the text says Receiver, read the brass unless the clause concerns a bell or a quarrel, in which case read the person. Where it concerns both, read twice."

— Concordance 88, Annex 3, marginal recension

Attribution of the formula is contested. The Librarians' Register of Marginalia credits Vesk. The Theta Scriptorium Ledger enters it under the hand of an unnamed corrector and notes only that the corrector was paid in lamp-oil and did not sign. No Scholar-Ordinary has been willing to rule on the matter, and the Forty-Second Concordance declines to address it on the grounds that "marginal matter is not matter."

Function in the schedule

The annotation's practical effect is to make the instrument schedule self-correcting. A clause that reads "the Receiver shall be brought to temperature before use" is read as referring to brass; a clause that reads "the Receiver shall not be brought to temperature" is read as referring to a person, and to a prohibition dating from the Overheating of the Ninth Landing. The reading is mechanical and may be applied by any clerk of the second grade without reference to the original dispute.

The formula does not resolve every passage. A celebrated failure is recorded at Floor 6118, where a clause requiring the Receiver to be "witnessed by two of the Witnesses of Absence" was applied to an instrument, and two witnesses were accordingly dispatched to sit with a brass receiver for eleven days. Their report, filed as Witness Report 6118-C, observes that the receiver neither moved nor was expected to, and that the arrangement was "in all respects regular." The report was accepted without amendment.

Relation to the Receivers proper

Because the annotation treats the two senses as a single grammatical person, later compilers have occasionally treated them as a single office. The error is common in third-recension copies, which frequently merge the entry for instrumental Receivers with that for the custodial body. The Designated Receivers have lodged four protests against such mergers since the annotation entered general use, each arguing that the merged reading assigns to instruments the custodial authority over Jurisdictionally Un-Rung bells that properly belongs to persons. The most recent protest, filed by Receiver-Adjutant Orne Hasp, notes that no instrument has ever accepted custody of a bell and that the schedule should not imply otherwise.

The counter-position is maintained by the Office of Concordant Recension, which holds that the merged reading is the intended one and that the distinction between brass and person is a copyist's convenience rather than a doctrinal fact. The Office's position paper, On the Indifference of Substance to Schedule, argues that the Receivers of Absence are best understood as a single class of things capable of receiving absence, of which some are maintained and some are sworn. This view is not accepted at Theta, where the instruments are calibrated using Diagram Theta and would be ruined by swearing.

Notable recensions and errors

Five recensions of the annotation are held in the Archive of Second Readings on Floor 1889. The second recension omits the words "or a quarrel" and consequently produced, between its issue and its withdrawal, a series of rulings in which jurisdictional disputes were entered against instruments. These rulings were vacated by the Concordance of Vacated Entries in a single sitting, though the instruments themselves were not informed, as the practice of informing instruments was discontinued in the same year for reasons the record does not give.

The fourth recension adds a sentence not found in any earlier copy — "and in cases of Absence Flux, read the brass on Thursdays" — which appears in no Concordance and is believed to be the private note of a corrector who has never been identified. The Standing Committee on Instrumental Ambiguity has twice voted to strike it and twice failed to agree on the wording of the strike. It remains in the text, and Thursdays at Receiver-Complex Theta are observed accordingly.

Current standing

The annotation is presently in its fifth recension and is printed in the front matter of every instrument schedule issued since the Revision of the Second Column. It is read aloud at the opening of each calibration at Theta, after the instruments have been brought to temperature and before Diagram Theta is unrolled. Visitors to the calibration chamber are asked to stand for the reading and to leave their coats on the hook by the door, as the chamber is kept cold for the brass.

No further amendment is pending. The Committee has noted, without resolving, that the formula "read twice" has never been defined as to order, and that clerks who read the clause backwards have so far produced no ruling that any party has seen fit to appeal.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Witnesses of Absence: how is it conducted?

Witnesses of Absence are the sworn officers whose testimony establishes that something is not present. They are not witnesses to absence in the loose sense used by lay floors, but witnesses of it: the absence is the subj…

Witnesses of Absence
Witness of Absence: how is it conducted?

Witness of Absence (also Absential Witness or Formal Attestor) is an accredited professional, licensed by the Realized Absence Guild, whose primary function is to observe and formally attest to the condition, properties,…

Witness of Absence
Receiver-Complex Theta: where is it?

Receiver-Complex Theta is an acoustic isolation and measurement facility situated within Spiral Theta's main resonance column. It is the primary terminus for acoustic anomalies routed by the Office of the Receiver of Irr…

Receiver-Complex Theta
Diagram Theta: what is it for?

Diagram Theta is the administrative designation for a unique cartographic artefact categorized under Ambivalent Artefacts, Class Theta and housed within Spiral Theta. It is a certified Latent Structural Diagram that empi…

Diagram Theta

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.