The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Quill of the First Amendment

MS 8843.02 · Objects and instruments

Description

The Quill of the First Amendment is a writing instrument held under the custodianship of the Protocols Directorate, recorded as the reference implement for all amendatory entered into the Concordance series. It measures 214 mm in length, weighs 41 grams, and is barbed at the nib in a manner consistent with early scriptorial stock. Its quill barrel bears an incised ordinal — I — which the Directorate maintains is an original marking and not a later addition.

The instrument is not, despite frequent assumptions by visiting cataloguers, the quill used to write the First Concordance itself. The Directorate has issued this clarification on no fewer than nine occasions, most recently under Concordance 88, Annex 3.

Custody and provenance

The Quill passed to the Protocols Directorate at the founding of that office, though the instrument's earlier custodians are recorded inconsistently. The register of Floor 302 lists it as transferred "from the hand of the amendment-clerk of the era," a designation that resolves to no named individual. A marginal note in the same register attributes prior custody to Hesper Quill, an attribution the Directorate regards as unsupported but has never formally struck.

Physical custody alternates between a sealed alcove on Floor 302 and a portable case used for ratification ceremonies. During the ceremony for the Seventh Concordance Amendment 4, the case was found to contain the Quill of Concordance instead; the substitution was discovered after the signing and has never been satisfactorily explained. Both instruments were returned to their correct locations the following week.

Amendatory use

The Quill of the First Amendment is employed only at the moment of ratification, when an amendment is struck into force. It is not used for drafting, consultation, or marginal correction — a distinction enforced with some vigor by the Directorate's under-keepers. In the Year of the Quill 114, a junior keeper used the Quill to annotate a draft copy of The Delegation is Procedural during the dispute raised by Kaelen of the Subscript; the annotation was later ruled a nullity, and the draft was reissued.

The instrument is said to leave a mark that does not fade at the same rate as ordinary ink. Whether this constitutes an official property of the Quill or an observation recorded once and repeated thereafter is a matter the Bureau of Metric Reconciliation has declined to adjudicate.

Scholarly disagreement

Two readings of the Quill's status persist in the literature. The first, associated with the annotation appended to the Seventeenth Concordance, holds that the Quill confers the authority of the amendment itself — that a document signed with it is amended regardless of quorum. The second, set out in Concordance 88 proper, holds that the Quill is ceremonial and that ratification depends on the presence of three witnesses named in the Concordance of the day.

The contradiction is unresolved. In practice the Quill is produced at every ratification, and no amendment signed with it has been successfully voided on procedural grounds, which some readers treat as evidence for the first position and others as evidence that no one has yet tried hard enough.

Related instruments

The Quill of the First Amendment should not be confused with the Sanctioned Quill of Errosion (see also The Sanctioned Quill of Erasure), the Standard Issue Quill Concordance Model, or the Recurrence Quill. It is also distinct from the Quill of Concordance, which has on occasion been mis-shelved under the Errosion designation. A full concordance of quills appears in the Synod of the Quill record.

The Adherents of the Fading Quill maintain a devotional interest in all instruments bearing an ordinal mark, but the Directorate has never granted them access to Floor 302. Visitors should note that the alcove is unlit and that the under-keepers do not care to be asked why.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Standard Issue Quill Concordance Model: how is it conducted?

The Standard Issue Quill Concordance Model (catalogue mark SIQ-CM, eleventh recension) is the Tower's benchmark apparatus for determining whether a given quill is in concordance with itself. The question is less abstract…

Standard Issue Quill Concordance Model
Bureau of Metric Reconciliation: who are they?

The Bureau of Metric Reconciliation is one of the four reconciliation bureaux whose overlapping remits are recorded but never consolidated, and the only one whose founding instrument has been amended more times than it h…

Bureau of Metric Reconciliation
Quill of Concordance: what is it for?

Quill of Concordance refers to any of the 17 ceremonial marking instruments ratified under specific clauses of the Seventh Concordance for use in the inscription and amendment of Concordance documents. Their usage is dis…

Quill of Concordance
Sanctioned Quill of Errosion: how is it conducted?

Sanctioned Quill of Errosion is the administrative designation for a chronic mis-cataloguing error, originating on Floor 7,412 (“The Atrium of Minor Corrosions”), pertaining to the object formally known as The Sanctioned…

Sanctioned Quill of Errosion
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.