The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Provisional Seal

MS 2194.07 · Practices and doctrines

The Provisional Seal is the collective term for the class of marks authorised to authenticate instruments whose standing is not yet settled. It is not a single object. The Keeper of Provisional Archives maintains that the term covers eleven distinct dies, four of which have never been struck and one of which is missing; the Hall of Provisional Whispers enters twelve in its registry and declines to say which. Instruments bearing a Provisional Seal are valid, binding, and subject to revision — a combination the Tower has found workable for the better part of six centuries.

Provisional Seals are distinguished from final seals by the manner of their lifting rather than the manner of their affixing. A final seal is removed by authority; a Provisional Seal is removed by expiry, by supersession, or by the slow inattention of the office that applied it.

Composition of the class

The class is conventionally divided into the witnessing seals and the operative seals. The witnessing seals attest that a thing exists in the form described. The Seal of Provisional Authenticity belongs to this group: it is stamped on instruments, pigments, and persons whose authenticity is regarded as established but not yet settled, and it does not by itself confer any standing. The operative seals confer standing for a term. Chief among them are the Provisional Sigil (Ψ), applied during Provisional Inscription, and the Provisional Sigil proper, which seals provisional grants and is not to be confused with the Seal of Provisional Authenticity despite the near-identity of their common names in the older recensions.

Two members of the class are restricted to particular instruments. The Section 7.4 seal attests composition rather than standing and appears only on instruments of partitioned material; the Seal of the Half-Open Aperture was affixed to each original Provisional Shelving Directive and to nothing since. The Seal of Provisional Continuance granted Cycle 412 a provisional term of one hundred years, renewable by silent assent, and its die has been held in reserve since the renewal of Cycle 512.

Certain marks are sometimes counted within the class and sometimes not. The Apportionment Seal, the Vitreous Seal, and the directive seals issued under Aperture Seal Directive 7-Alpha are all provisional in effect, but the Seal-Wardens maintain that a seal is provisional only if its die carries the Ψ understrike, and none of the three does.

Procedure and the case of Clerk Ademund

Application of a Provisional Seal requires a sponsoring office, a term stated in years, and a counter-signature from the Department of Provisional Archives. The term is entered on the face of the instrument in words and again in figures; where the two disagree, the words govern. Where the words are illegible, the instrument is returned to the sponsoring office without comment.

The rule was tested in the winter of 788, when a clerk of the Fourth Scriptorium, Ademund of the Lower Verges, sealed a schedule of shelf clearances with a term written as "seventeen" in figures and "seventy" in words. The sponsoring office had intended seventy and said so. The Hall of Provisional Whispers ruled that the words governed, that the clearance schedule therefore ran for seventy years, and that Ademund's error had extended the closure of two galleries by fifty-three years beyond its intended span. Ademund was not disciplined. He was reassigned to the reading of terms in words, a post he held until his death and in which he is remembered as meticulous.

Lifting and lapse

A Provisional Seal lapses at the end of its term without ceremony. No instrument need be surrendered, no counter-mark applied, no notice given; the seal simply ceases to attest, and the document it sealed becomes what the Tower calls "quiet paper" — readable, citable, and without effect. Instruments under Seal 9-C (Provisional) demonstrate the principle: the final form of the Elara Proto-Notations is held under that seal, and its term is recorded nowhere the public registry can reach.

Lapse may be forestalled by silent assent, the mechanism by which an unopposed term is renewed in the absence of any act at all. Silent assent was held in Provisional Directive 401.7b to run from the date the sponsoring office last read the instrument rather than the date of sealing. The distinction has proved expensive. Nine offices now require an annual reading aloud of every provisional instrument in their keeping, and one, the Office of Cleared Shelving, reads its instruments to a witness who signs a register confirming that the reading occurred.

Disputed numbering

The Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, fixes the number of Provisional Seals at nine and forbids the creation of further dies. The Seventh Concordance, Annex 2, fixes the number at twelve and provides a procedure for striking a thirteenth, which has never been invoked. The Hall of Provisional Whispers enters twelve; the Keeper of Provisional Archives counts eleven and has asked the Seal-Wardens to inspect the missing sixth die, a request outstanding since 901.

"Where a register and a keeper disagree as to the count of seals, the register shall be presumed correct until the keeper has counted in the presence of two Librarians. No such counting has yet been requested."

— Seventh Concordance, Annex 2, clause 6

Two Librarians have, in fact, been requested. Neither attended, both pleading the press of the Seal Integrity audit, and the count remains at eleven or twelve depending on the reader and the hour.

Practical notes

Provisional Seals are struck in sealing wax over a linen tape, in the colour designated for their class: red for witnessing seals, green for operative, and black for the two restricted dies, which are struck only in the presence of the Keeper. The wax is not to be warmed by breath. Instruments returned to a sponsoring office for correction are not to be re-sealed over the original strike; a second seal applied to a previously sealed instrument is void, and the instrument with it. Visitors to the Whispers' registry room are asked to leave their bags at the desk.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Department of Provisional Archives: who are they?

The Department of Provisional Archives is the office of the Tower charged with the custody, provisional numbering, and eventual disposition of documents, artifacts, and phenomena whose status as holdings has not yet been…

Department of Provisional Archives
Seal-Wardens: who are they?

Seal-Wardens are specialists certified under the Seal Affixation Protocols to perform preparatory and observational duties prior to the application of high-order seals by their designated Keepers. Their authority is deri…

Seal-Wardens
Provisional Sigil (Ψ): what is it for?

Provisional Sigil (Ψ) denotes the standardized glyph appended to a submission's provisional shelf-mark to invoke Provisional Reality, thereby granting a subject temporary, conditional reality within The Tower for the pur…

Provisional Sigil (Ψ)
Keeper of Provisional Archives: who are they?

The Keeper of Provisional Archives is the officer of the Department of Provisional Archives charged with the custody, provisional numbering, and eventual disposition of holdings that have not yet been confirmed as holdin…

Keeper of Provisional Archives

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.