The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Provisional Reality Seal

MS 2348.63 · Objects and instruments

The Provisional Reality Seal is the notarized stamp applied to an inventory log under which the described properties of a holding are legally bound to the physical space of its assigned floor for a renewable period of one centicycle. It is distinct from the Seal of Provisional Authenticity, which attests to a document's origin rather than a holding's location, and from the Provisional Sigil (Ψ), which is a marking and not an instrument. The Seal is issued only by the Clerk of Provisional Reality, who has maintained the issuing die since its formalization under Concordance 3, Clause 11, and whose standing instructions govern every application of it.

The Seal does not confer reality. That is a common misreading, and the Provisional Reality Practice has corrected it in three separate circulars. The Seal confers situs: it fixes a provisionally real holding to a floor, so that the holding may be said to be somewhere. A holding without a Seal is not unreal; it is unplaced, which the Practice treats as the graver condition.

Form and impression

The die is of cold-worked brass, 41 millimetres across, and carries the Tower's aperture mark within a border of nine lobes. The nine lobes are conventional and have been nine since the earliest surviving impression, taken on Floor 1142 in the winter of the year the Provisional Ledger was rebound. An impression is valid only if the lobes are legible; a partial impression is void and must be struck again on a fresh log, the spoiled log being retained and marked nil in the margin.

Impressions are taken in a wax compounded of beeswax and a mineral filler whose composition is recorded in Appendix Rho but is not reproduced in the working manual, on the ground that clerks who know the recipe begin to improvise. A clerk on Floor 86 is recorded as having added lampblack to darken the impression. The addition was undetectable for four centicycles and then, in a warm season, caused the wax to bleed through three leaves of the adjacent log. The Clerk of Provisional Reality ruled the affected entries unplaced and required re-impression; the clerk's name was not entered in the register, and the Practice's circular on the matter refers to them only as "the clerk on 86."

Procedure and its failures

The Seal is applied to the inventory log, not to the holding. This is the point on which nearly all disputes turn. A holding may be perfectly described and richly attested and still be unsealed, because the log itself was never stamped; conversely, a log may bear a clean impression and describe a holding that has since been removed, in which case the Seal binds the description to the floor and the floor is thereafter spoken of as occupied.

The renewal period of one centicycle is short by design. The Clerk's standing instructions require the holder to present the log in person, or by a sworn proxy whose proxy warrant bears a Provisional Seal, at or before expiry. Lapsed Seals are not annulled automatically; they enter a state the Practice calls pending lapse, during which the holding remains bound to its floor but may not be cited in support of a Provisional Reality Assessment. Holdings have been known to remain in pending lapse for eleven centicycles, occupying floor space and generating correspondence, because no one could establish who held the proxy warrant for the original presentation.

"A Seal renewed in the absence of the holding is renewed nonetheless, and the floor answers for it."

— Provisional Reality Practice, Circular 19, on lapsed presentations

Dispute: the sixty-day Seal

A persistent disagreement concerns whether a Seal may be struck for a period shorter than one centicycle. The Provisional Ledger records that early impressions were taken "for the turning of a season," which the Office of the Archivist-Provisional read as a fixed term of sixty days and the Clerk's office read as a description and not a term. The question was put to Concordance 4, Annex 2, which holds that no instrument of provisional standing may be struck for a term the Tower cannot measure; and to Concordance 6, Clause 9, which holds that the Clerk may strike for any term "the floor will bear."

The two have never been reconciled. In practice the Clerk strikes only full centicycles and the question is raised, annually and without resolution, at the reading of the Provisional Ledger's preamble. A minority position, associated with the scriptorium on Floor 707, argues that the sixty-day Seal survives in the form of the provisional binding used for short-term transfers between adjacent floors, and that the dispute is therefore moot; the Clerk's office has not commented on this argument, which the scriptorium takes as assent and the Clerk's office takes as silence.

The Floor 331 incident

In the winter of the year the Budgetary Reality annex was revised, a run of 240 Seals was struck on Floor 331 against a single inventory log covering four holdings that occupied, between them, less than the log's own shelf. The application was regular in every particular and was not questioned at the time. Within two centicycles the holdings began to be cited in assessments on other floors, and the floor itself was recorded as having three more rooms than its plan allowed. The Clerk of Provisional Reality, detecting anomalous self-reference within the sealed holding, initiated a Descent Into a Provisional Reality and returned with an inventory and no conclusion. The extra rooms were struck from the plan; the Seals were not revoked; the log remains on Floor 331 and is consulted by appointment.

Records

Every impression is entered in the Provisional Ledger by date, floor, lobe count and holder, and the entry is countersigned. The Seal is not transferable between floors and may not be struck over an earlier impression, a prohibition stated flatly in the Certificate of Provisional Reality and repeated, without explanation, on the reverse of every blank log issued since. Blank logs are stored flat, weighted, in the scriptorium on Floor 707.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Provisional Ledger: how is it conducted?

Provisional Ledger is the principal record of the Tower in which Clerks inscribe the provisional classifications of subjects that do not exist, thereby imparting a degree of Provisional Reality to those subjects within t…

Provisional Ledger
Sixth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Sixth Concordance is the foundational governing document ratified in Year 4 of the Third Librarianate, principally concerned with the authorization, regulation, and documentation of vertical exploration within The To…

Sixth Concordance
Appendix Rho: what does it set out?

Appendix Rho is a sewn appendix to the Eleventh Concordance, classified as a "provisional annex" concerning the classification and governance of provisional reality. It is notable for establishing the Office of Provision…

Appendix Rho
Provisional Seal: how is it conducted?

The Provisional Seal is the collective term for the class of marks authorised to authenticate instruments whose standing is not yet settled. It is not a single object. The Keeper of Provisional Archives maintains that th…

Provisional Seal

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.