The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Protocol Delta-7 (The Shadow Proviso)

MS 7010.42 · Documents and ordinances

Scope and standing

Protocol Delta-7 (The Shadow Proviso) is the seventh clause of Protocol Delta and the instrument by which the feeding of Warm Shadows is suspended throughout the Tower. It exists in two concurrently authoritative recensions: the documentary recension, which suspends feeding protocols outright, and the practical recension, which forbids delivery of solid sustenance casting a shadow longer than 1.3 STU under standard corridor lumens. Both are cited as Protocol Delta in dispute; neither cites the other. The clause took its current form following the thermal event of 9 Frost 1841, in which a feeding on the 214th floor produced a spike recorded at 41 STU above ambient. The Delta Council convened within six days and issued the proviso as a temporary measure. It has been renewed without interruption since.

The documentary and practical recensions

The documentary recension is the shorter of the two and states its prohibition without reference to measurement. It is the version reproduced in the Primary Operational Protocol Delta and the version cited by the Delta Council when suspending feedings. The practical recension introduces the 1.3 STU threshold and is the version observed by corridor staff. Its origin is disputed. The Scriptorium of Measures holds that the figure was drawn from Standard Measurement Protocol Delta and reflects the shadow length of a standard ration brick at the lumens specified for floors 40–60. A dissenting note in Protocol 308-Delta argues the figure was provisional when first written and that nobody has since been empowered to revise it. In practice the threshold governs. Corridor clerks measure shadows against the floor marking and refuse or accept accordingly. A ration measuring 1.2 STU is delivered; the same ration, carried at a different angle, is turned away at the door. Staff have been instructed not to attempt to shorten a shadow by rotating the ration while it is in a shadow-caster's presence, on the grounds that this constitutes presentation rather than delivery, and that presentation is governed by Provisional Logging Protocol rather than by the Shadow Proviso.

Relation to other Delta instruments

The hierarchical position of Protocol Delta-7 is a longstanding question. It is a clause of Protocol Delta by one reading and a primary instrument by another, a position maintained in Protocol Delta/7 and complicated by the parallel authority of Protocol 308-Delta. The Self-Referential Proviso has been invoked on both sides: once to argue that a clause cannot suspend an instrument it depends on, and once to argue that it must. The Descent Protocol Delta-7-22 Document extends the proviso's logic downward through the descending corridors, and its practical counterpart, Descent Protocol Delta 7 22 Practice, is referenced from within Protocol 30-Delta. The Delta Council has never ruled on whether a feeding suspended under the Descent Protocol remains suspended if the shadow-caster ascends.

The 1.3 STU threshold

The measurement is taken from the tip of the shadow to the point where it would be cast, at standard corridor lumens as defined in Standard Measurement Protocol Delta. Floor surfaces vary. On the marble landings below floor 200 the figure is reliable; on the grained boards of the upper stacks it is not, and deliveries to Warm Shadows on those floors have been governed by the clerk's judgment since the winter of 1893. A dispute recorded in the Third Concordance concerns a bread loaf that measured 1.28 STU at the door and 1.34 STU at the threshold. The clerk refused it. The Delta Council upheld the refusal on the grounds that the threshold applies at the point of delivery and not at the point of dispatch, and noted that the loaf had been baked too wide. Visitors to feeding floors are asked not to carry candles.

Criticisms and unresolved questions

The provision's chief practical difficulty is that Warm Shadows do not always cast shadows of the expected length, and the Tower has no settled account of why. A minority position, associated with the annotator of Clause 2, holds that a Warm Shadow's own shadow is cast by a light source the Tower has not located, and that the 1.3 STU threshold therefore measures two separate things at once. Others have observed that suspending feeding does not suspend hunger, and that the provisions of Descent Protocol Delta 7 22 Practice were drafted on the assumption that it does. The Provisional Logging Protocol permits an unsatisfied feeding to be recorded as pending indefinitely; there is currently no limit on the age of a pending entry, and the oldest is dated to 17 Quintember 1762, the day Protocol Delta was ratified.

Amendments

The proviso has been amended four times, none of which changed the threshold. The fourth amendment, recorded as an annex rather than a clause, permits the Delta Council to suspend the Shadow Proviso in cases of documented thermal emergency. No such suspension has ever been declared, largely because the conditions for declaring it are set out in Protocol Delta/7 and the conditions for measuring them are set out in Protocol 308-Delta, and the two documents disagree on the definition of a thermal emergency by eleven degrees.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Protocol Delta/7: how is it conducted?

Protocol Delta/7, subdesignation Point of Origin: Formal Contradiction, is the seventh clause of Protocol Delta, establishing the framework for resolving formal contradictions between a primary operational protocol and a…

Protocol Delta/7
Descent Protocol Delta 7 22 Document: what does it set out?

The Descent Protocol Delta-7-22 Document is the codified regulatory and procedural framework governing authorized vertical descent via Aperture Delta-7 and its associated infrastructure, as established under the Third Co…

Descent Protocol Delta 7 22 Document
Descent Protocol Delta 7 22 Practice: how is it conducted?

The Descent Protocol Delta-7-22 Practice is the codified application and interpretation of the Descent Protocol Delta-7-22, establishing a procedural orthodoxy for the preliminary stages of authorized downward traversal …

Descent Protocol Delta 7 22 Practice
Protocol 308-Delta: what does it set out?

Protocol 308-Delta is an auxiliary volume appended to the Primary Operational Protocol Delta in accordance with the suffix standardization rules established by Protocol Delta itself. It details the specific archival para…

Protocol 308-Delta

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.