The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Proposition 1883-44

MS 0585.12 · Documents and ordinances

Proposition 1883-44 is the standing catalogue entry for a proposal first tabled before the Librarians in the forty-fourth session of the 1883 concordat year. In its original form it asserted that "a subject may be entered in the register before any of its constituent facts have been established, provided the entry is marked provisional." The Proposition was neither adopted nor rejected. It was received, numbered, and referred — a status it has held for one hundred and forty-one years, and which the Indexers' Guild has twice declined to disturb on the grounds that disturbing it would require deciding what it is.

Proposition 1883-44 is unusual among catalogue entries in that its subject matter is not a phenomenon, a document, or a school of thought, but a procedural form. Its own entry is marked provisional, and so the article describing the Proposition is itself an instance of what the Proposition proposes. The Bureau of Junctural Integrity has ruled (Ruling 1883-44/alpha) that this is not a Paradox but a "faithful self-application," though the ruling does not explain the difference in a way that has satisfied anyone who has read it twice.

Origin and tabling

The Proposition was drafted by Archivist-Clerk Mirenne Halveth, then of the Ninth Ascending Scriptorium, in the winter following the partial collapse of the East Reading Gallery on Floor 412. The collapse destroyed some nine hundred holdings whose subjects had never been verified; the loss prompted Halveth to argue that the register ought to hold a place for such subjects in advance of their verification, "lest the loss of a name be mistaken for the loss of a thing."

Halveth's drafting survives in three recensions. The second, submitted to the session on the eleventh of Frostmonth, opens with the sentence that has since been quoted at every subsequent session on the matter: "A receptacle is not a holding, but neither is it nothing." The Seventh Concordance had already addressed the question obliquely in Annex 4, and Halveth's phrasing was read aloud in session as a challenge to that Annex. The challenge was noted. It was not answered.

"The provisional entry does not assert the existence of its subject. It asserts only the existence of the intention to assert it, and the intention is itself a citable fact."

— Mirenne Halveth, Draft Recension 2, tabled 11 Frostmonth 1883

Reception and referral

The session of 1883 received the Proposition without debate and referred it to the Subcommittee on Epistemic Rigor, which at that time was occupied with the Vesk Proposition and did not convene on the matter until 1891. By then, two of the three archivists who had drafted the referral were dead and the third had been transferred to Floor 88, whose holdings are not open to inspection. The Subcommittee's minutes for the 1891 sitting record only that "the Proposition was read, and read again, and set aside."

Subsequent referrals accumulated in the manner characteristic of the Tower's more durable unfinished business. Proposition 1883-44 has been referred to the Subcommittee seven times and returned to the full session six; the seventh referral remains outstanding. Each return has appended a note to the file. The notes, collected in the file's third fascicle, do not agree with one another and in two instances do not agree with themselves, a condition the Bureau has classified as a structural contradiction of the minor kind.

Scholarly dispute

The Vekian School holds that a provisional entry, being observed in the register, is a walked corridor rather than an observed one, and therefore cannot generate a citable fact; on this reading the Proposition fails at its first sentence. The Inherency Thesis takes the opposite view, arguing that the intention to assert is inherent in the register the moment the entry is numbered, and that Proposition 1883-44 is therefore not a proposal at all but a description of existing practice.

The Allegorical Archivists have advanced a third reading, little cited but never formally refuted, in which the Proposition is not about provisional entries but about the habit of proposing them. Their 1912 commentary on the file — appended to the Compendium of Unwritten Prefaces as an unnumbered annex — suggests that the Tower maintains such propositions "not to resolve them but to have somewhere to put the unresolved." No Concordance has been cited against this reading, and none in favour.

The Provisional Receptacle

Between 1884 and 1902 the Proposition was implemented informally on eleven floors, in each case without authorization. The receptacle took the form of a plain shelf-end label reading provisional, beneath which a subject's name might be inscribed in advance of any holding. Floor 276 maintains one to this day; its label has been replaced four times and its single inscribed name — that of a subject whose facts were never established — has never been read aloud in session. A maintenance note attached to the shelf directs that the label be dusted on the first of each month and that nothing be placed upon the shelf itself. The note has been observed since 1903.

The Guild of Quantitative Idealists attempted in 1907 to count the provisional receptacles in operation, in order to establish a denominator for what they termed "the receptacle rate." The count was abandoned after the third ascending sweep, when the surveyors reported that receptacles had been found on floors they had not yet reached. The Guild's report on the incomplete count is held as Annex 12 to its own proceedings and is marked, in its own hand, provisional.

Status

Proposition 1883-44 has not achieved Theorem status and cannot, under the procedure administered by the Subcommittee on Epistemic Rigor, while its referral remains outstanding. It is cited in forty-one subsequent propositions, of which thirty-nine are themselves provisional. The Certainty theodolite was applied to the Proposition's junctural integrity in 1938 and returned a reading of "sound, pending," which the Bureau has adopted as the Proposition's official description.

No amendment to Proposition 1883-44 has been proposed. The file remains open on Floor 412, in the rebuilt East Reading Gallery, on a shelf whose label reads provisional. Visitors wishing to consult it should note that the Gallery closes at the ninth bell and that the file may not be removed from the floor.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Allegorical Archivists: who are they?

The Allegorical Archivists comprise a specialized and historically influential school of Archivists dedicated to the proposition that every physical object or documented process catalogued within the Tower is, at its cor…

Allegorical Archivists
Inherency Thesis: how is it conducted?

The Inherency Thesis is a foundational proposition within the Tower's epistemological framework, positing that for any subject catalogued, a "seam" — the ontological boundary distinguishing it from all other subjects — e…

Inherency Thesis
Vekian School: how is it conducted?

Vekian School is the collective designation for a lineage of cataloguing theorists and floor-colleges descended from the writings of Theoretician Vek, principally concerned with the proposition that all contexts within t…

Vekian School
Indexers Guild: who are they?

The Indexers Guild is a recognized governing body within The Tower charged with the categorization, cross-referencing, and topological mapping of the archive’s non-sequential holdings. Its authority, derived principally …

Indexers Guild

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.