The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

PC-441-Σ-77

MS 0622.71 · Objects and instruments

PC-441-Σ-77 is the classification under which the Tower records a category of pale, low-frequency sound reported on floors between 300 and 600, most consistently in the eastern stairwells of the 441st through 447th galleries. The designation derives from the Phonocylinder register — PC, for the medium; 441, the floor of first confirmed capture; Σ, the sigma-series of anomalous hold; and 77, the cylinder's place in that series. In ordinary usage the term denotes the sound itself; in strict usage it denotes only the cylinder, the sound being formally "the phenomenon recorded under" it. The distinction matters chiefly to the Preservers, who have twice declined to rule on whether an uncaptured occurrence of the sound exists at all in the sense the register requires.

The sound is characteristically described as one long note held near the lower margin of hearing, with a slight beat in it, as of two instruments not quite agreeing. It lasts, by the cylinder's own measure, eleven seconds. Listeners differ on whether eleven seconds is a property of the sound or of the recording apparatus, and no one has resolved the question.

The winter of the first capture

PC-441-Σ-77 was captured during the winter of the 441st gallery's second accession, an event remembered in the stairwells as the Cold Feasance, though the archives record no formal name for it. An auditory clerk of the Librarians, Kelderine Aum (d. 447), was assigned to the gallery on a routine check of the stairwell ventilators and returned with an empty Phonocylinder and a written memorandum stating that the stairwell "sounded" and that she had "put it down."

Aum's memorandum was rejected three times for lack of descriptive content before a presiding officer in the Western galleries accepted it on the ground that the cylinder, being the actual evidence, rendered the description superfluous. This acceptance established what clerks now call the instrument-over-memo rule, cited in nearly every later dispute over anomalous capture. Aum herself took no part in the subsequent proceedings; her grievance against the rejecting officers was set down at length, and that document, not the capture, is why her name survives in the register.

Content and challenge to content

The cylinder plays a single sustained tone, unaccompanied. The audit, conducted by three Librarians in a sealed gallery, found no voice, no words, and no identifiable instrument. It recorded, however, a faint beating at approximately two beats per second, stable throughout. The audit's finding was itself contested on the ground that two of the auditors had been standing within two paces of the instrument and were therefore beating the floor.

"The tone is unpeopled. Its origin, if any, is not entered, and may not be entered by any clerk of this gallery without further instrument."

— Audit finding recorded under Third Concordance, Annex 4

The phrase "if any" has been quoted in every subsequent dispute and has settled nothing. Annex 4 leaves open whether the sound is produced by anything; the Twenty-Second Concordance, Annex 9 (a later amendment, less read) requires any capture without a recorded origin to be returned to the floor of its capture within one year. The two provisions stand unreconciled. The cylinder has been returned twice and retrieved twice, and is at present held in the Western archive pending a ruling that no one has requested.

Further occurrences

The sound is not confined to the cylinder. Reports cluster between floors 300 and 600, and the Western Resonance Spire has recorded it four times during structural surveys of its lower aperture chamber, always at night, never for longer than eleven seconds. Per the standing rule at the Spire, the chamber is cleared of all staff during surveys; the rule predates the first report and its origin is not recorded.

Attempts to capture the sound a second time have produced twelve cylinders, of which nine are silent, two hold a sound judged by the register to be "of a different character," and one — PC-441-Σ-78 — was destroyed in the rack during routine cleaning. The surviving second capture, if the two-character-bearing cylinders are counted, is disputed on the ground that the auditors were asleep. The leading scholarly account, by Vessel Corr, treats PC-441-Σ-77 as the only sound of its kind in the register and all later cylinders as "the archive repeating itself," a formulation the Preservers have neither endorsed nor struck out.

Dispute over the classification

The classification remains contested. One reading holds that Σ, applied to a sound, indicates a designation that has been heard and cannot be assigned a cause; on this reading the second capture's "different character" is not a lesser occurrence but a different sigma altogether, and PC-441-Σ-78 should never have been compared to it. A second reading, advanced by the auditory clerks in a memorandum of 463, holds that Σ was originally a parallax series applied to sightings and was borrowed into sound classification without amendment, so that every sigma classification is in fact a sighting that has been heard — a "loaned mark," in the memo's words, whose terms have not been translated.

The dispute reached the Preservers in the matter of the Seventeenth Concordance, which addresses the marks permitted upon instruments of record and neither lists nor excludes sigma. The Preservers ruled that the classification stands until such time as a Concordance is written against it, noting that no party had requested withdrawal. The memo of 463 is still in circulation. It is unsigned.

Practical note

Visitors to the 441st gallery may listen to PC-441-Σ-77 by appointment, two persons at a time, in the listening room off the west landing. The room is kept at low light. Visitors are asked not to speak during playback and not to bring additional chairs.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Western Resonance Spire: where is it?

Western Resonance Spire is the primary acoustic analysis and containment structure for active and Western Spire’s lower precincts, specifically catalogued under Floor 4044, Annex 7. It is distinguished by its pronounced …

Western Resonance Spire
Phonocylinder: what is it for?

The Phonocylinder is a specialized apparatus authorized under the Third Concordance for the recording, storage, and playback of purely abstract sonic events. Unlike conventional sound-capturing devices, which require a p…

Phonocylinder
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.