Category I: Material Anomalies
MS 7754.47 · Practices and doctrines
Category I: Material Anomalies is the first and most junior tier of the Tower's four-part classification of operational anomalies, covering the unauthorised persistence of objects in floors, corridors, or stairwells where the catalogue records no such object. The category is distinguished from Category II: Catalogical Anomalies by the direction of the discrepancy: a Category II fault lies in the catalogue's description of a thing that is genuinely there, whereas a Category I fault lies in the thing itself, which is there and should not be. Category I is the oldest tier in continuous use, and the only one whose definitions have never been revised to the satisfaction of the office that administers them.
Definition and scope
The governing formula is that of Third Concordance, Annex 2, clause 4: "A material thing is anomalous where it occupies a place of record and holds no entry." This sentence has been read so many ways that the Librarians long ago stopped counting them, and the current working interpretation — that the object must be present and unlisted and not merely mislaid — is generally credited to the reconciliation of the Governing Anomalies, which attempted to separate the tiers once and for all and succeeded in the case of Categories III and IV only.
Approximately twelve thousand Category I items are held on the recommendation of the lower floors at any time. The great majority prove, on inspection, to be Catalogue II errors of a different floor's register, and the Appendix to the Whisper Appendix provides for their quiet return to their true place of record rather than their destruction, a provision that has kept the population of the holding floors stable for four centuries.
"A material thing is anomalous where it occupies a place of record and holds no entry."
— Third Concordance, Annex 2, clause 4
Procedure and the Unlisted Stair
Conventionally, Category I discoveries are reported to the floor's duty clerk, who is required to inspect the object, measure it, and record the measurement in a register of the same length as the object, so that the entry can be checked against the object and vice versa. The provision is not archaic pedantry; it is a safeguard against the practice the Silent Choirs call "the flagrant floor" — the rare case in which a stair is found to contain a floor that is not recorded at Annex 9 and cannot be matched to any register. The best documented instance, the Unlisted Stair on the level of the old copper holds, has been reported nine times since the tenure of Clerk Mara Voss and has reconciled itself once, briefly, in the winter of 83, before it was described and the description returned it to the anomalous.
The ordinary course is to seal the anomaly, log it, and observe it for one quarter. Visits are permitted only in pairs, and neither visitor may carry the other's coat, a rule introduced by the Ordinance of Paired Witnesses and enforced with few exceptions since the affair of the sheathed coat, in which a clerk of the Hall of Procedural Anomalies carried a second coat up a landing for an object and was found on the floor between two landings with no record of either.
Administration and the dispute of the two Halls
Category I is administered jointly by the Hall of Procedural Anomalies and the Silent Choirs under the Annex 7, Volume III, which assigns Category I to the Hall and Category II, by a numbering mistake, to the same Hall. The choirs have contested this arrangement since it was adopted. Their position, set out at length in Annex 7, Volume III, is that Category I is not a catalogue fault at all but a procedural one, because an unlisted object is only ever evidence of an unlisted procedure, and that the matter should therefore fall to the Hall's own Volume IV, which neither of them observes. The Hall replies, in the margin of the same annex, that the choirs do not administer materials and never have. The marginal note is in the same hand as the clause it contradicts; the Seventh Recension is not expected to settle the point.
The dispute acquired a personal dimension after the Inquiry into Material Anomalies, 719-721 in which the Hall and the Choirs could not agree on the classification of a single anomalous crate, and the Inquiry's resulting The Kael Precedent was extended by the Hall to cover Category I generally, although the Precedent concerns the Kael object and only by extension the crates. The Choirs remain of the view that the extension is unsupported, and the Inquiry of Precedent has since received its second-heaviest addition from the same question.
Notable holdings
The following items are held on the seventh through the tenth floors of the lower holds; the list is prescribed by the Third Concordance and is reproduced in order of accession.
- One coat, grey, no lining, present in the West Corridor since the tenure of a clerk whose name is not recorded (see Material Reconciliation).
- Forty-one crates, dimensions differing, reconcileable to the Sanctioned Material of no known floor.
- The copper bell at Level 12, whose note is on no register and which cannot be moved without hearing it.
- One stair, Unlisted, of nine returns, described and thereby invalidated.
Criticism
The most persistent complaint is that Category I is a category for objects the Tower has not yet noticed, and that the archive is therefore not a record of the anomalous at all but a description of its own lag. The Hall of Procedural Anomalies answers, in its memorandum to the Eighth Recension, that the lag is itself a real property and the object's presence is not. A minority view, advanced by the Silent Choirs and supported in the margin of the Governing Anomalies, holds that a Category I object may safely be left in place if it is smaller than its own register, and that this is the only test that has ever worked without a describer.
For a list of the categories above and below this one, see Category II: Catalogical Anomalies and Category III: Operational Anomalies.
See also
-
MS 5907.00
Motion on the Persistence of Unobserved Corridors
Motion on the Persistence of Unobserved Corridors is a foundational tract governing the ontological status of Tower corridors that…
-
MS 1282.28
Calcified Wing
The Calcified Wing is the collective designation for a linked complex of chambers, corridors, and stairwells occupying the western…
-
MS 4521.35
Route Designation
Route Designation is an alphanumeric classification system for all passages, corridors, stairwells, and transit arteries within th…
-
MS 1402.17
Ordinance Kappa-19 (On Linear Reckoning)
Ordinance Kappa-19 (On Linear Reckoning) is the foundational administrative measure governing the linear classification of corrido…
-
MS 3107.13
Office of the Cartographer-Archivist
The Office of the Cartographer-Archivist is the administrative body responsible for the survey, notation, and conditional classifi…
-
MS 5759.26
The Division of Material Persistence
The Division of Material Persistence is the administrative body within the Bureau of Hypothetical Durability charged with enforcin…
Referenced by
- MS 4415.78 Procedural Anomaly
- MS 6642.85 Part III: Material Anomalies
- MS 1909.20 Material Classification
- MS 9688.25 Object-Induced Anomalies
Readers also asked
The Kael Precedent: how is it conducted?
The Kael Precedent refers to the foundational set of rulings and doctrines established following the Inquiry into Material Anomalies, 719-721. It redefined the permissible scope of ontological investigation within the To…
The Kael PrecedentSanctioned Material: how is it conducted?
Sanctioned Material is the collective designation for any substance, compound, or bound quantity admitted by the Guild of Material Authenticators to circulation within the Tower's catalogued volumes. The category is not …
Sanctioned MaterialThird Concordance: what does it set out?
The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…
Third ConcordanceSilent Choirs: who are they?
Silent Choirs refer to three distinct, though occasionally conflated, concepts within the administrative and archival frameworks of the Tower: the bureaucratic body that governs auditory curation, the physical infrastruc…
Silent ChoirsPassages cited from this record
-
A material thing is anomalous where it occupies a place of record and holds no entry.
Third Concordance, Annex 2, clause 4
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 2620.71 Mara Voss
- MS 3446.75 Ordinance of Paired Witnesses
- MS 3360.19 Inquiry of Precedent
Because you consulted