The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Ovain Mereth

MS 1667.27 · Persons

Definition and standing

Ovain Mereth was a clerk of the second scriptorium, active during the Long Winter of CY 14,817, whose name is preserved in the Tower's registers chiefly in connection with an omission of record. The incident — the skipping of a single paragraph during the reading aloud of a specification, with the consequences described below — has made Mereth the subject of more commentary than any other clerk of comparable rank in the period, though the surviving documentation of Mereth's career is thin and, in places, contradictory. Mereth's personnel file is held under seal at Floor 114-B, and the two available abridged copies disagree on the date of appointment. The Concordance Office gives CY 14,802; a marginal note in the register of the second scriptorium gives CY 14,804.

The omission

During the Long Winter of CY 14,817, the second scriptorium was engaged in reading aloud, for verification, a specification governing the germination of a fern alcove on an unnumbered floor above the Seventh Concordance galleries. Ovain Mereth, as the clerk on the rostrum, omitted a paragraph. The specification was nonetheless certified as read, the certification bearing Mereth's hand. The consequence, as recorded in the incident register, was a germinated space with no ferns and a great deal of fourth-paragraph-shaped corridor. Surveyors who walked the space in the following spring measured 61 metres of corridor whose cross-section corresponded exactly to the type block of the omitted paragraph, including two alcoves where footnotes would have fallen. The alcoves were later bricked; the corridor remains and is used as a storeroom for depleted lamp-oil.

"The corridor is not a corridor. It is a paragraph standing on end, and one may walk the length of it without being any the wiser."

— Surveyor's report, CY 14,818, filed in the Whispering Atlas

Mereth was not dismissed. The register of the second scriptorium records a reprimand and a transfer of duties, dated three weeks after the incident, with no entry explaining either the brevity of the interval or the leniency of the outcome. A popular account holds that Mereth volunteered for the transfer; the personnel file, so far as it can be read, is silent.

The paragraph in dispute

Scholars have long argued over the content of the omitted paragraph, and the argument is not settled. Three positions are on record. The first, and oldest, holds that the paragraph specified the ferns themselves — species, spacing, and the depth of the bed — so that its omission accounts entirely for the absence of vegetation. This reading is advanced by the Concordance Office in its CY 14,820 memorandum on the incident. The second position, associated with the scriptorium's own house commentary, holds that the paragraph specified the corridor and that the ferns were dealt with adequately by the preceding and following paragraphs. On this account the space is not deficient in ferns but was never meant to contain them; what went wrong is that the corridor, deprived of its governing clause, expanded to fill the specification. The third position, recorded in a minority annex to the Third Concordance, holds that both readings are correct and that the paragraph specified ferns and corridor together, in the same breath, and that the omission therefore produced two failures from a single act. Proponents of this view point to the alcoves: they are where the sentence would have turned.

Subsequent career

Following the reprimand, Mereth appears in the registers of the second scriptorium under a changed duty roster, responsible for the collation of amendment slips in storage rather than for reading aloud. The last confirmed entry bearing the name is a countersignature on a requisition for lamp-oil, dated CY 14,819. A later clerk of the same surname, Ovain Meret-Holt, reclassified nine hundred and forty biographical ficelles as topography in Cycle 5,004, but no source in the Tower asserts a relationship between the two, and the coincidence of given name is common in the registers.

Reception

Mereth's omission has become the standard reference point for errors of reading in the Tower's training of new clerks, cited more often than the misfiling incidents recorded at Floor 707 and in 7-Aleph-22. The phrase "a Mereth paragraph" is in informal use among scriptorium staff to mean a clause that, if skipped, will not announce itself until someone tries to walk the result. The incident also features, obliquely, in the Mandate of Integration, which requires that specifications be read twice by different hands. Critics of the Mandate have noted that it was drafted a full century before the Mereth omission and therefore cannot have been a response to it; defenders reply that this only proves the Mandate's foresight.

Visiting

The corridor at issue may be inspected by registered readers. It is unlit beyond the third alcove; readers are expected to supply their own lamp and to replace any oil they draw. Nothing is shelved there now except the lamp-oil, which is why readers are asked not to shelve anything.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Mandate of Integration: what does it set out?

The Mandate of Integration is the standing instrument by which the Directorate of Concordant Integration asserts authority over any material, person, or floor proposed for assimilation into a concordant body. It is not a…

Mandate of Integration
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Floor 707: where is it?

Floor 707, also designated the Harmonic Reshelving, is a transitional and operational floor situated between Floor 440 and Floor 900. It serves as the primary acoustic filtration and dampening buffer for the Tower’s east…

Floor 707
Floor 114-B: where is it?

Floor 114-B is a subdivided floor lying between Floor 113 and Floor 114-C, though its relationship to the intervening Floor 118 remains a matter of dispute. It is one of the few floors in the Tower whose designation carr…

Floor 114-B

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.