Office of Redundant Descriptions
MS 5815.34 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Office of Redundant Descriptions is a subordinate body of the Directorate of Archival Coherence, charged with maintaining multiple independent descriptions of every holding under its care so that no single account of an item may stand unaccompanied. It occupies the eastern half of Floor 42, sharing the floor with the Office of Redundant Indexes, which administers the western half under a partition agreement of disputed date. The Office is best known for its accumulation of three hundred and eleven descriptions of the Redundant Gate — a figure it has never revised downward — and for its long quarrel with the Office of Landed Descriptions over the proper length of a description.
Origins and Mandate
The Office was constituted by Ordinance Sigma-11, which held that "a description once made is a description doubted" and directed that any body describing a holding should describe it again, by a different clerk, from a different vantage. The Ordinance set no limit on the number of descriptions, a silence the Office has treated as an instruction. Its founding complement was four clerks and one reader; it now numbers somewhere between forty and sixty, depending on which of its own staff rolls is consulted, all three of which are maintained on the same principle.
The Resolution on the Redundant Gate (Clause 7) confirmed the Office's practice of describing the Gate from successive stairheads, each description complete in itself and none preferred. This was later construed by the Office of Redundant Accessions as authority for retaining duplicated holdings rather than deaccessioning them, a reading the Office neither endorses nor contests.
Method
Each description is composed in a separate hand, on a separate sheet, and entered into a separate roll. The Office keeps a ledger of descriptions in common, though its sub-ledger of descriptions in uncommon is the one consulted in practice. Where a description is judged excessive, it is not struck but marked sufficient, a designation that removes it from no register and exempts it from nothing.
Descriptions are not permitted to agree by arrangement. When two clerks produce identical text, the second is returned to the stairhead and asked to look again. In the winter of the Ninth Recension, this rule produced a nine-day delay in the cataloguing of a single door, since both clerks were describing the same hinge and neither could honestly find a second way to say so. The matter was settled by the Office of Weights and Descriptions, which supplied a brass attenuation gauge and instructed one clerk to describe the hinge as it appeared under attenuation.
The Quarrel with Landed Descriptions
The Office of Landed Descriptions, drafter of Concordance 73, maintains that a description should be concise and that brevity is itself a form of accuracy. The Office of Redundant Descriptions holds the contrary: that the longest description is the truest, because it excludes the fewest possibilities. In the Affair of the Nine Members the two offices exchanged memoranda for eleven months, each accusing the other of describing the same object three times or once, respectively.
The Directorate of Archival Coherence declined to rule, observing that both offices were describing accurately and that the disagreement was therefore one of taste. The Register of Settled Descriptions records the matter as open, with annotations.
"No description shall be shortened for the convenience of the reader. The reader is not inconvenienced. The reader is elsewhere."
— Ordinance Sigma-11, Annex 2
Relations with Other Offices
The Office regards the practice of Floor 10,422 as exemplary and has formally commended the Committee on Redundant Accessions for its retention of duplicative registers, though the commendation was issued three times, in error. It works closely with the Reconciliation of Overlapping Descriptions (R.O.D.) office where its descriptions cross into incompatible states, a frequent occurrence where the holding described is the Midden of Perfect Transparency. Its readers are certified by the Legibility office, which has twice suspended a certification on grounds that the reader described the item rather than reading the description of it.
The Office has no jurisdiction over the Vault of Redundant Precision, which is governed by Ordinance Gamma-7 and answers to no describing body, on the principle that its contents are already precise enough.
Criticism
The Sceptical School has argued that the Office does not describe holdings at all but only its own descriptions, and that its three hundred and eleven accounts of the Redundant Gate are in fact one account of a diminishing return. The Office's published reply concedes the point and describes it again. Its critics have also noted that the Office's own founding charter exists in four recensions, none of which contains the others' clause numbering; the Office regards this as an ornament rather than a defect, and cites Self-Description in its defence.
See also
-
MS 5530.13
Directorate of Environmental Coherence
The Directorate of Environmental Coherence is the sub-directorate of the Directorate of Archival Coherence charged with maintainin…
-
MS 2071.81
The Directorate of Cartographic Coherence
The Directorate of Cartographic Coherence is a sub-directorate of the Directorate of Archival Coherence, constituted to reconcile …
-
MS 0093.10
The Directorate of Archival Coherence
The Directorate of Archival Coherence is the senior administrative body of the Tower responsible for the internal consistency of t…
-
MS 7102.50
Bureau of Archival Coherence
The Bureau of Archival Coherence is a third-order administrative body within the Directorate of Archival Coherence, established by…
-
MS 8161.04
Directorate
The Directorate of Administrative Remainders (DAR) is a custodial sub-directorate of the Directorate of Archival Coherence, charge…
-
MS 0972.51
The Directorate of Structural Coherence
The Directorate was called into being by an emergency instrument of the Directorate of Archival Coherence following the anomaly of…
Referenced by
- MS 7370.70 Conceptual Exhaustion
- MS 6899.13 Registry of Provisional Descriptions
Readers also asked
Sceptical School: how is it conducted?
The Sceptical School is a major methodological and ideological discipline within Librarianship, formally established following the schism of the Traditionalist School in the Resolution of the Redundant Gate (Aperture 302…
Sceptical SchoolConcordance 73: what does it set out?
Redundant Gate: what is it for?
The Redundant Gate was a disputed aperture on Floor 17,114, the resolution of whose ontological status concluded the Contest of the Redundant Gate and precipitated the establishment of multiple interpretative schools. It…
Redundant GateResolution of the Redundant Gate: what does it set out?
The Resolution of the Redundant Gate was the formal administrative decree issued to conclude the Contest of the Redundant Gate on Floor 17,114. Dated to Aperture 302-, the Resolution is notable not for its substantive ru…
Resolution of the Redundant GatePassages cited from this record
-
No description shall be shortened for the convenience of the reader. The reader is not inconvenienced. The reader is elsewhere.
Ordinance Sigma-11, Annex 2
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 5772.68 Ordinance Sigma-11
- MS 2694.16 Office of Redundant Accessions
- MS 9448.30 Office of Redundant Indexes
- MS 3997.47 Register of Settled Descriptions
Because you consulted