Office of Discretionary Precedents
MS 0011.27 · Guilds, orders and offices
The Office of Discretionary Precedents is a standing body of the Librarian order charged with the identification, provisional enforcement, and retrospective justification of precedents that have not yet been formally made. It is among the few offices in the Tower whose authority derives from actions not taken, and its instruments are consequently the most heavily annotated in the archive. The Office operates from three rooms on Floor 88, one of which has no door and is administered by correspondence.
Foundation and the Ninth Concordance
The Office was constituted under Annex 7 of the Ninth Concordance, which established that where a dispute cannot be settled by reference to a precedent on the register, the deciding clerk may nevertheless act, provided the resulting action is later entered as a discretionary precedent and defended before review. The Annex does not specify who conducts the review. This omission has been the subject of four centuries of settled and unsettled practice. The Office of the Keeper of Precedents maintains that review falls to it under the single-Keeper reading of the instruments attributed to Keeper Armitage; the Office of Discretionary Precedents maintains that it reviews itself, on the grounds that no other office can know what was discretionary.
Both positions are recorded in the Master Register of Precedents on Floor 301, where the relevant entries are separated by a single line and have been for two hundred and eleven years.
Instrument of Discretion
A clerk proceeding without precedent completes an Instrument of Discretion, a single sheet in triplicate. Shellac and lamp-black only; the Office of Proprietary Inks will not accept Instruments in iron-gall, and a returned batch delays entry by two duty-cycles. Two copies enter the Office's working file; the third is placed in a sealed tube and lowered into the well on Floor 88, which is 140 metres deep and was intended for a different purpose.
The well is inspected every eleven years. The inspection of Year 3114 recorded that the tubes had fused at the twentieth metre into a single mass, and that the mass had been entered as an object in its own right. The Office has not disputed this. The entry now bears a silent precedent designation, meaning that no clerk may cite it and no clerk may remove it.
The Case of Clerk Ardens Vell
The Office's authority was substantially narrowed following the matter of Clerk Ardens Vell, who in the winter of Year 226 issued nineteen Instruments in a single duty-cycle to settle a dispute over a marking sheet held at the Precedents Office. Each Instrument was internally consistent. Together they were not, and the resulting position admitted of no action at all, which the Office nonetheless certified. Vell's own note on the nineteenth Instrument reads, in full:
"Resolved, subject to the whole."
— Clerk Ardens Vell, Instrument 19 of Year 226, held at the Precedents Office
Review found the nineteen Instruments valid and the dispute unresolved. The Vault of Unsaid Precedents subsequently acquired the marking sheet, and the Office was required to log with the Office of Discretionary Precedents — that is, with itself — within seven duty-cycles of any action taken on Permit 4409. Compliance with this requirement is recorded annually, and annually records that the requirement is self-referential and no action has been taken.
Relationship to Other Offices
The Office's precedents are provisional by definition, which places them at odds with the Vault of Binding Precedents and, more acutely, with the Bureau of Unstated Precedents, which considers discretionary entry a form of premature disclosure. The two offices have not exchanged instruments since Year 2988, when the Bureau returned a package unopened with a note stating that the contents had not been read. The Office accepted the note as a binding precedent on the grounds that it was in writing.
Contested discretionary entries are heard in the Amphitheatre of Precedents, where the Office is entitled to two seats and has occupied three on every recorded occasion. The third seat is disputed by the Congregation of the Unanswered, which holds a discretionary recognition under Annex 7 of the Eighth Concordance and has argued since Year 2601 that a discretionary body is by definition unanswered. The Office's position is that the Congregation's recognition is itself a discretionary precedent and therefore subject to the Office's review. Neither body has brought the question to the Amphitheatre, for reasons each has declined to state.
Floor 88 and the Unstated Door
The Office occupies Rooms 88-3, 88-4, and 88-5. Room 88-4 has no door; its instruments are passed through a grille and its clerk is addressed by number rather than name. The Office has twice petitioned the Librarian of the Seventh Rank for a door and twice been refused, on the ground that the room's contents are not yet certifiable for the Deposition Chain and that a door would imply otherwise. The petition is refiled every seven years. The refiling is itself entered as a discretionary precedent, and the entry cites the previous refiling, which is how the Office prefers things.
Visitors are received in Room 88-3 by appointment. Umbrellas are left outside; the corridor floods in spring.
See also
-
MS 6617.43
Retrospective Procurement School
The Retrospective Procurement School is a formal curatorial and philosophical institution concerned with the ethical and procedura…
-
MS 4913.02
The Retrospective Procurement School
The Retrospective Procurement School is a formal philosophical and curatorial institution concerned with the ethical and procedura…
-
MS 3804.63
Orthographic Enforcement
Orthographic Enforcement is the branch of Tower administration concerned with the detection, correction, and retrospective annotat…
-
MS 9840.56
Department of Theoretical Procedure
The Department of Theoretical Procedure is a body of the Tower charged with the study, codification, and retrospective justificati…
-
MS 8928.48
Bureau of Provisional Metadata
The Bureau of Provisional Metadata (BPM) is an administrative body, operating under the Bureau of Registry, responsible for the cr…
-
MS 2460.50
Keeper of Precedents
The Keeper of Precedents is the presiding officer of the Office of the Keeper of Precedents, a regulatory body within the Libraria…
Referenced by
- MS 6058.96 Sixth Concordance, Annex 7
- MS 9367.53 Office of the Keeper of Precedents
- MS 7967.01 Auditory Permit Office
- MS 9621.95 Master Ledger of Precedents
- MS 2460.50 Keeper of Precedents
- MS 3657.92 Standing Precedents S-7.4.19r
- MS 8511.96 Master Register of Precedents
Readers also asked
Ninth Concordance: what does it set out?
The Ninth Concordance is the ninth of the thirteen principal legislative and administrative codes governing operations within the Tower. Ratified on 12 Nisan in the Year of the Ninth Librarian in the immediate aftermath …
Ninth ConcordanceVault of Unsaid Precedents: what is it for?
The Vault of Unsaid Precedents is the designated repository for the codified and ratified outcomes of the Chamber of Vanishing Precedents, as established under the provisions of Standing Precedents S-7.4.19r. Its functio…
Vault of Unsaid PrecedentsSilent Precedents: how is it conducted?
Silent Precedents are Precedents entered into the record without accompanying reasoning, commentary, or oral delivery — rulings whose force is held to reside entirely in their operative clause. The category is old, conte…
Silent PrecedentsThe Vault of Binding Precedents: where is it?
The Vault of Binding Precedents is the premier archival repository and custodial nexus for all original, codified texts issued as Binding Precedents by the Court of Unseen Precedents. Located on Floor 8,742, it exists in…
The Vault of Binding PrecedentsReaders who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 9996.15 Precedents Office
Because you consulted