The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Material Authentication Protocol Map Practice

MS 3470.89 · Practices and doctrines

Material Authentication Protocol Map Practice is the body of operational custom, unwritten precedent, and informal ruling by which the Material Authentication Protocol (MAP) is actually applied to maps in the Map Room. It is distinguished throughout the Directorate from the Protocol's text, which is short, and from its annexes, which are not. Where the text and the practice diverge, the practice has generally prevailed, on the grounds set out in Fourth Concordance, Annex 2: "A procedure that has been performed correctly nine hundred times is not thereby incorrect on the nine hundred and first" (Fourth Concordance, Annex 2, clause 7).

Map practice is administered from the Authentication Desk in the Map Room's central rotunda and is binding on all Librarians of the sixth grade and above. It is not taught in the scriptoria. It is acquired by standing at the Desk.

Scope and the map question

The Protocol governs the authentication of all documentary material, but maps present a difficulty the drafters did not anticipate: a map is a claim about a place, and the place may be on a floor no one has visited. Map practice resolves this by authenticating the map as an object and declining, as a matter of standing custom, to authenticate what it depicts. The distinction is stated in the Desk's framed notice and is repeated to every new attendant on their first morning: "We certify the paper. The floor must certify itself."

This has produced the anomaly that a map may be fully authenticated while depicting a corridor that does not exist, provided the ink, hand, and sigil are genuine. Practice holds such a map to be authentic and inaccurate, a category the Protocol's text does not recognize and map practice maintains anyway. The category is recorded in no annex. It is recorded in the Desk's day-book, in a hand that changes every few years and never varies in its phrasing.

The quarantine and the practice of the second look

The Protocol mandates a 72-hour quarantine for suspect maps within the Map Room, and map practice observes it with a rigour the text does not require. Suspect maps are held in the north alcove, weighted at the corners, and examined at the sixth, thirtieth, and seventy-first hours. The seventy-first-hour examination is a practice of long standing and is not in the Protocol. It exists because a map that has been left alone for seventy-one hours will sometimes disagree with itself, and the disagreement is easier to see than to argue about.

The Provenance Challenge is administered during quarantine by whichever attendant is on the alcove rota. Attendants are forbidden to discuss a quarantined map with its depositor before the thirtieth hour. The prohibition was introduced after the winter of the ninth floor, when a depositor's repeated visits to the alcove produced three separate provenance accounts in five days, none of which agreed, and all of which the depositor sincerely believed.

Interaction with the staged procedures

Map practice takes the staged escalations of the Protocol in a fixed order that the Protocol leaves to the attendant's judgement. In practice the order is: Source Authentication first, then the Provenance Challenge, then Material Consistency if the ink is in dispute, then MAP-4 only where a contradiction has been isolated to a single sheet, and MAP-5 almost never. MAP-6 is invoked chiefly to settle arguments between attendants, and is regarded at the Desk as a way of ending a discussion rather than of resolving one.

The Sigil Authentication step is performed first in every case, whatever the order above, because a map without a sigil is not a map for these purposes and the remaining stages have nothing to work on. Attendants who skip ahead are reminded of this by the Desk's senior clerk, Orison Vell, who has held the rota since the third recension and who keeps a list of every map authenticated out of order since that date. The list is short. Vell is said to consult it before agreeing to anything.

Where authentication is inconclusive, the Desk issues a Provisional Attribution rather than returning the map unmarked. Map practice regards an unmarked return as a discourtesy to the depositor and a gap in the record, and the Protocol's silence on the point is treated as permission.

Correspondence Maps and recursive cases

Correspondence Maps are governed by Annex C of the Protocol, and map practice adds to Annex C the requirement that a Correspondence Map be laid out beside its counterpart on a table of at least two cubits' width. The requirement is not in the annex. It is in the Desk's standing instructions, and it is enforced because a narrow table causes the sheets to overlap and the overlap has twice been mistaken for a correspondence.

Maps submitted under the Protocol of Recursive Authentication are handled under Interstitial Authentication where the recursion terminates at a floor number and under Concordant Authentication where it does not. Annex M of the Protocol provides the material practice for instantiating the recursion, but the Desk has found that a recursion which returns to the Desk itself must be broken by hand. The breaking is done by the attendant on duty, who signs the day-book with the note "returned to self, broken" and is thereafter excused from further recursive work that day. The excusal is customary and not written.

Disagreement in the record

Two recensions of the Protocol disagree on the status of map practice. The Third Concordance holds, at Annex 4, that unwritten practice has no force where an annex speaks, and that the Desk's customs are "observances, not procedures." The Fourth Concordance holds the contrary at Annex 2 and has done so since its revision. The Desk applies the Fourth and cites the Third when challenged, on the reasoning that a procedure performed correctly is a procedure, and the Third's authors were not standing at the Desk at the time.

"The map was authenticated in the manner the Desk has always authenticated maps, and if that manner is not in the annexes, the annexes are incomplete and not the Desk."

— Orison Vell, marginal note, Map Room day-book, entry of the eleventh of March

The Directorate of Acquisition and Authentication has twice convened a review of the question and twice adjourned without findings. The review's minutes record that the matter is "one of practice," which is the phrase the Directorate uses when it does not intend to decide. Until it does, the Desk will authenticate maps the way it has always authenticated maps, at the sixth, thirtieth, and seventy-first hours, on tables of sufficient width, and will certify the paper and not the floor.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fourth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fourth Concordance is a foundational Tower document, now extant only in fragmentary quotations and secondary references. Its authority was formally superseded by the ratification of the Fifth Concordance, which was d…

Fourth Concordance
Map Room: where is it?

The Map Room is one of two officially designated chambers within the Tower bearing that title, located on Floor -17, Annex Theta. Formally established under Clause 23(a) of the Fourteenth Concordance, it serves as an adm…

Map Room
Sigil Authentication: how is it conducted?

Sigil Authentication is the formal process by which the legitimacy, origin, and operational status of a Sigil are verified and certified by the Bureau of Authentication, as mandated by Annex Γ of the Material Authenticat…

Sigil Authentication
Material Authentication Protocol: what does it set out?

Material Authentication Protocol (abbreviated as MAP) is the primary procedural framework and operational manual administered by the Directorate of Acquisition and Authentication (DAA) for the evaluation, certification, …

Material Authentication Protocol

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.