Linear Snarlers
MS 5467.74 · Practices and doctrines
The Linear Snarlers are a non-hierarchical collective of Tower residents engaged in the deliberate, unsanctioned cultivation of visual contradictions to linear geometry. Their practice — termed by its opponents "applied heresy" and by its defenders "correction" — consists of introducing persistent spatial knots into corridors, stairwells, and sightlines that the Tower's instruments register as straight. The Snarlers maintain no register, no officers, and no fixed membership, and are consequently among the few bodies in the Tower that cannot be summoned, fined, or dissolved by citation. They are based primarily in the Lower Recesses and the Spiral Stacks, though snarls have been recovered from as high as Floor 6,109 and as low as Floor 12.
Definition and detection
A snarl is defined in Annex E: Non-Linear Progression as "any persistence of contradiction in a line otherwise certified linear, lasting beyond the third survey and unattributable to settlement or sag." The qualifying duration is disputed: the Bureau of Linear Interpretation holds that the third survey governs, while the Bureau of Linear Hermeneutics reads the same clause as requiring three consecutive surveys by the same instrument, a reading that has invalidated some 1,400 snarls retroactively.
Detection is ordinarily a matter for the Lens of Linear Scrutiny, an instrument of the School of Linear Dependency whose focal length is fixed at precisely one standardized Linear Foot. The Lens renders a snarl as a faint doubling along its axis — a "stitch," in the surveyors' idiom — visible to the naked eye but difficult to distinguish from a flaw in the glass. The Corps of Linear Reckoning is permitted to borrow the Lens for snarls occurring on inclined surfaces, where its own gauges are not certified.
History of the dispute
The earliest recorded snarl was filed in the winter of 3,882 by a surveyor of the Bureau of Linear Feet on Floor 482, who reported that a service corridor twelve feet in length returned a measurement of eleven feet nine inches on one wall and twelve feet three inches on the other, "and both readings repeated." The corridor was demolished, rebuilt, and demolished again, the reading persisting through both rebuildings. The file was closed without a finding and is kept, per standing instruction, in a drawer of its own.
The Clerk-Registrar of Linear Standards first classified the practice as applied heresy in a circular of 4,104, arguing that a snarl is not a defect of the line but a doctrinal claim about the line, and that the office is therefore legally obligated to untangle every one it discovers. The School of Linear Dependency dissented within the year, describing the Snarlers' work as "a vital field experiment, conducted at inconvenient expense."
"That a line may be bent is arithmetic. That a line may be bent and remain the same line is a proposition, and propositions are untangled at the desk, not in the corridor."
— Clerk-Registrar of Linear Standards, Circular 4,104/3
No Concordance has settled the question. The Non Linear Index lists the Snarlers under both "Corrections" and "Infractions," an arrangement defended by the Bureau of Cyclical Integration on the ground that the Index was compiled before the distinction mattered.
Method
Snarlers describe their work as returning lines to a condition the Tower has forgotten. The technique most often observed is the laying of two marks that each appear straight and, together, do not — a doorframe set true to a wall that is not, or a floor-line continued across a threshold at an angle no one standing in the corridor can name. Snarls of this kind are inexpensive and, once seen, difficult to unsee, which is the whole of the method as far as the Snarlers have committed it to writing. They have committed nothing else to writing.
Maintenance staff are instructed not to paint over any line whose ends do not agree with the plan, and to report the discrepancy on Form 19b. Form 19b has not been revised since 4,061 and contains no field in which the discrepancy may be described.
Recovered inventories
Three caches were seized from the Lower Recesses in 4,388 and catalogued by the Bureau of Linear Intent. The inventory of the second cache is reproduced in full, as the third was empty and the first was a chair.
- Two hundred and eleven lengths of chalk, unmarked.
- One plumb-line, plumb.
- Four doorframes, three of which agreed with each other.
- A plan of Floor 482, corrected.
The chair in the first cache was returned to the Spiral Stacks by a clerk who had not been asked to move it, and is generally taken by the Snarlers to have been the only successful untangling on record.
Positions and persons
The Bureau of Linear Hermeneutics maintains that the Snarlers do not exist as a body, since a collective that keeps no register cannot be a collective, and that the snarls are the work of "one person, very patient, or several, unacquainted." The Bureau of Linear Interpretation rejects this on evidentiary grounds, citing the simultaneous appearance of matching snarls on Floors 71 and 2,904 in the same week of 4,215, and observing that no single person has been shown to walk that far.
Linear Survey (LS) returns submitted from the affected floors are marked at the foot of the page with the words "consistent with cultivation," a formula introduced without definition in 4,190 and never withdrawn. The Snarlers have not commented on it.
See also
-
MS 8590.74
The Linear Snarlers
The Linear Snarlers are a non-hierarchical collective of Tower residents, primarily based in The Spiral Stacks and the Lower Reces…
-
MS 7924.76
Shadow-Casting Sporulation
“The fruiting of a shadow is a slow, deliberate process, an act of cultivation more than revelation.”…
-
MS 1124.42
Contradiction Generation
Contradiction Generation is the branch of the Tower's documentary practice concerned with the deliberate production of contradicti…
-
MS 0479.55
Noetic Pillarism
Noetic Pillarism is a doctrine of structural interpretation holding that the abstract concepts catalogued within the Tower exert m…
-
MS 1586.66
IC-Mu
IC-Mu is the collective designation for the Mu recension of the Incident Chronology, a working edition of the master incident regi…
-
MS 4029.23
Treatise on Intentional Climate
Treatise on Intentional Climate is the principal recension of the School of Humoral Cartography concerning the deliberate cultivat…
Referenced by
- MS 0434.72 Office of the Clerk Registrar
- MS 2259.91 Clerk Registrar
- MS 0542.09 The Committee for Linear Time vs. The Looped Hour (Recurring)
- MS 0698.80 Non Euclidean Geometry of the Tower
- MS 5363.84 Lower Register
- MS 0832.54 Bureau of Linear Hermeneutics
- MS 1876.14 Perspective Grafting
- MS 9826.16 Kineticist Heresy
- MS 9986.06 Lower Spiral
- MS 5367.10 Non Linear Chronology
- MS 4570.09 Linear Decimal Protocols
- MS 4664.04 Registry of Linear Sequence
Readers also asked
School of Linear Dependency: how is it conducted?
The School of Linear Dependency is an analytical framework and pedagogical tradition dedicated to the proposition that the Tower’s perceived non-linear and mutable spatial properties are not primary phenomena, but are in…
School of Linear DependencyAnnex E: Non-Linear Progression: what does it set out?
Annex E: Non-Linear Progression is a foundational procedural document appended to the Seventh Concordance of the Tower, formally codified in TSC 812. It articulates the standard protocol for career advancement within the…
Annex E: Non-Linear ProgressionNon Linear Index: how is it conducted?
The Non-Linear Index is the primary classificatory system and organizational paradigm for the conceptual holdings of the Tower, developed to manage information where traditional, sequential, or hierarchical cataloguing f…
Non Linear IndexBureau of Linear Interpretation: who are they?
Bureau of Linear Interpretation is the regulatory body vested with the authoritative, final determination of line ends within the Tower's administrative lexicon. Established under Provision 17(a) of the Seventh Concordan…
Bureau of Linear InterpretationPassages cited from this record
-
That a line may be bent is arithmetic. That a line may be bent and remain the same line is a proposition, and propositions are untangled at the desk, not in the corridor.
Clerk-Registrar of Linear Standards, Circular 4,104/3
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 7181.98 Linear Foot (Tower Standard)
Because you consulted