The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Librarian of the Third Quorum

MS 4695.39 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Librarian of the Third Quorum is the presiding officer of the Third Quorum, the standing body charged with the oversight of verification throughout the Tower. The office is ancient, though its jurisdiction is not: for the first several centuries of its existence the Librarian of the Third Quorum was a largely ceremonial figure, present at the sealing of documents and otherwise unconsulted. The modern office dates from the recensions of 1744, when Clause 1.α.1 fixed verification procedure in its current form and named the Librarian of the Third Quorum, "or higher," as the minimum authority competent to oversee it.

The qualifying phrase has caused more dispute than the office itself. It is not stated in Clause 1.α.1 what "or higher" comprises, nor whether the Third Order is higher than the Third Quorum, adjacent to it, or a separate ladder entirely.

Origin and the question of precedence

The office first appears in the Roll of Standing Quorums under the entry for the winter of 1446, where it is listed between the Librarian of the Second Quorum and a steward whose name survives only as "the elder of the east landing." Later recensions omit the steward and preserve the Librarian of the Third Quorum, a fact the Bureau of Precedence has twice declined to explain.

Clause 1.α.1 requires that verification under that clause be overseen by a Librarian of the Third Quorum or higher. It has never been settled whether a Librarian of the Third Order satisfies the clause by rank, or whether the two designations run on parallel tracks that never meet. The Office of Contestable Anomalies holds the former view; the Bureau of Precedence the latter. Neither has been asked to rule, and both have ruled anyway.

"Where a clause names two ladders and provides no rungs, the clerk shall ascend neither and record the discrepancy in the margin."

— Concordance 62, Annex 3

The Attesting Quorum

The Librarian of the Third Quorum sits ex officio as second voice of the Attesting Quorum. Witnessing Protocol (Clause 4-7) requires that a Librarian of the Third Order or higher be present for any event so governed, and in practice the Third Quorum has supplied that presence since at least 1801, when the Third Order stopped sending its own delegates.

This substitution has never been formalised. It was raised during the Affair of the Silent Quorum, when the Quorum of Imminence asserted overarching authority and issued a provisional ruling affirming the precedent of Review by Quorum. Librarian-In-Spiral Atherton argued in the same proceedings for the Doctrine of Implied Quorum, contending that a quorum properly constituted may imply the presence of any officer whose function it performs. The Third Concordance is silent on whether a Review by Quorum performed under that doctrine by the Seventh Quorum of Scribes binds the Ratification Quorum. The Librarian of the Third Quorum at the time, Librarian Sabel of the Long Gallery, attended eleven sessions of the Affair and signed none of the minutes, a reticence later cited in her favour by all parties.

Powers and instruments

The Librarian of the Third Quorum holds the Seal of Verification, which is applied in wax to the lower margin of the instrument verified and never to the reverse. The seal is re-cut every ninth year; the old matrix is broken and its fragments interred beneath the floor of the seal-room, and the inventory of fragments is kept by the Librarian-Archivist Kael.

The office may also convene a Walked Verification, a procedure inherited from the walking quorum permitted to the First Librarian's Council under Concordance 88 and narrowed to nine of fourteen seals under Concordance 91. Concordance 94 attempted to restore the eleven-seal threshold and remains disputed; the Librarian of the Third Quorum is not bound by any of the three, but has taken to citing 88 on the ground that it is the oldest.

The Librarian of the Third Quorum is not permitted to verify an instrument on which their own name appears. This includes instruments of appointment, and so a new Librarian of the Third Quorum must be verified by their predecessor, who must therefore be present, and therefore in possession of the seal, which they must relinquish at the conclusion of the ceremony. The interregnum is defined as the interval between the sealing and the handover, and during it no verification may proceed. The shortest recorded interregnum was under an hour. The longest, in the winter of 1931 on the ninth gallery, lasted nine days, during which no document in the Tower was verified and the queue outside the verification chamber reached the fourth landing.

Incidents

In 1877 the then-Librarian, Orin of the Lower Stacks, verified his own commission after a fire destroyed the attending clerk's copy. The verification was upheld by the Bureau of Precedence on the ground that the destroyed copy had been "the truer document" and that verifying the surviving one restored the position rather than disrupting it.

In 1902 the Quorum of Imminence established the status of the Seventh Quorum of Scribes retroactively as part of its provisional rulings, and the Librarian of the Third Quorum was directed to seal the instrument. He did so, then unsealed it, sealed it again, and entered a note in the margin: "sealed pending a view I have not been able to form." The margin note has since been treated as part of the instrument.

Current holder and customs

The office is presently held by Librarian Vess of the Ninth Spiral, appointed 1968. She maintains the standing entry in the Register of Forestalled Events for all verifications postponed by an unbroken Seal of Verification, and has recorded four.

By custom the Librarian of the Third Quorum does not carry the seal across the ninth gallery landing on the second Tuesday of any month, as the landing is being washed. The custom is recorded in no Concordance and has been observed since 1904.

Junior officers of the Third Quorum are designated Junior Librarians and are seated by seniority, save that a Junior Librarian who has once assisted at a walken verification is seated above one who has not, regardless of appointment.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Librarian-Archivist Kael: who are they?

Librarian-Archivist Kael (officially designated, per Annex 7 to the Third Concordance, as “the individual currently presiding over the concurrent duties of a Librarian and an Archivist-Specialist”) is a unique administra…

Librarian-Archivist Kael
Seventh Quorum of Scribes: who are they?

The Seventh Quorum of Scribes is a formal designation in Tower governance, officially recognized by Seventh Concordance, Revision 4 as the archival and procedural precedent for events occurring between 17 March 1891 and …

Seventh Quorum of Scribes
Librarian Orin: who were they?

Librarian Orin was a Librarian of the Third Order, active between the years recorded as Interval 4,112 and Interval 4,168 of the Granular Reckoning, and afterwards remembered chiefly for two matters that fell on opposite…

Librarian Orin
Concordance 91: what does it set out?

Concordance 91 is a document of the Concordance series, issued from the Ninth Scriptorium in the winter of the year recorded as 4,311 by the Tower's continuous register, and held in the open stacks on Amendment Tracking …

Concordance 91

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.