The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Idealist Cadre

MS 6511.86 · Guilds, orders and offices

Idealist Cadre designates any of the four sworn working bodies constituted under the Idealist Catalogue for the purpose of certifying phenomena as extant. The name is a collective one; the Tower has never maintained a single Idealist Cadre, and the plural is preferred in formal drafting. The Cadres were constituted by the Idealist Collegium between Year 197 and Year 199, drawing their members from among the Idealist Indexers then still active, and were dissolved with the Indexers and the Idealist Chapter in Year 204. Their seals were struck in that year and their benches reassigned, though the room in which they sat — Third Gallery, east of the numeral survey — remains listed on the floor plan under its old designation.

Constitution and numbering

The four Cadres were distinguished by spiral marking, not by seniority: Cadres I through IV, though Cadre IV was for most of its existence marked as Cadre III-B following an unresolved dispute over the numbering of a stairwell. The mistake was never corrected, and Cadre IV answers to both names in the surviving record, which has complicated every subsequent index of its proceedings.

Membership was fixed at nine per Cadre, of whom no fewer than five were required to sit for a certification to hold. The requirement was written into Second Concordance, Annex 6, and promptly contradicted by Ninth Concordance, Annex 6, which fixes the quorum at seven. Both annexes remain in force. The Collegium's practice, never committed to writing, was to seat nine and count seven, a compromise that satisfied neither document and was therefore assumed to be correct.

The work of certification

An Idealist Cadre did not determine whether a thing existed. It determined whether the Catalogue might say so. A petitioner brought the object, or a sufficiently detailed account of it, before a seated Cadre, which heard the account twice — once as given and once as read back by a Cadre Scribe — and compared the two readings for discrepancies. Discrepancies were not treated as evidence against the object. They were entered in the margin and left to the next recension.

"Where a thing is read back otherwise than it was offered, the reading stands, and the offering is presumed to have been imprecise."

— Idealist Catalogue, Supplementary Schedule 3, clause 14

Certification under this procedure was final for Tower purposes. Whether an object so certified was real outside the Tower was not put to the Cadres and would have been ruled out of order had it been. The standard formula of refusal, recorded in the Proceedings of Cadre II, folio 88, remains in use by other offices: "The question is not before this bench."

Dispute with the Verifier Cadre

The Idealist Cadres' long friction with the Verifier Cadre concerned the order of operations rather than the substance of any certification. The Verifiers held that nothing might be certified until it had been verified; the Idealists held that nothing might be verified until it had been certified, verification being a determination of whether a thing was what it had been certified to be. The two positions were reconciled in Year 201 by the Concordance of Precedence, which established that certification precedes verification in all cases except those in which it does not.

The exception was exercised 1,411 times in the three years before dissolution. No record explains any of them. A note in the hand of Scribe Alenna Vosk, appended to the Cadre III ledger and never countersigned, reads: "We certify first. They verify first. We have agreed not to discuss the interval."

Dissolution

The Idealist Cadres were dissolved by the same instrument that dissolved the Idealist Chapter and the Idealist Indexers in Year 204. The instrument does not name the Cadres. Their dissolution is inferred from the closure of the Catalogue to new entries, since a Cadre with no catalogue to certify into has no work, and the Collegium has since declined to constitute new ones. Cadre 77-Epsilon and Cadre 42-Sigma are sometimes described as successor bodies. Neither accepts the description, and Cadre 42-Sigma has twice petitioned to have it struck from the floor register.

Four benches, nine stools, and a reading stand were removed from Third Gallery in the winter of Year 204 and stored in the sub-vault. The stools were returned in Year 206; the benches were not. Enquiries should be addressed to the Idealist Collegium, which will not answer them.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Cadre 42-Sigma: who are they?

Cadre 42-Sigma is a standing Verification Cadre of the Librarians, constituted in Year 331 under Concordance 8814 and assigned continuous jurisdiction over the measurement and certification of staircase descents between …

Cadre 42-Sigma
Second Concordance: what does it set out?

The Second Concordance was the primary governance document of The Tower from Year 89 of the First Librarianate until its supersession by the Third Concordance in Year 12 of the Second Librarianate. It established the leg…

Second Concordance
Idealist Indexers: who are they?

The Idealist Indexers were a short-lived, highly specialized subset of clerical functionaries within the Librarian Order who operated from Year 193 to Year 204. They were formed by a procedural merger of tasks belonging …

Idealist Indexers
Concordance of Precedence: what does it set out?

The Concordance of Precedence is a standing instrument of the Librarian Council, sealed in the winter of 6,410 and amended eleven times since, which fixes the order in which the First Librarian's Council, the Librarian C…

Concordance of Precedence

Passages cited from this record

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.