The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Holding LSA-401.8

MS 2448.02 · Documents and ordinances

Holding LSA-401.8 is a documented archival holding consisting of a single index card and the eleven thousand, four hundred and six cards that the first card is understood to be about. It is shelved in Bay 11 at the fourth aperture, forty-one paces from the site of the 1173 incident, and is administered under Provisional Holding Number 401.8-P. The holding has never been counted twice with the same result.

The card at LSA-401.8 itself is unremarkable and legible. It reads, in full: See other cards. No accession clerk has ever been able to establish which other cards, and the Office of Designation has declined four petitions to have the phrase struck as insufficient.

Description and extent

The eleven thousand, four hundred and six subordinate cards occupy three and a half shelf-spans and are index cards of standard issue. Each bears a single place name and a date, and no two are alike. None corresponds to any floor of the Tower that can be located, and none of the dates given fall within the Year of the Archive 1142 to the Year of the Archive 1198 range that governs Holding LSA-114.2 and most of the LSA series.

Attempts at enumeration have produced the following results, all on file in the Scriptorium of the Fourth Aperture:

  • Year of the Archive 1261 — 11,406 cards, counted by hand over nineteen days.
  • Year of the Archive 1261, recount — 11,405 cards.
  • Year of the Archive 1288 — 11,406 cards, but a different 11,406, with forty-one names absent and forty-one others present.
  • Year of the Archive 1304 — count abandoned on the eleventh day; the counting clerk had begun to recognise the names.

The 1288 substitution

The discrepancy of 1288 is the holding's central difficulty and the reason it remains under Status Beta. A comparison of the two enumerations, conducted over the winter of 1288–1289 by the clerk Ovida Menn, established that the forty-one substituted cards were all of places with two words in their names, while the forty-one displaced cards were not. Menn submitted that this proved the holding was "not a list but a position," and requested a reclassification of the entire LSA series.

"A list may be corrected. A position may only be occupied. That LSA-401.8 is occupied should be evident to any reader who has spent an hour at the fourth aperture."

— Ovida Menn, Memorial on the Fourth Aperture Holdings, Year of the Archive 1289

Menn's request was refused under the amendment to Holding 44.12- which holds a holding's validity to rest on its internal documentation. Menn was reassigned to Holding 9,999-A in 1290 and did not return to Bay 11.

Dispute between the Concordances

The holding's status is contested between two instruments. Annex 7 of the Fourth Concordance provides that a holding bearing no self-description beyond a cross-reference shall be read in the direction the cross-reference points. The Seventh Concordance, drafted some decades later and by a different hand, provides at Clause 3 that a holding shall be described as it describes itself, and that no clerk may supply a subject the holding has declined to name.

Read together, the two clauses place LSA-401.8 in the position of a holding that is its own subject, which the Office of Designation has ruled is "not permitted, but not prohibited." The ruling, filed 9 Verdant 1301, is nine words long and has been cited in forty-one subsequent decisions concerning holdings that point at themselves.

The Paradox of the Verified Holding is frequently invoked here and has never helped. Procedural Neutrality has been recommended twice by visiting Librarians and twice declined, on the grounds that the holding is not neutral and has never claimed to be.

Theories of the subordinate cards

Three explanations of the subordinate cards remain current. The itinerary position holds that the cards are a record of places visited by a single unnamed traveller, and notes the recurrence of a harbour in eleven of the names. The correspondence position, favoured in the Office of Designation, holds that each card names a floor that did exist until the card was written, at which point it did not. The replacement position holds that the cards are the contents of an earlier holding, dispersed and re-formed, and points to the physical wear on the card edges, which is consistent with repeated shelving and re-shelving elsewhere.

No position accounts for the forty-one substitutions of 1288, which remain the only instance of a holding altering itself in a manner that observers could not attribute to handling, damp, or the passivity of shelved material.

Access and handling

LSA-401.8 may be consulted without petition, provided the reader does not remove the first card from its position at the head of the span, does not reorder the subordinate cards, and does not read the names aloud. The last instruction was issued by Librarian Vey Anselm in 1304 following the abandonment of that year's count, and appears in no Concordance; its authority rests on the single signature and has not been tested. Readers wishing to compare the 1261 and 1288 enumerations must apply to the Scriptorium of the Fourth Aperture in writing and must state their business in one sentence. The office is closed on the eleventh day of each recount.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Active vs. Passive Holding: how is it conducted?

Active vs. Passive Holding is the foundational taxonomic distinction governing the status of all catalogued entities within The Tower. It delineates the legal, operational, and philosophical parameters of a holding's eng…

Active vs. Passive Holding
Office of Designation: who are they?
Year of the Archive 1142: what happened?

Year of the Archive 1142 is a designation in the Standard Archive Chronology primarily noted for the discovery of The Obsidian Decree. It is also the calendar year in which the Inquiry into the Posting of A-77b was forma…

Year of the Archive 1142
Seventh Concordance: what does it set out?

The Seventh Concordance is the primary administrative codex governing the measurement, classification, and cataloguing of phenomena defined by their absence, incompletion, or intrinsic paradox. Ratified in Year 47 of the…

Seventh Concordance

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.