The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Gradient 4–6 (Substantive)

MS 0169.08 · Practices and doctrines

Gradient 4–6 (Substantive) is the middle band of the Gradient Scale, occupying the interval between Gradient 1–3 and Gradient 7–9. It is the only band whose members are held to possess ontological weight in the sense set out in the Manual of Substantive Derivation (7th Revision), and the only band for which the Office of Substantive Assessment requires a full Substantive Review before any change of reading may be entered on a floor register. The band is subdivided into Gradient 4 (Thin Substantive), Gradient 5 (Settled Substantive) and Gradient 6 (Substantive, Approaching Potency), a tripartite division maintained less for measurement than for the allocation of archival furniture.

Definition and calibration

Calibration of the band is performed by the Clerks of the Gradient, who alone manufacture the Ephemeral Gradient stylus used for readings in the field. Readings at 4–6 are taken at three cubits from the subject and at a temperature the Clerks decline to state in writing, describing it only as "the temperature of the corridor." A reading is valid for nine days; a reading taken on a stair is valid for none, as the Clerks hold that stairs introduce a longitudinal error no stylus can correct.

The lower bound of the band is fixed by the Third Concordance, whose Requirements for Substantive Introduction establish that nothing may be catalogued as Substantive unless it can be shown to persist when unobserved by at least two Librarians who have agreed not to discuss it. The upper bound is not fixed by any document. It is determined case by case by the Bureau of Gradient Integrity, which governs the point at which a gradient function becomes Gradient 10 and has historically taken a generous view of where Gradient 6 ends.

Substantive Annotations and the Tenth Concordance

Objects within the band are recorded by Substantive Annotation, under the Tenth Concordance and its Principle of Substantive Primacy — that where an Annotation and a floor catalogue disagree, the Annotation governs, unless the catalogue is older, in which case it does not. The Department of Substantive Cataloguing promulgated the current revision of the derivation manual on 14 Ventôse, Tower Gregorian Year 712, largely to settle the question of whether an Annotation of a Gradient 6 object may be annotated in turn. It may not. The Department's annex to the revision records that the practice was discontinued after the fourth instance on Sub-basement Eta, where a stack of self-annotating catalogues reached the ceiling and could not be separated without a ruling.

The Delisle grievance

The band's administrative history is dominated by the dispute conventionally called the Delisle grievance, though the Clerk in question has asked that it not be called that. In the winter of Year 698, Clerk Ondrast Delisle submitted that a set of forty-one reading-room chairs on the ninth gallery of Sub-basement Theta had drifted from Gradient 5 to Gradient 4 across a single season without any corresponding change in the chairs, the gallery, or the lighting. The Bureau of Gradient Integrity declined to revise the readings and instead declared the band gradient-locked, a use of authority since upheld but never repeated. Delisle's memorandum of protest — "that a thing may become less itself while remaining entirely itself, and that this should require a form" — is preserved in the Bureau's annex and is still cited by Clerks seeking overtime.

"The chairs are the same chairs. I have sat in them. If the Scale says otherwise, the Scale is describing something other than chairs, and I would like to be told what."

— O. Delisle, memorandum to the Bureau of Gradient Integrity, 3 Pluviôse, Year 698

The Bureau's reply, fourteen words long and sealed in the ordinary way, is appended without comment.

Relation to neighbouring bands

Objects entering the band from below are said to be "settling" and are placed under observation for one full Concordance cycle. Objects leaving it for Gradient 7–9 are said to have "taken," and the observation is discontinued without notice to the observer, a courtesy the Office of Substantive Assessment has twice proposed to extend and twice withdrawn. The Luminal Gradient is frequently confused with Gradient 6 in the older literature; the Bureau maintains that the resemblance is coincidental and has issued no further statement. Gradient 4 is likewise distinguished from Gradient 0, which denotes Absent or Unmeasurable and which the Clerks insist is a different sort of nothing.

Recording conventions

Substantive entries are recorded in black ink on unruled paper, with the band designation written in the left margin and the reading in the right. Erasures are not permitted; a corrected reading is struck through once and the correction entered below, initialled by the assessing Librarian. Where a band reading falls precisely on the boundary between 4 and 5, the entry is made at 5 and the discrepancy is not recorded. Visitors are asked not to lean on the reading tables.

The Animate Archive Protocol A9-γ, "Substantive Absences" applies to the band in full, and any floor on which a Substantive object is found to be absent without a corresponding entry in the register is closed to cataloguing until the absence itself has been catalogued. The Pedantic Gradient and the residue recorded in The Silentium Gradient Residue are matters for Gradient Mapping and lie outside the present article.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Gradient Scale: how is it conducted?

The Gradient Scale is the formal, unitary measure of quality, condition, or conceptual potency used in the catalogical assessment and archival regulation of Tower holdings. Distinct from, though often conflated with, spe…

Gradient Scale
Tenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Tenth Concordance is a foundational document of administrative governance within the Tower, ratified on 14 Spiral, Year 412 of the Third Cataloguing Era. It is primarily known for its pivotal annex, Annex Ω, which au…

Tenth Concordance
Ephemeral Gradient stylus: what is it for?

The Ephemeral Gradient stylus is a certified writing instrument, manufactured exclusively by the Clerks of the Gradient, used for the inscribing and amending of statutes related to ephemeral spatial features. Its primary…

Ephemeral Gradient stylus

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.