The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Fragment of Retroactive Humidity

MS 4408.50 · Objects and instruments

The Fragment of Retroactive Humidity is a small vellum leaf, catalogued as holding R-9/41, held under seal in the Sub-Vault of the Office of Hygrometric Records on Floor 301. It is not the most famous damp document in the Tower — that distinction belongs to the Miletus Fragment Humidity — but it is the oldest holding whose dampness is agreed to have arrived before the scribes who wrote it did. The fragment was catalogued at a recorded humidity of 41%, in accordance with the Humidity Annex of the Central Vellum Repository, and has remained at that figure since its first measurement, regardless of the weather, the season, or the number of persons in the room.

Description and condition

The leaf measures 148 by 211 millimetres and bears eleven lines of a trade inventory in a hand the Guild of Dormant Scribes dates to the fourth recension of the Western Stair period. Lines one through nine are legible. Lines ten and eleven have never been read, not because the ink has faded but because the vellum is wet at the lower margin and has been wet since before the Guild's copying was complete. The moisture does not spread, drip, or evaporate. Vault attendants blot the margin twice yearly and record the result as no change.

The fragment is stored flat, unweighted, in a lidded cedar tray. The tray may not be carried through the Eastern Corridor between the hours of Vespers and the changing of the watch, an instruction entered in the Sub-Vault register in an unattributed hand and retained since.

Discovery on Floor 404

The leaf first came to notice during the preliminary survey preceding the Great Dampness of Cycle 7421, though it was not then recognised as connected to it. A junior cataloguer, Ilse Vantrey, was reconciling holdings in Floor 404: The Archive of Lost Protocols when she observed that the shelf upon which the fragment lay was wet, and that the wetness had already damaged three neighbouring items before the fragment had been accessioned. Her report, submitted under protest because she had been told to reconcile and not to observe, reached the Office of Hygrometric Records in Cycle 7421, seven days before the Great Dampness of Cycle 7421 proper.

The Office subsequently classified the fragment as a terminal breach rather than an affected item, and cited it in its findings as evidence that the surge had entered through the Archive of Lost Protocols. Vantrey's original report is preserved as Appendix 6 and is the only document in the file that describes the dampness without naming a cause.

Scholarly dispute

The central dispute concerns the fragment's age relative to its dampness, and it is not settled. The Retroactive School holds, on the authority of On Retroactive Precedence, that the dampness is a genuine instance of Retroactive Humidity and that the leaf should be read as a document written on paper that had already been ruined. The Office of Hygrometric Records accepts this in principle but has declined to adjust the holding's date of accession, on the ground that its directives cannot be applied to dampness that predates the register in which the dampness would be recorded.

A minority position, associated with the Sub-Vault's present keeper, argues that the fragment is simply a wet leaf and that the Office's difficulties arise from having classified it too early. This view has never been put in writing, and therefore cannot be cited.

"Where an item is found damp, and the damp is found to precede the finding, the item shall be entered under the date of the damp."

— Clause 3, second recension, read against the margin note of the ninth

The contradiction between the two recensions is well known and has been referred to the Retroactive Adjustment desk, which has not reported. A separate application to relist the fragment as a Type B holding under Type B was withdrawn in Cycle 7402 after the Office observed that a Type B classification would require it to be dry.

Relationship to the Miletus holdings

The fragment is frequently confused with the Miletus Fragment Humidity in petitions to the Retroactive School, and the confusion has been productive. In the course of the Miletus Fragment Dispute the Guild of Dormant Scribes cited the Fragment of Retroactive Humidity as precedent for the proposition that a damp document may govern a dry clause. The arbitration of Cycle 12 did not adopt the analogy, but the fragment's catalogue entry was amended thereafter to note its "possible bearing on disputed instruments," a phrase the Office has twice attempted to strike and twice failed to strike.

A request to transfer the leaf to the Miletus Fragment Petition file was refused in Cycle 7409 on grounds of humidity, the two holdings being incompatible at close shelf distance.

Access

The fragment may be consulted by written application to the Office of Hygrometric Records, supported by a countersignature from the applicant's floor supervisor. It is not lent. It is not photographed. The Office's standing note on the matter reads, in full: "The holding is damp. Visitors should not be surprised by this."

Consultation is permitted for one hour, during which the reader is asked to keep both hands on the table. Since Cycle 7415 the fragment has been measured before and after every consultation; the readings have not varied, and the Office has begun to record the constancy itself as a finding, under the heading Retroactive Drift Assessment.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Retroactive Adjustment: how is it conducted?

Retroactive Adjustment is the official administrative process by which the Library's timeline and physical holdings are reconciled following the identification and resolution of a Retroactive Anomaly. Governed by Clause …

Retroactive Adjustment
Clause 3 (Retroactive Application): how is it conducted?

Clause 3 (Retroactive Application) is a provision found in multiple foundational Concordances and administrative ordinances. It is not a singular entity but a class of clause establishing the authority and, critically, t…

Clause 3 (Retroactive Application)
On Retroactive Precedence: what does it set out?

On Retroactive Precedence is a foundational treatise issued by the Retroactive School on Floor Δ-49 (the "Silent Spire") that establishes the procedural and philosophical framework for the temporal reconciliation of conf…

On Retroactive Precedence
Great Dampness of Cycle 7421: what happened?

The Great Dampness of Cycle 7,421 was an event of extraordinary duration in which a surge of what the Office of Hygrometric Records termed Retroactive Humidity overwhelmed every containment measure then in force, moisten…

Great Dampness of Cycle 7421

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.