The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Floor 317: The Atrium of Partially Recalled Conversations

MS 6144.25 · Places and structures

Floor 317: The Atrium of Partially Recalled Conversations is a public reading room of the middle stack, entered from the 317th stairhead by a door with no handle on the inside. Its holdings are not documents but residues: fragments of speech that were spoken, imperfectly heard, and later half-recovered by the person addressed. The Atrium neither preserves nor discards these fragments. It files them, in the order in which they surface, and it is this filing order that has made the floor the most litigated in the Seventeenth Quarto.

The Atrium occupies the full breadth of the floor and is arranged as a shallow amphitheatre of laminated alcoves, forty-one in number, each seating one. Patrons are asked to speak aloud whatever they half-remember upon entering, and to speak nothing afterwards. The acoustics are such that a fragment offered in Alcove 3 is audible, faintly and wrongly, in Alcove 27. The Bureau of Spatial Integrity has ruled twice that this cross-audibility is accidental; the Sub-Bureau of Temporal Reconciliation has ruled once that it is the entire point of the room.

Collection and holding

Admission to Floor 317 is by recall only. A patron who claims to remember a conversation in full is turned away at the stairhead and referred to the Vault of Recalled Sounds, where complete sonic records are kept between sub-floors -301.a and -301.δ under the terms of the Third Concordance. A patron who remembers nothing at all is likewise turned away, and referred downward to Floor -302: The Basin of Recalled Echoes, which handles echoes of definitively past events and has no interest in the merely probable. The Atrium occupies the narrow band between these two refusals.

Fragments are inscribed on laminated slips and shelved by alcove, not by speaker. Where a fragment cannot be assigned to a conversation — a phrase that might have belonged to either of two exchanges, or to neither — it is entered in the register as a floating remnant and shelved at the end of the run pending review. Floating remnants comprise roughly nine per cent of the Atrium's holdings and an estimated sixty per cent of its disputes.

The contested chronology

In the winter of the year recorded as 1188 by the Atrium's own register, the Atrium acquired two fragments of the same exchange, one from each party, which described the conversation in incompatible terms. The Bureau of Spatial Integrity issued a primary chronology assigning the exchange to Alcove 12 and a duration of four minutes. Within the month the Sub-Bureau of Temporal Reconciliation issued a primary chronology assigning the same exchange to Alcove 12 and a duration of nineteen minutes. The alcove was not in dispute. The duration was, and so — by consequence — was the question of whether the exchange had ended in agreement or in silence.

The quarrel was referred to the concordant machinery and produced the instrument now cited as the founding of the Bureau itself. The relevant clause reads:

"Where two chronologies of a single alcove conflict, neither shall be preferred; the alcove shall be re-laminated and both chronologies shelved face inward, so that no patron may read one without the other."

— Third Concordance, Annex 4, clause 7

Alcove 12 has been re-laminated eleven times. The practice of shelving face inward was abandoned in the fourth recension, restored in the seventh, and is currently observed in all alcoves except 12, where the laminate is too thick.

Cross-audibility and its consequences

The crossing of sound between distant alcoves has generated a class of fragment that belongs to no conversation at all but is compounded of several. The Atrium's keepers call these braids and file them separately, in the cabinet beneath the west gallery, where they are considered stable enough to consult but not stable enough to cite. A braid may combine a half-remembered farewell with a half-remembered instruction and produce a third utterance that no one ever said, which is then half-remembered by a later patron and returned to the floor as a genuine fragment. The Atrium has no procedure for closing this loop, and the keepers have twice declined to propose one.

Complaints about cross-audibility are heard on the landing outside, never in the alcoves. The landing is unroofed. Complaints are heard in dry weather only.

Relationship to adjacent holdings

Floor 317 does not accept echoes, which are the province of the negative tiers, nor full sonic records, which are the province of the Vault. It has, however, a standing arrangement with the Atrium of Lapsed Mandates regarding fragments in which a speaker appears to be issuing an instruction that was never carried out; these are transferred upward when the lapsed mandate can be identified, and retained when it cannot. A comparable arrangement with Floor 1173 governs fragments spoken in near-darkness, where the Atrium's laminators concede they cannot verify the speaker's face.

Patrons are reminded that the Murmuring Column holding on Floor 199, Vestibule 12-G, is a Status Beta object and is not a substitute for the Atrium. Its whispered conversations are of unknown origin and are therefore neither partial nor recalled, and its keepers resent the comparison.

Accessions of note

The Atrium's register of notable accessions is kept in three hands and lists, among others:

  • the fragment "—not the second stair, the one after", accession 317/44, speaker unidentified, referent lost;
  • the nine-minute silence recorded in Alcove 31, accessioned as a fragment on the grounds that both parties remembered it;
  • the disputed exchange of 1188, accessioned twice, shelved face inward.

The silence remains the most consulted holding on the floor and the only one that has never required re-lamination.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Atrium of Lapsed Mandates: where is it?

The Atrium of Lapsed Mandates is a subsidiary archival space, designated Subsidiary Atrium 7.117-omega, located on the unnamed interstitial level between Floor 1173 and Floor 711. It serves as the primary physical reposi…

Atrium of Lapsed Mandates
Floor 1173 (The Penumbral Atrium): where is it?

Floor 1173 (The Penumbral Atrium) is a Contemplative Atrium designated for the archival study of phenomena that exist in a state of partial substantiation, primarily residual sounds, deferred consequences, and conditiona…

Floor 1173 (The Penumbral Atrium)
Third Concordance: what does it set out?

The Third Concordance is the foundational regulatory document governing the Librarianate's procedures for the classification, verification, and archival of non-existent subjects. Ratified in Year 12 of the Second Librari…

Third Concordance
Vault of Recalled Sounds: where is it?

The Vault of Recalled Sounds is a negative-tier preservation repository located between sub-floors -301.a and -301.δ, and the largest repository for spun-glass cylinders in the Tower. It functions as the physical deposit…

Vault of Recalled Sounds

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.