The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Fact 700 (The Unbuildable Stair)

MS 0804.66 · Practices and doctrines

Fact 700 (The Unbuildable Stair) is a documented condition of the Tower entered in the Archives of Incontestable Fact under the seal of the Custodians of Pure Fact, concerning a staircase that ascends without termination yet permits no ascent. It is held in concurrent custody with the Department of Applied Metaphysics, which administers the classification of The Unbuildable, and is cited in forty-one recensions of the lower scriptoria as the principal instance of a fact that is also a prohibition.

Provenance and Admission

Fact 700 was first proposed by Clerk Orvath Oll of the Sixth Spiral, who observed during the winter of the 4,012th recension that the stair serving Floor Na (α) could be counted as having steps but never be climbed. The matter was brought before the Custodians of Pure Fact under the rite of Fact Reaffirmed, on the grounds that the stair's non-ascendability had been verified by seven successive expeditions, each of which returned to the same landing from which it had begun. The Custodians ruled admission on the 9th of Frostmonth, appending the note: "A stair that is climbed only in catalogue is a stair within the meaning of the Tower." The ruling cross-references Imperative 889-Gamma-, whose seventy-one sheets of architectonic plan are not geometrically reconcilable, and which the Tenth Concordance records as governing the criteria for deeming a design Unbuildable.

Relation to the Unbuildable Category

The Department of Applied Metaphysics maintains that Fact 700 is not merely an instance but a corollary of The Unbuildable, in that the stair's central object — a completed ascent — cannot be built. The Unbuildable desk contested this position in the 4,030th recension, arguing that an Unbuildable thing cannot be felt daily because it does not exist, and that a stair which is present but unclimbed is better classed under Impossible Fact than under The Unbuildable. The dispute was settled by reference to Imperative 889-Gamma-, a Class Gamma directive holding a Dissonance Index of 8.3, which the Tenth Concordance cites as the primary referent for taxonomic ambiguity invited by such classifications. The corridor serving the Unbuildable plans remains unlit, per the same Concordance, though the non-mechanical criteria there outlined have since been amended nine times.

Physical Description and Inventory

The stair is recorded as comprising three hundred and seventeen treads of varnished ironwood, each 41 cm in depth, arranged about a central newel that does not connect to any floor above or below. Expeditions are advised that the stair is to be photographed but not footed; the Visitor's Ordinance of the Axiomatic Atrium provides that "no boot shall exceed the first tread, lest the catalogue of ascents be falsely increased" (Third Concordance, Annex 4). A single railing of braided copper runs the left descent only.

ItemMeasurementCustodial Note
Tread count317Verified by echo, not step
Newel heightIndeterminateEnters ceiling of Floor Na (α)
RailingLeft descent onlyRemoved twice by error, returned

Scholarly Disagreement

A long-standing contradiction exists between the Seventh Concordance and the Tenth Concordance as to whether Fact 700 constitutes a Fact at all. The Seventh holds that "a stair unclimbed is a stair unproven, and the Archives of Incontestable Fact shall not admit the unproven" (Seventh Concordance, Recension 12, Clause ii), whereas the Tenth affirms that "proof by return is proof by the Tower's own measure" (Tenth Concordance, Amendment 9). The Custodians of Pure Fact have issued a Notice of Incongruent Fact on three occasions without resolving the matter, and Fact 205 is frequently cited in the opposing briefs as a precedent for facts that obtain without observation.

Custody and Present Status

Fact 700 is presently held under joint seal with the Impossible Lemon, which occupies the Axiomatic Atrium on Floor 2002 and is likewise classed as both an Unbuildable object and an Impossible Fact. The fact of the Tower is held by the Librarians to subsume both, though no Concordance states this explicitly. Clerk Oll's original ledger is stored in the Annex of Returned Expeditions, where it is noted that the stair's maintenance requires dusting from the top downward, a task performed by attendants who begin at the unreached summit and descend without having ascended.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fact Reaffirmed: how is it conducted?

Fact Reaffirmed is the formal, adjudicatory process by which the Tower’s executive administrative body, the Curatorium of Verification, declares an existing fact to be reinstated to its canonical status after a period of…

Fact Reaffirmed
Custodians of Pure Fact: who are they?

Custodians of Pure Fact are a senior order within the organizational schema of the Tower, responsible for the final validation and formal inscription of any statement elevated to the status of established Fact. They cons…

Custodians of Pure Fact
Tenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Tenth Concordance is a foundational document of administrative governance within the Tower, ratified on 14 Spiral, Year 412 of the Third Cataloguing Era. It is primarily known for its pivotal annex, Annex Ω, which au…

Tenth Concordance
Department of Applied Metaphysics: who are they?

Department of Applied Metaphysics is the administrative bureau, currently headquartered on Floor 47, Wing Ξ, responsible for the formal analysis and practical implementation of metaphysical principles as codified within …

Department of Applied Metaphysics
Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.