The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Emergency Concordance 9.1.3

MS 4425.12 · Documents and ordinances

Emergency Concordance 9.1.3 is the short-form instrument by which the Materialist Chapter exercised extraordinary powers during the Great Salting of ‘07 and the reshelving disturbances that followed it. It is the only Emergency Concordance to have been issued in a single sitting, without recension, and the only one whose preamble consists of a single sentence: "The Tower will be read once more." It authorized, among other measures, the deployment of Luminous Verdian agents and the suspension of the Circadian Reshelving Ordinances for a period of ninety-one days. It was drafted on Floor 4,412 (the Vestibule of Provisional Seals) on 3 Firthing, and bears eleven seals where the customary number is four.

Origin and drafting

Emergency Concordance 9.1.3 was composed under the authority of the Third Concordance, Annex Theta-9, Clause 14, and is held to derive its standing from the Emergency Powers Protocol rather than from the ordinary concordant sequence — a distinction that has mattered in every dispute about it since. The drafting chamber was sealed at the eleventh bell and reopened at dawn; the record of those hours is held in the Annex Sigma of the Ninety-Second, where it is filed under "Unedited Testimony" and may be consulted only in the presence of a Librarian of the third grade.

The instrument's brevity is attributed to the presiding clerk, Halverin Doess, who is reported to have refused all amendments on the ground that "a concordance read twice is a concordance disagreed with once." Doess appended his seal to the instrument at the Record of Emergency on the same morning, some hours after the seal itself had been applied, an irregularity noted but never pursued.

Provisions

The operative clauses of 9.1.3 are four in number — a figure so small that early copyists assumed pages had been lost and inserted blank leaves in their transcriptions to make up the number. Of these, Clause 2 authorizes Luminous Verdian agents in the investigation of Un-sourced Phenomena, working in conjunction with the supplementary authority of Emergency Measure 12. Clause 3 suspends the Circadian Reshelving Ordinances outright, on the reasoning that a schedule of reshelving is "of no force against material that cannot yet be placed." Clause 4 is procedural and concerns candles.

The suspension under Clause 3 was applied, in practice, only to Floors 4,400 through 4,700, and lapsed at the end of the ninety-first day without renewal. The stacks below Floor 4,700 were never reshelved under the suspension at all, a fact not discovered until the following winter and discussed at length in Emergency Directive 891-5.

Relation to Emergency Custodianship

Emergency Concordance 9.1.3 does not itself invoke Emergency Custodianship; it presumes it. The distinction is technical and was contested within a fortnight of issue. The Office of Emergency Custodianship has consistently held that 9.1.3 operates only where custodianship is already in force under the Emergency Powers Protocol, while the Chapter has argued the reverse — that the Concordance's own preamble constitutes an invocation sufficient in itself. Neither position has been adjudicated, and both are cited in the working papers of Emergency Ordinance 112-B.7.

Dispute over date and precedence

Scholars disagree sharply as to when 9.1.3 took effect. The Theta-9 recension gives the third of Firthing; the Chapter's own ledger gives the second; and the Record of Emergency bears an entry in Doess's hand dated only "the morning after." The discrepancy has never been resolved and is regarded by some as evidence that the Concordance was issued twice, and by others as evidence that it was issued once and then very quietly again.

"The instrument is dated to its own need. Where the need precedes the seal, the seal governs; where the seal precedes the need, the need is presumed."

— Third Concordance, Annex Theta-9, Clause 14, commentary

A minority position, advanced in the reading-room notes of the Provisional Stone-Wardens Committee, holds that 9.1.3 was never properly engrossed and that all subsequent practice rests on a fair copy. The Committee has not published its findings and is not expected to.

Aftermath and standing

Emergency Concordance 9.1.3 expired by its own terms and has never been repealed. It is therefore, uniquely among the Emergency Concordances, both spent and in force — a condition the Tower's clerks describe as "resting" and which permits its citation in current matters provided the citer states which clause and which day. Its suspension of reshelving is still cited in the training of the Auditory Resonance Drill, and its preamble is engraved above the door of the Vestibule of Provisional Seals, though the engraver's plate shows the final word as "more." The door cannot be propped open, even for carrying.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Ninety-Second Concordance: what does it set out?

The Ninety-Second Concordance is a foundational administrative text concerning the procedural authorization of movement, consultation, and temporary resource reallocation within the Tower. Ratified in Year 47 of the Seco…

Ninety-Second Concordance
Emergency Powers Protocol: how is it conducted?

The Emergency Powers Protocol refers to the codified set of procedures and authorizations by which standard governance under the Third Concordance can be temporarily superseded in response to a state of existential threa…

Emergency Powers Protocol
Emergency Measure 12: Concerning the Provisional Retention and Study of Un-sourced Phenomena: how is it conducted?

Emergency Measure 12: Concerning the Provisional Retention and Study of Un-sourced Phenomena is the instrument by which the Curatorial Council assumed emergency authority over phenomena discovered within The Tower that c…

Emergency Measure 12: Concerning the Provisional Retention and Study of Un-sourced Phenomena
Emergency Ordinance 112-B.7: what does it set out?

Emergency Ordinance 112-B.7 is a provisional measure ratified on the 14th of Frostfall, 881, concerning the temporary sequestration of stairwells that exhibit a downward bias exceeding three floors per unmeasured interva…

Emergency Ordinance 112-B.7

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.