The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Echo-Discrepancy

MS 2356.50 · Practices and doctrines

The Echo-Discrepancy is the formal term for any divergence between an echo and the record of the reflection that produced it, whether because the echo carries content the reflecting surface did not send or because it fails to carry content the surface did. The term is defined in the Concordance of Terms, Fourth Recension, Annex 2, and classified under the schedules maintained by the Office of Discrepancy Management. It is not to be confused with a simple miscount, which is a fault of the counter, nor with a Discrepancy Report, which is the instrument by which a suspected divergence is brought to notice. An Echo-Discrepancy is a fault of the echo itself, and the Tower treats it accordingly.

Definition and classification

The Fourth Recension distinguishes three classes. A positive discrepancy is one in which the echo returns matter not present in the source; a negative discrepancy is one in which matter present in the source is absent from the echo; and a persistent discrepancy is one that survives three successive re-reflections without alteration. Only the third class is entered in the Discrepancy Volumes, and only the third class attracts the attention of the Discrepancy Clerks. The first two are recorded, sealed, and left to settle, a practice defended in the Fourth Recension itself on the ground that "an echo twice repeated is a rumour; an echo thrice repeated is a record" (Annex 2, clause 9).

Classification is performed by the clerk who first observes the divergence, and is not subject to appeal. This has caused difficulty. In Year 1,806 a clerk of the Lower Reading Rooms classified a persistent divergence as positive on the ground that the echo had returned a corridor that did not exist; the corridor was subsequently found, and the classification was allowed to stand on the principle that the echo had returned it before the corridor was found, which was held to be the same thing.

The Kappa-Aperture Discrepancy Echo

The largest recorded instance remains the Kappa-Aperture Discrepancy Echo, which arose from the dispute between Pell and Elara Chen over the inventory count of the Echo-Spires of Myn in Cycle 12,431. The divergence was first noted when the count returned by the Spires exceeded the count dispatched to them by a margin of one, and the margin did not close on re-reflection. The Kappa-Aperture Discrepancy is now recognized as the instigating incident of the larger event, and the paperwork generated by it occupies four shelves in the Annex of Struck Sections.

Archon Theodora, invested in Year 1,842, has taken the resolution of the Echo Discrepancy into her own work program, and the Office of Discrepancy Management attends her on the matter. The Office also maintains a continuous watch over the Aris Thorne Discrepancy, which has not altered since it was first entered and is watched nonetheless.

Filing

An Echo-Discrepancy is filed on Discrepancy Form 37-A, in which the sections relating to ordinary miscount are struck through and the echo particulars entered in the margin. The margin is 41 millimetres wide, a dimension fixed by the Stationery Concordance of Year 1,199 and never revised, though the forms themselves have been revised eleven times. Clerks who run past the margin are instructed to continue on a second form and strike through its first four sections in turn, so that a long discrepancy may be read as a sequence of struck forms with a single margin at the end.

"Where the margin is exhausted, the clerk shall not compress the hand. A compressed hand is a second discrepancy."

— Stationery Concordance of Year 1,199, Schedule 3

Scholarly disagreement

The Fourth Recension holds that an Echo-Discrepancy exists only where a record of the reflection was made before the echo returned, and that an unrecorded reflection cannot generate a discrepancy because there is nothing for the echo to disagree with. The Fifth Recension, Draft takes the opposite position, arguing at Annex 1 that the echo is itself a record and that requiring a prior record is "to ask the shadow for a witness before it will admit the sun" (Draft Annex 1, clause 4). The Draft has never been ratified, but the Discrepancy Clerks have followed its reasoning since Year 1,788, when a clerk named Ovren Halloway refused to close a file on the Fourth Recension's ground and was upheld by the Office of Discrepancy Management on the practical argument that the file was already open.

A third position, advanced by the School of Reflected Practice and never formally answered, holds that the distinction is empty because every reflection is recorded somewhere in the Tower, if only by the surface that performed it. The School's Memorial on Unwitnessed Surfaces (Year 1,833) is cited chiefly for its closing sentence, which the Office has declined to annotate.

Related practices

Echo-Discrepancy is distinguished from Echo Tracing, which follows an echo back to its surface without judging the content, and from Echo Containment, which is applied only after a persistent classification and involves the sealing of the reflecting surface rather than the echo. The relationship to Chronic Discrepancy Inertia is disputed: the Office treats inertia as a property of the file, the School of Reflected Practice as a property of the echo, and the Discrepancy Volumes record it as neither, having been compiled before the question was asked. The oldest unresolved entry, the Aethelred Discrepancy, occupies Volume I, folio 3, and is filed under both headings.

Visitors to the Echo Galleries are asked not to speak while a reflection is in progress. The rule is posted at the door and is enforced by the gallery attendants, who are not Librarians and have no other duties.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Discrepancy Volumes: how is it conducted?

Discrepancy Volumes is the collective designation for those bound holdings whose physical extent is held to disagree with their own catalogue descriptions. The category is administrative rather than material: a Discrepan…

Discrepancy Volumes
Kappa-Aperture Discrepancy: what happened?

The Kappa-Aperture Discrepancy denotes a specific class of administrative event arising from a procedural misalignment between the Kappa Cycle and the Aperture Cycle during a scheduled inventory. The titular incident occ…

Kappa-Aperture Discrepancy
Lower Reading Rooms: what is it?

The Lower Reading Rooms are a variable complement of halls, alcoves, and descended galleries occupying the archive's lower register, principally but not exclusively between Floor 2,204 and the damp margin below Spiral 29…

Lower Reading Rooms
Chronic Discrepancy Inertia: how is it conducted?

Chronic Discrepancy Inertia is the measurable resistance offered by a long-standing, formally registered contradiction to its own resolution, correction, or quiet forgetting. It is observed most severely in holdings admi…

Chronic Discrepancy Inertia

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.