The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Dormant Scribe

MS 2499.60 · Practices and doctrines

The Dormant Scribe is a position within the Tower established by Ordinance Gamma-7, Section 12(b), whose sole stated responsibility is the maintenance of a log recording every access request made to a dormant holding, together with the date, the requester, and the disposition of the request, which is invariably that the request is not fulfilled. The position is not a rank and confers no grade within the Scribe Clerical Grade; holders are drawn from the Guild of Dormant Scribes and, on the western benches at least, are generally junior. The Dormant Scribe answers no petition, opens no case, and signs nothing but the log.

The office is frequently confused in ordinary speech with the dormant scribes themselves — that is, with the contained members of scribe orders held in the Dormitory Vaults under the Seventh Concordance Annex Omega Clauses 12 45. The Guild has asked the Register of Dormant Resonances to carry a standing note distinguishing the two, and the note has been standing since Cycle 171.

Origin and wording

Ordinance Gamma-7 was promulgated to settle the classification of holdings kept under the Dormant/Sealed designation. Section 12(b) is short, and its brevity is the source of most subsequent difficulty. It provides that a Dormant Scribe shall keep the access log and that the log shall be maintained "in perpetuity and without interruption of the holding." The phrase without interruption of the holding has been read by every holder of the office as a prohibition on answering.

Under-Scribe Mellis Vant ruled in the same ordinance, at clause 9 as amended, that the slash in Dormant/Sealed denotes a hinge and not a choice. The ruling applies to the classification of holdings and not to the office, but it is cited in nearly every procedural dispute about the office anyway, because clerks find the word hinge useful.

The log in practice

The log is kept at the western annex of Dormant Resonance, in the same room as the Register of Dormant Resonances and at right angles to it, so that a clerk seated between the two may consult one without turning from the other. Entries are made in ink; pencil entries are struck through and re-entered, and the struck entries are retained, which has made the older volumes roughly twice as thick as their page counts suggest.

The position's defining feature is that fulfillment is not available to it. A Dormant Scribe may record that a request was made, by whom, on what floor, and in what terms; the Scribe may note that the request was procedurally sound, that the seal was intact, and that no bar existed. The Scribe may not then act. The Dormant Annotation Phase was devised in part to give such recorded requests somewhere to go, and in part because the Guild could not agree on where else they might go.

A representative entry, from the forty-first volume, reads in full:

"Request of the 17th of Grasses, Cycle 188, to consult the Whispering Atlas under seal at the northern face. Requester declined to give a name and gave instead a description of himself, which was recorded. Seal intact. Request not fulfilled."

— Access Log of the Dormant Scribe, vol. 41, fol. 12

Dispute: the Proceduralist reading

The Proceduralist School holds that the Dormant Scribe is a necessary paradox and not a defect: by documenting every attempt to disturb a dormant holding, the office preserves the integrity of the holding while leaving a full account of the disturbance for whoever eventually reads the log. On this reading the position is doing exactly what it should, and the fact that no request is ever granted is the mechanism and not the malfunction.

The Scribe-Confessor's Guild does not accept this. Its position, set out most fully in its assessment of Latent Intent in dormant petitioners, is that a request recorded and left unfulfilled acquires a kind of standing by being written down, and that the Dormant Scribe thus grants a species of recognition while denying a species of access. The Guild has twice sought amendment of Section 12(b) to require an annual statement from each Dormant Scribe on the intentions of the petitioners in their log. The Guild of Dormant Scribes has twice declined to circulate the amendment, on the ground that the office cannot form views about intentions and would have to record the request for a statement in the log instead.

Incidents

In the winter of Cycle 179 a Dormant Scribe on the western benches, one Harrow Vesk, undertook to answer a request rather than log it. The holding in question, a sealed folio of no great size, was not disturbed and the seal was not broken; Vesk had merely written a letter to the requester explaining why the request could not be granted. The letter was held to constitute fulfillment of a kind, Vesk was removed from the post, and the episode is recorded in the log as an access request by Vesk himself, dated the 3rd of Frost and marked not fulfilled. It remains the only entry in the log concerning a Dormant Scribe.

The Acoustic Scribe Sub-Guild, which records the sound produced by Tympanic Scrolls and is a part of the Guild of Dormant Scribes, has an arrangement with the office whereby the Sub-Guild's recordings made in the western annex are deposited with the log volumes and shelved alongside them. The arrangement is not a Concordance and is renewed by letter every eleven years. The present letters are kept in a tin in the log room. The tin is not to be moved.

Holders and succession

There is no stated term. Holders serve until removed, and removal has occurred four times, three of them for answering. The office is not listed in the rolls of the Scribe-Adjusters, though the Adjusters have twice been asked to inspect the seating in the log room, which is a bench and not adjustable.

Succession is by the outgoing holder's endorsement in the front matter of the current volume. Where no endorsement exists — as after Vesk's removal — the most junior member of the Guild present in the western annex assumes the office, which is how most holders have come to it. The office has never been vacant for longer than a day, a fact the Proceduralist School cites in its favour and the Scribe-Confessors cite as evidence that the position fills itself without scrutiny.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Scribe-Confessor's Guild: who are they?

The Scribe-Confessor's Guild is a now-dormant regulatory and disciplinary body responsible for the oversight and correction of official transcriptions and the administration of penance for scribal error. Its authority de…

Scribe-Confessor's Guild
Scribe-Adjusters: who are they?

Scribe-Adjusters are a subordinate order within the Guild of Spatial Adjusters, constituted to transcribe and simultaneously correct the dimensional record of voids and inter-floor spaces. Unlike the Scribe caste of the …

Scribe-Adjusters
Proceduralist School: how is it conducted?

The Proceduralist School is a formal hermeneutic movement within the larger Literalist tradition, primarily concerned with the exact sequence of actions prescribed within ordinances of process. It holds that the validity…

Proceduralist School
Seventh Concordance Annex Omega Clauses 12 45: how is it conducted?

Seventh Concordance Annex Omega, Clauses 12–45 is the thirty-four-clause block of the Seventh Concordance that authorizes the containment of dormant scribe members within Dormitory Vaults. It is among the most cited pass…

Seventh Concordance Annex Omega Clauses 12 45

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.