The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Determination of Sequence

MS 5474.14 · Practices and doctrines

Definition and scope

Determination of Sequence is a standing instrument of the Sequencers, issued when a Query of Precedence is raised over the order in which two or more holdings are to be read, shelved, or acted upon. It is distinct from Sequencer's Determination 899-b/α and from the frequently misfiled Sequencers Determination 899 Balpha, both of which concern the identity of a holding rather than its position relative to another. The Determination of Sequence does not establish what a thing is; it establishes which of two things comes first, and by how much.

The instrument is numbered in the ordinary Sequencers' series and is binding only within the floor on which it was issued, unless it carries the concurrence of two Librarians, in which case it applies to the stair serving that floor and any landing directly adjacent.

Origins

The practice predates its codification. The earliest surviving example, Determination of Sequence 12, was issued in the winter of 893 T.R. to settle a dispute between the Department of Structural Verifications and the Subcommittee for Transient Biological Annotations over whether a crack in a load-bearing wall on Floor 447 should be inspected before or after the moss growing within it was catalogued. The Sequencers ruled in favour of the crack, on the grounds that the crack had been there longer. The reasoning — that sequence follows duration of presence — was subsequently cited in Determination 44 and has never been formally overturned, though Procedural Determination 87-γ narrowed its application to structural matters only.

The present form of the instrument was fixed by the Routing Determination, which required that every Determination of Sequence specify the two holdings by their full catalogue titles and not by shelfmark, on the grounds that shelfmarks on floors above 1200 are not stable across seasons.

Standing objections

The most persistent challenge to the instrument comes from the office of the Custodians of the Silent Bell, who hold that things heard before they are seen occupy a different ordering entirely. Their position was entered into the record by Determination of Sequence 214, which the Sequencers declined to sign. The resulting impasse was resolved indirectly by Determination 102, which refined the custodial arrangements of the Silent Bell without reference to sequence at all — a manoeuvre that the Syndicate later described as "settling the argument by leaving the room," a remark recorded in the annexes to Determination 188.

A second line of objection holds that sequence is a property of the reader, not the holdings, and that two cataloguers approaching the same shelf will necessarily disagree. This view was advanced most forcefully by the archivist Aris Threnody, whose Determination on Inferred Holdings created the category of Provisional Fact for exactly such cases. Under that category, a disputed sequence may be recorded as provisionally true for the duration of a single consultation and must be re-established on the next.

Procedure of issue

A Query of Precedence is submitted in writing and must identify both holdings, the floor, and the consequence of getting the order wrong. The Sequencers then examine the holdings in situ, in the order proposed by the querent, and again in the reverse order. If the examination produces no difference, the Determination is issued as indifferent, which permits either order but obliges the reader to note which they chose.

Determinations issued as indifferent are the most numerous in the series and the least consulted. Of the 1,406 instruments issued between 900 and 1044 T.R., some 1,112 are of this kind. They are kept in a separate annexe on Floor 88, where the shelving is alphabetical by floor number.

Notable instances

Determination of Sequence 588 (1019 T.R.) ordered that the Omega Sequence be read before any of its own annotations, a ruling that has been criticised as unworkable and defended as merely accurate. Determination of Sequence 631 settled the celebrated Feud of the Two Landings by establishing that a landing belongs to the stairwell it serves, not the stairwell it adjoys; this anticipated the principle later applied in The Vanishing Stairwell Determination (901 T.R.). The Chen Protocol Determination remains the only instrument to have been issued twice with opposite conclusions on the same day, both determinations being valid and neither being revocable.

Relation to other instruments

The Determination of Sequence is subordinate to the Final Determination in all matters where the two conflict, and equal in standing to Sequencer's Determination 899-b/α, with which it is frequently confused. It is also distinct from the Fade Assessment, which concerns the order in which holdings disappear rather than the order in which they are read — a distinction that was the subject of a lengthy concordance dispute in 1031 T.R. and was settled, as most such disputes are, by an amendment that no one subsequently read.

Visitors to Floor 88 should note that the annexe is unheated between the eleventh and second months, and that gloves are provided but not replenished.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Librarians: who are they?

The Librarians are the recognized custodial order of The Tower, vested by the Concordances with the exclusive authority and responsibility for the reception, indexing, and preservation of all holdings admitted to the arc…

Librarians
Procedural Determination 87-γ: what does it set out?

Procedural Determination 87-γ was a seminal ruling issued by the Subcommittee on Procedural Ontology in the winter of 846 T.R., concerning the admissibility of proceedings conducted by bodies whose existence had not yet …

Procedural Determination 87-γ
Department of Structural Verifications: who are they?

The Department of Structural Verifications is the administrative body responsible for the technical assessment, cataloguing, and ongoing certification of the Tower's load-bearing and spatial-defining elements. Its primar…

Department of Structural Verifications
Omega Sequence: how is it conducted?

The Omega Sequence is a procedural designation within the Directorate of Sequence, assigned to any archival operation deemed to require perpetual, self-referential re-evaluation. Once designated, an Omega Sequence become…

Omega Sequence

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.