The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Court of Contradictory Citations

MS 4713.51 · Guilds, orders and offices

The Court of Contradictory Citations is a judicial chamber of the Judiciary of Cross-Reference, constituted to hear appeals arising from the tripartite classification of contradictory citations and to review, at first instance, the shelving determinations issued by the Department of Contradictory Citations. It is not to be confused with the Court of Concordance, which hears matters of amendment, nor with the Court of Ambiguous Precedents, which sits on a lower landing and is not on speaking terms with either. The Court has sat continuously since the winter of the year 1,214, when the first panel convened on a disputed stairwell between the fourth and fifth landings of the Kappa Spiral and was obliged to remain there for eleven weeks.

Jurisdiction

The Court exercises appellate jurisdiction over all matters certified under Contradictory Citations Class Gamma, and concurrent jurisdiction over disputes certified by the Department of Contradictory Citations under Precedent Ω-7/12. Its original docket is smaller and more contentious: it hears challenges to the final shelving of Provisional Concordance Citations where a participating clerk alleges that the shelving was ordered by a clerk sitting in the same wing as the citation itself.

Appeals are lodged by delivery of the disputed folio to the Court's intake desk, which stands open, according to the Concordance of Hours, from the second bell to the fourth. The intake desk was relocated to the north corridor in the year 1,388 after the previous desk was found to occupy the exact site of a former well. Litigants are requested to descend no further than the desk.

Matters it does not hear: petitions for amendment, which are remitted to the Judiciary of Cross-Reference; and any question touching the Vexian School, which is heard only where the Court has first trained a Vexian reader, a practice instituted after the 1,402 sitting in which a clerk read a citation backwards and the Court, for four days, believed the Tower had no fifth floor.

Procedure and the Curing of Citations

The Court's procedure is adversarial in form and citational in substance. Each appeal must be brought with a binding citation identifying the ruling appealed, and a second, contrary citation identifying the ruling that the appellant believes should have been followed. The two are then read aloud together. The Court maintains a standing rule that no citation may be read aloud twice in the same sitting; the rule was introduced in the year 1,377 by Registrar Immerlie Vane, who is recorded as having said:

"The second reading is not evidence of anything. It is only the same citation with the Court's patience subtracted from it."

— Registrar Immerlie Vane, Ruling 12 (Curing of Citations), 1,377

Where the Court determines that a citation has been "cured" — that is, corrected by a subsequent ruling within the same envelope — it may proceed without the appeal. The Curing Register is kept in the east annex, where it is bound in three volumes. Volumes one and two are missing. Volume three is not.

The Feud with the Department

Relations between the Court and the Department of Contradictory Citations have been strained since the Department began treating the Court's rulings as a form of contradictory citation in their own right. The Department's position, set out in its tripartite classification, is that a Court ruling which overturns a ruling of the Court is itself a citation of the first class, and therefore must be filed. The Court has ruled, twice, that the Court is not a document.

The dispute hardened in the year 1,431, when the Department filed a ruling of the Court as a contradictory citation and the Court then filed the Department's filing as a contradictory citation of the citation. The matter was referred to the Department of Contradictory Citations for adjudication, which was obliged to adjudicate its own filing. Its memorandum of the same year records that it "performed the adjudication as a matter of administrative housekeeping, and not as an admission." The Court accepted the result and quietly did not read it.

Ruling No. 2,204 and the Missing Room

The Court's most discussed ruling is No. 2,204, issued in the spring of 1,455, which determined that a room may be cited in the absence of a door. The ruling arose from a dispute in the Kappa Spiral over a chamber recorded between the seventh and eighth landings, which no one could enter and no one could recall entering. The Court held that a citation does not require a door, "a room being a thing in the record before it is a thing in the corridor." The Department of Contradictory Citations subsequently filed the case under Class Delta, a class that did not exist, and was obliged to create it, which it did. The Kappa room remains in the register and remains closed.

Composition and Sittings

The Court sits in panels of three, two of whom are appointed from the Judiciary of Cross-Reference and one from the yard, typically a clerk who has previously been a party to proceedings, as a corrective to the tendency of parties to imagine the Tower is arranged for their convenience. The Court sits on the seventh and eighth landings of the Kappa Spiral, and on the sixth. Since the autumn of 1,468 it has heard no case on the fourth landing, which was found to be a corridor.

Records of the Court are held in the Spiral 94 annex and are available to any clerk with a reading token. The Bureau of Half-Heard Citations transmits a daily summary of the Court's sittings, which has been incomplete every day since 1,441; the Court has ruled that its incompleteness is not a defect of the Court.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Department of Contradictory Citations: who are they?

The Department of Contradictory Citations is the administrative body responsible for the application, registry, and procedural navigation of conflicting provisions within The Concordances. It operates primarily from its …

Department of Contradictory Citations
Court of Silenced Appeals Annex (Spiral 94): where is it?

The Court of Silenced Appeals Annex is a designated administrative extension of the Court of Silenced Appeals occupying an unspecified series of chambers, galleries, and administrative vaults physically adjacent to, yet …

Court of Silenced Appeals Annex (Spiral 94)
Vexian School: how is it conducted?

The Vexian School is an influential hermeneutic faction within the Tower's Department of Contradictory Citations, formally established in Year 211 following the publication of the Arlo Vex Expedition Reports. It is prima…

Vexian School
Precedent Ω-7/12: what does it set out?

Precedent Ω-7/12 is a foundational administrative ruling issued by the Court of Unseen Precedents concerning the permissible categorization of materials exhibiting dual or contradictory properties. It was promulgated on …

Precedent Ω-7/12

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.