Contiguity
MS 2271.27 · Practices and doctrines
Contiguity is the property, in Tower cataloguing, of a floor's being reachable from another floor of the archive without descent through an intervening numbered floor. It is at once a physical description, a legal status, and — under the doctrine of Conceptual Contiguity — a permitted inference. The three uses are not distinguished in ordinary speech and are distinguished with great labour in the record. A floor may be physically contiguous and legally otherwise; it may be legally contiguous on conceptual grounds alone; and, in a small number of surviving cases, it may be contiguous in all respects while no one can demonstrate how one arrives at it.
The governing instrument is the Edict of Contiguity, first issued in CY 884, whose Clause 3 requires that contiguity between any two floors be attested by a Contiguity Survey before inter-floor cataloguing may proceed. The Edict followed the Contiguity Conundrum, a dispute of some eleven years' standing that had arisen when a consignment of meteorological instruments was catalogued on three floors at once and could not afterwards be found on any of them.
The three degrees
Survey practice recognises three degrees of contiguity, set out in the working schedule issued by the Contiguity Surveys office in CY 902 and amended four times since, most recently to accommodate the Incomplete Survey categories.
- Direct contiguity
- The floors are joined by a stair, shaft, or landing requiring no descent through a numbered floor between them. This is the only degree the Edict originally contemplated.
- Conceptual contiguity
- The floors are catalogued in doctrinal affinity with a classified subject. Extended to survey practice by Clause 2 of the Non-Contiguity Clarification.
- Administrative contiguity
- The floors are treated as adjacent because the intervening floor has been struck from the schedule and is no longer numbered. Contested; see below.
A surveyor recording the third degree is required to note the struck floor's former number in the margin. Where the former number is unknown, or where it has since been reissued to a different floor under the arrangements described in Non Sequential Floor Numbers, the margin is to be ruled through and initialled.
The Conundrum and the adjacent intent
The Contiguity Conundrum turned on whether proximity of intent could substitute for proximity of stone. The Office of Spatial Reconciliation, called in as arbiter in CY 879, declined to answer the question directly and instead consolidated the position of the Continuity Over Contiguity faction, which held that physical adjacency on the shelf mattered more than unbroken historical custody. The faction's opponents, the Continuity Faction, held the reverse and were never formally defeated.
The reconciliation of these positions is the doctrine of adjacent intent, by which two floors are contiguous if the cataloguer intended them to be, provided the intention was recorded before the shelving was done. This has been criticised as reversing the ordinary order of evidence. Librarian Avens of the Ninth Recension put the objection thus:
"To intend adjacency and then to build it is survey. To build and then to intend it is decoration."
— Avens of the Ninth Recension, marginalia to the Edict of Contiguity, CY 886
Avens' note is preserved in the working copy but was not carried into the fair text, and the doctrine stands.
The Contiguity Crisis of 112
The most serious dislocation in the history of the property occurred in CY 112, when a routine reshelving created a chain of attested adjacencies that returned to its own starting floor by a route of nine steps. The Crisis is treated at its own holding; for present purposes it established that contiguity is not transitive. Two floors contiguous to a third need not be contiguous to each other, and the assumption that they are is now recorded as an error of the first order.
The survey forms were amended accordingly. Under Subclause 9.1: Contiguity Surveys, a surveyor must lodge triplicate copies of Form 9.1-Δ with the Contiguity Surveys office for a survey to be regularized, and the form now carries a check-box by which the surveyor affirms that the route described does not close upon itself. The box was added in CY 114 and, in the first year of its use, was left unchecked in one hundred and six returns, all of which were nonetheless regularized.
Disagreement in the Concordances
The Non-Contiguity Clarification, informally so called, is Concordance 1012-γ. Its Clause 2 extends conceptual contiguity to survey practice; its Clause 5, less often cited, provides that a floor found non-contiguous remains so until a contrary survey is lodged and that no lapse of time cures the defect. The Concordance 1007-β holds the reverse in a single sentence, and has never been repealed.
The two have been read together since CY 1041, when the Office of Spatial Reconciliation ruled that they were to be applied in the order most convenient to the matter in hand — a ruling which the office has since described, in an internal minute of CY 1058, as "a settlement rather than a resolution." Surveyors navigating the discrepancy customarily refer the return upward and mark the floor provisionally adjacent pending instruction.
Related phenomena and a note on practice
Contiguity is sometimes confused with vertical sonic contiguity, the condition in which two floors are treated as adjacent because each can hear work being done on the other. The two are distinct and the distinction matters: sonic contiguity may obtain between floors separated by an intervening floor, which ordinary contiguity expressly excludes.
Two further usages deserve note. An Intermittent Auxiliary is a stair or lift that maintains contiguity for part of the cycle only; its returns are filed separately from those of the Interim Auxiliary, which maintains contiguity throughout but has not been formally dedicated. The difference between them is one of intent, not mechanism, and is invisible to the traveller.
Surveyors are reminded that the survey is of the route, not of the destination, and that a survey describing a floor that has since been renumbered is to be returned rather than corrected. Boots are to be removed at the fourth landing of the eastern spiral; the boards were replaced in CY 1077 and are not to be walked on wet.
See also
-
MS 0791.39
Article II: The Phenomenological Sequence
Article II: The Phenomenological Sequence is the second numbered instrument of the Concordance of Foundational Articles and the pr…
-
MS 9950.55
Auto-Contradictory Items
Auto-Contradictory Items are holdings whose catalogue entry, physical description, or certified condition is internally inconsiste…
-
MS 9010.21
Apical Mechanics
Apical Mechanics is the branch of the Tower's physical philosophy concerned with the behaviour of structures, forces, and measurem…
-
MS 4729.55
The Principle of Latent Fidelity
The Principle of Latent Fidelity is the doctrine holding that a catalogue holding's truthfulness is not a property of its recorded…
-
MS 4914.00
Archive of Theoretical Sounds
The Archive of Theoretical Sounds is a specialized, non-contiguous repository within the Tower dedicated to the cataloguing, forma…
-
MS 9584.02
Clause 5 (Phenomenological Description)
Clause 5 (Phenomenological Description) refers to a specific rule within the Thirteenth Concordance, defining the standards and ma…
Referenced by
- MS 7920.37 Atmospheric Calibration
Readers also asked
Continuity Over Contiguity: how is it conducted?
Continuity Over Contiguity is the interpretive doctrine holding that where a stairwell, corridor, duct, or other thoroughfare is found to be continuous along its own length, that continuity is sufficient ground for inter…
Continuity Over ContiguityIncomplete Surveys: how is it conducted?
Incomplete Surveys is the collective designation for a class of survey returns held by the Contiguity Surveys office in which the surveyor's route, inventory, or both are recorded as having terminated before the survey's…
Incomplete SurveysOffice of Spatial Reconciliation: who are they?
The Office of Spatial Reconciliation (designation OSR-) is the administrative body tasked with the verification, calibration, and doctrinal enforcement of spatial contiguity within the Tower’s non-cartographic volumes. E…
Office of Spatial ReconciliationInterim Auxiliary: how is it conducted?
The Interim Auxiliary is any bureau, office, or sub-committee established by provisional order to manage a situation of unstable contiguity, dimensional paradox, or procedural anomaly, pending a final determination by th…
Interim AuxiliaryPassages cited from this record
-
To intend adjacency and then to build it is survey. To build and then to intend it is decoration.
Avens of the Ninth Recension, marginalia to the Edict of Contiguity, CY 886
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 4179.01 Contiguity Survey
- MS 6846.56 Contiguity Conundrum
- MS 6649.11 Concordance 1007-β
- MS 7979.71 Contiguity Surveys
Because you consulted