The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Non-Contiguity Clarification

MS 1434.28 · Documents and ordinances

The Non-Contiguity Clarification is the informal designation of Concordance 1012-γ, issued by the Office of Spatial Reconciliation in CY 901 to settle the class of disputes arising from floors that could be reached in sequence but could not be shown to be adjacent. Formally titled On the Standing of Floors Reached Without Adjacency, the Clarification established that arrival constitutes a recordable fact independent of the route by which arrival occurred, and it remains the principal instrument by which the Tower's survey corps justifies the inclusion of physically unreachable holdings in good standing. It is the third and shortest of the Reconciliation texts, running to eleven folios, of which nine are annexes.

Background: the Hasp Question

The Clarification arose from a dispute concerning the eastern stair of Floor 2204, where a landing door was fitted with a hasp but no lock. Contiguity Surveyors filing under Subclause 9.1: Contiguity Surveys could ascend the stair and record the landing, but could not attest entry, since entry required an act of opening and the hasp had no key and no latch. The Subclause requires attestation that "a floor may be reached from another without descent through an intervening numbered floor," and the surveyors held, reasonably, that a landing one cannot enter is not reached. Three successive survey teams recorded Floor 2204 as contiguous; a fourth, under Surveyor Maren Ostleth, recorded it as non-contiguous and was suspended pending review. Her suspension file ran to four hundred pages and is preserved in the annexe to the Clarification, where it is cited more often than the ruling itself.

Ostleth's argument before the Office was that the hasp's presence implied a door, the door's presence implied a floor behind it, and the floor behind it was therefore administratively real whether or not anyone had been through. The Office found for her on the narrow ground that the surveyors had in fact recorded the landing's dimensions, and that a landing whose dimensions can be recorded has been, in the language of the ruling, "reached to the extent that measurement permits."

Principal Provisions

The Clarification's operative clauses are three. Clause 1 separates the fact of arrival from the means of arrival, holding that "the Tower shall not be required to account for the route by which a thing is known, only for the knowing of it" (Clarification 1012-γ, Clause 1). Clause 2 extends the doctrine of conceptual contiguity from its original application in cataloguing to survey practice at large, permitting a survey to be sustained on doctrinal affinity where physical adjacency cannot be shown. Clause 3, which the Office added at the last reading, provides that a floor recorded under Clauses 1 or 2 shall be marked with an aperture notation and shall not thereafter be entered by ladder.

"A floor reached by any means is reached; a floor reached by no means is recorded as awaiting reach, which is a standing and not a defect."

— Clarification 1012-γ, Clause 1

The nine annexes are largely devoted to worked examples. Annex 4 concerns the hasp directly and concludes, after considerable argument, that a hasp without a lock is a fitting and not a barrier. Annex 7 addresses floors reached by sound, and is not generally relied upon.

Relation to the Edict of Contiguity

The Clarification does not amend the Edict of Contiguity, and this is a persistent source of confusion. Clause 3 of the Edict continues to require a Contiguity Survey attesting adjacency, while the Clarification permits a survey to stand without one. The Office of Spatial Reconciliation has never reconciled the two texts, and the received position — stated in the Office's own preface to the 908 recension — is that the Edict governs what may be catalogued and the Clarification governs what may be believed. Practitioners generally file both.

The opposition is older than the Clarification. The Continuity Over Contiguity school holds that physical adjacency on the shelf ought to prevail over any derived relation, and its partisans have twice attempted to have Clause 2 struck. The second attempt, in the winter of CY 917, failed by a single vote of the Committee after a member was detained on Floor 3311 by a non-contiguous landing and could not be returned in time to vote against it. The episode is recorded without comment in the Committee's minutes and is much cited by both sides.

Criticism and the Belhaven Reading

The most substantial challenge to the Clarification came from Librarian Cort Belhaven, who observed in a private memorandum of CY 913 that Clause 1, taken at its plain meaning, would permit any floor to be certified provided someone had once described it. Belhaven did not publish. His memorandum was found among his effects and printed posthumously as an appendix to the Contextual Clarification Bulletins, where it has been read as either a reductio or a proposal, depending on the reader. The Office has not responded to it, and the practice of certifying floors by description alone has grown steadily in the decades since.

Modern surveyors distinguish the Belhaven reading from the ruling itself by holding that a description must be of a specific floor and not of floors in general. The distinction has not been tested.

Effects in Practice

Holdings recorded under the Clarification are marked in the catalogue with the aperture notation γ, which is not to be confused with the floor-numbering convention of the same letter. The notation carries no privileges except that a γ-marked floor is not required to appear on any route map, and a referent may not demand that a reader be conducted to it. In practice most readers never do.

Since CY 901 the Clarification has grown from a procedural note into a body of practice. Floors 2204, 3311 and a further hundred and six numbered holdings stand in the catalogue on the Clarification's authority alone, several of them described in detail by clerks who have not been to them. Annual maintenance of γ-marked floors is suspended. The Office's standing instruction is that a γ-marked floor is to be left as described.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Continuity Over Contiguity: how is it conducted?

Continuity Over Contiguity is the interpretive doctrine holding that where a stairwell, corridor, duct, or other thoroughfare is found to be continuous along its own length, that continuity is sufficient ground for inter…

Continuity Over Contiguity
Office of Spatial Reconciliation: who are they?

The Office of Spatial Reconciliation (designation OSR-) is the administrative body tasked with the verification, calibration, and doctrinal enforcement of spatial contiguity within the Tower’s non-cartographic volumes. E…

Office of Spatial Reconciliation
Subclause 9.1: Contiguity Surveys: how is it conducted?

Subclause 9.1: Contiguity Surveys is the operative provision of Concordance 11, Clause 9, governing the examination of newly accessioned unrealities for doctrinal affinity with holdings already classified elsewhere in th…

Subclause 9.1: Contiguity Surveys
Edict of Contiguity: what does it set out?

Edict of Contiguity is the customary name for the consolidated ruling issued in CY 884 by the Office of Spatial Reconciliation, whereby the conditions under which two non-adjacent floors may be recorded as contiguous for…

Edict of Contiguity

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.