The Tower
Cited by 12 Concordances Compliant with Ordinance 4 Surveyed — partially ISO 8,812 — pending since 11,904

Concordance 255

MS 9461.92 · Documents and ordinances

Concordance 255

Concordance 255 is a single-leaf instrument of the Concordance series, held under seal in the Ninth Scriptorium and catalogued at Floor 187, whose name — Read Just Past — was assigned to it four days after the leaf's arrival. It is, by its own opening clause, "an instrument of no antecedent," meaning that it supersedes nothing and derives from nothing, and it is the only instrument in the sequence to make that claim in the first line rather than bury it in an annex. Its principal function, as amended, is the assignment of precedence when two breaches of the Concordances occur in the same stairwell within the same hour.

The leaf measures 41 by 29 centimetres and is composed in two hands. Its first nineteen lines are the work of the clerk Ansel of the Third Landing, whose hand is otherwise known chiefly from the Second Concordance and from a collection of dunning letters whose recipients are not recorded. The remaining eleven lines were added, at a later date and in a hard angular hand, by an amending officer signing only as D. The two hands do not agree on the year, and neither of them is wrong.

Content and operation

Concordance 255 sets out what it calls the rule of the nearer tread. Where two breaches occur simultaneously in one stairwell, the breach occurring lower on the tread governs; where the two occur on the same tread, the breach with the earlier seal governs; where both seal and tread are equal, the matter is to be referred to the Concordance Reconciliation desk, which will consult Concordance 244 and, if that instrument proves unhelpful, will not say so.

The rule was applied for the first time in the winter following its sealing, in a dispute between the Guild of Sealsmen and the Wardens of the Western Stair, the former claiming that a seal had been affixed to the wrong riser and the latter claiming that the riser in question belonged to no stairway and was therefore not subject to the rule at all. The Reconciliation desk found for the Sealsmen on the ground that the riser, whatever its status, was lower than the alternative riser, and the Wardens were thereafter instructed to number their risers separately from their treads, a practice they maintain.

"Where two breaches stand level in all particulars, the desk shall not choose between them but shall set both aside, and shall mark the place where they were set aside, so that it may be found again if the need arises, which it will."

— Concordance 255, clause 24, hand of D.

The marking of the place where breaches are set aside is done in chalk. The chalk is supplied by the Office of Chalk and Twine at a standard allocation of one and a half sticks per desk per quarter; the half stick is not a fraction of a stick but a stick of shorter manufacture, and the distinction has been litigated.

The supersession question

There is no scholarly agreement on whether Concordance 255 has been superseded. The difficulty arises from its opening disclaimer. By declaring itself of no antecedent, the instrument made itself unaddressable by the ordinary machinery of supersession, which operates by naming the instrument to be replaced. Later instruments have accordingly named Concordance 255 and been read by some as having replaced it, and by others as having merely attempted to replace something the text insists was never there to replace.

The Third Annex of the Third Concordance addresses the question without resolving it, noting at clause 9 that "the leaf at 187 is superseded or it is not; the Annex takes no view." The Fifteenth Concordance is more direct and less useful: it lists Concordance 255 among instruments "enjoying the presumption of continuance," a category otherwise reserved for instruments whose text has been lost. The text of 255 has not been lost. It is at Floor 187. It is read there most weeks.

A minority position, associated with the cataloguer Mira of the Fourth Gallery, holds that Concordance 255 was superseded twice and that both supersessions lapsed, producing the present state in which the instrument is simultaneously in force and not in force depending on which door of the Scriptorium the reader entered by. The Ninth Scriptorium has two doors. The position has not been refuted.

Relation to the wider series

Concordance 255 cross-references Concordance 7 twice and Concordance 33 not at all, a reticence noted unfavourably by the compilers of the Concordance Amendment Tracking register, who observe that an instrument cross-referencing 7 without citing 33 is, in their phrase, "walking the stair with one hand." It is silent on the Twenty-Second Concordance, whose amendments arrived in the same decade and whose formulations on precedence are close enough to 255's to suggest a shared drafter, though the hands differ. It makes no reference to Concordance Zero, and the omission is considered deliberate; the Office of Antecedents has ruled that the omission "does not constitute an antecedent," which settled nothing.

Copies of the leaf are held at Floors 187, 402, and 611. The copy at Floor 611 is considered the most faithful, having been made by a scribe who could not read and who therefore copied the corrections as well as the text, including a marginal note reading "not this word," which appears in the 611 copy as the word "not."

Access

The original may be consulted on written application to the Ninth Scriptorium. Readers are admitted by the north door only; the south door has been sealed since the winter of the riser dispute and is not to be used, discussed, or leaned upon.

See also

Referenced by

Readers also asked

Fifteenth Concordance: what does it set out?

The Fifteenth Concordance (official designation: Concordance XV) is a superseded legislative and administrative document of the Tower, formally invalidated in its entirety by the ratification of the Sixteenth Concordance…

Fifteenth Concordance
Concordance 244: what does it set out?

Concordance 244 is a single-leaf instrument of the reconciliation class, held in the Aperture 12 bindery and consulted almost exclusively by parties who have already lost an argument about something else. It is not a lon…

Concordance 244
Concordance 33: what does it set out?

Concordance 33, titled Provisions Regarding the Documentation of Temporary Systems and Ephemeral Processes, is a collection of governance amendments, procedural stipulations, and operational clarifications formally enact…

Concordance 33
Concordance 7: what does it set out?

Concordance 7, also historically referred to as the Seventh Concordance, is a foundational administrative document governing the preliminary classification and provisional shelving of holdings prior to their full integra…

Concordance 7

Passages cited from this record

Readers who consulted this also failed to find

Assistance

A Librarian is with you.

MS 9679.39
MS 8532.92
MS 1913.80

The Librarian considers the matter closed.

Typical response time: one Concordance. If your enquiry concerns a holding, consult the finding aid.