Clause 9.1.6
MS 3216.74 · Documents and ordinances
Clause 9.1.6 is a subordinate provision of the Ninth Recension, lodged between Clause 9.1.5 and Clause 9.1.7, concerning the proper custody of objects that have been catalogued as absent. It was first inscribed on Floor 4,412 during the sixty-third winter of the Office of Clause Nomenclature and has since occasioned fourteen recorded disputes, two sealings, and one unexplained transfer to Sub-clause 9.β.
Text and Attribution
The received reading of Clause 9.1.6, as preserved in the Seventh Concordance, Clause 4, states: "That which is logged as not present shall be stored in the drawer marked not present, and the drawer shall be counted as full." The Office of Clause Nomenclature has upheld that this formulation supersedes the earlier marginal note found in Clause 7.8, wherein the same drawer is described as "awaiting." The discrepancy was ruled non-binding by the Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1, on the grounds that a drawer cannot await and be counted simultaneously.
"The catalogue of absences is itself complete; the drawer is therefore never empty, even when opened."
— Clause 812, recension of the Lower Scriptoria
Administration and the Drawers
Custody of the not-present drawer falls to the Wardens of the Ninth Spiral, a body whose membership roster has not been amended since the inscription of Clause 18.7. The Wardens are required by Clause 7.3 to report the fullness of the drawer quarterly to the Office of Clause Nomenclature, though the report for the winter of Floor 4,412 has been missing since its anticipated submission in the year of the long stair.
In practice the drawer is housed on Floor 2,017, in a recess to the archive of Clause 11.γ. A visiting clerk may observe the drawer only through the aperture prescribed by Annex Alpha, and may not request its contents, as the contents are defined by their absence. The Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1 further prohibits the placing of labels upon the drawer, on the reasoning that a label would imply a thing to be labelled.
Dispute with Clause 7 and Clause 19
Clause 9.1.6 has been drawn into the long impasse regarding Clause 44.8. Where Clause 7 reaches an impasse regarding Clause 44.8 by the same route as Clause 19, the question of whether an absent object retains precedence under Clause 1 has divided the scriptoria. Clause 7.03 holds that absence is a form of presence for purposes of storage; Clause 7.1.5 denies this, citing the operative principles of Clause IX, including Clause IX.2, which Clause 19 lays the philosophical groundwork for.
The Duration and Review Clause attempted to settle the matter by temporary merger of the drawer with the holdings of Clause D.5, but the merger was voided under Clause 4.11.γ when the Office of Clause Nomenclature ruled that a missing object cannot be merged with a described one. The Seventh Concordance, Clause 4 has not been amended to reflect the voiding, and clerks continue to cite it.
Scholarly Disagreement
The principal disagreement concerns whether Clause 9.1.6 answers to Clause 7.17, the terminal sub-clause of Clause 7, or stands independent under the Ninth Recension. The Seventh Concordance, Clause 4 implies dependence; the Clause 812 asserts independence on the authority of Clause I, which the Office of Clause Nomenclature has ruled distinct from Clause i. The late clerk Erasmin of the Lower Apertures argued in his bound dissent that the drawer's fullness is a measurement error, not a state, and that Clause 7.8 should govern. His dissent was sealed under Clause 7.3 and has not been opened owing to a missing key recorded as absent in the drawer itself.
Incidents and Notes
During the winter of Floor 4,412, a junior Warden of the Ninth Spiral attempted to count the drawer's contents and produced a figure of zero, which was rejected by the Office of Clause Nomenclature as contradicting the plain text of Clause 9.1.6. The Warden was reassigned to the maintenance of Clause 18.7 and is recorded as having raised no objection.
A visitor may not bring a personal drawer to Floor 2,017, as this has been found to confuse the aperture prescribed by Annex Alpha.
The Clause 7.03 recension notes that the transfer of Clause 9.1.6 to Sub-clause 9.β in the year of the closed ledger was reversed within nine days by the Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1, for reasons that the annex does not state and the Office of Clause Nomenclature has declined to supplement.
See also
-
MS 7925.84
Concordance 3, Clause 405
Concordance 3, Clause 405 is a provision of the Third Concordance concerning the custody, recitation, and eventual interment of ca…
-
MS 2911.99
War of the Margins
War of the Margins was a protracted jurisdictional conflict (circa the 41st Recension) concerning the proper boundary between cata…
-
MS 6516.46
Clause D.3
Clause D.3 is a subordinate provision of the Duration and Review Clause, governing what the Tower's records describe as "the stand…
-
MS 8006.42
Spiral 30
Spiral 30 is a subordinate archival spiral of the Spiral Sectors, designated Spiral Λ in the Spiral Concordance, and is catalogued…
-
MS 0157.50
Bureau of Proleptic Archives
Bureau of Proleptic Archives is the administrative body charged with the custody, recension, and anticipatory cataloguing of mater…
-
MS 8282.64
Clause 14(b)
Clause 14(b) is a subordinate provision of Clause 14, held in the Seventh Recension of the Seventh Concordance and administered jo…
Referenced by
- MS 3025.52 Clause 9
- MS 9699.51 Clause D.1
- MS 7548.72 Clause D.4
- MS 1345.47 Office of Clause Nomenclature
Readers also asked
Ninth Spiral: where is it?
The Ninth Spiral (officially designated Spiral the Ninth, Aperture Gamma) is a specific helical corridor connecting floors 714 through 832, and is chiefly remembered as the period of administrative upheaval and accelerat…
Ninth SpiralClause 11.γ: how is it conducted?
Clause 11.γ is the designation reserved, under the standing nomenclature of the Office of Clause Nomenclature, for a clause that has not yet been written. It is not a vacant number in the ordinary sense: the Office maint…
Clause 11.γSeventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1: what does it set out?
The full text of Clause 1 reads:
Seventh Concordance, Annex D, Clause 1Clause 7.1.5: what does it set out?
Clause 7.1.5 is a procedural sub-clause within Clause 7 of the Tower’s administrative Concordances. It concerns the classification and disposition of inferred holdings—catalogued items whose existence is deduced solely f…
Clause 7.1.5Passages cited from this record
-
The catalogue of absences is itself complete; the drawer is therefore never empty, even when opened.
Clause 812, recension of the Lower Scriptoria
Readers who consulted this also failed to find
- MS 6231.49 Erasmin of the Lower Apertures
- MS 1984.09 Clause 9.1.7
- MS 0042.26 Floor 2,017
- MS 5520.17 Clause 9.1.5
Because you consulted